Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Higher education is not a market place

The highly contentious British student loans system is unravelling. Many predicted that it would, but the surprise, given its high profile and political toxicity, is that it is falling apart so fast: hopelessly flawed, it seems to be falling under its own weight.

Government has revealed that the write-off costs have reached 45% of the £10-billion in student loans made each year, all but nullifying any savings to the public purse made by the new fee system. 

They started out with a £3 000 loan ceiling, which in fact became the norm. Then they hiked it up to £9 000, the better to lift the burden from the treasury and to give Britain — in the jargon beloved by ministers — world-class universities enabling it to compete in the global race.

What is actually happening seems very different, as the parliamentary admissions concede that the resource accounting and budgeting charge‚ indicating the level of likely default, is fast approaching the 48.6% mark. 

At that point, experts say, the government will lose more money than it would have saved by keeping the old £3 000 cap. 

There is simple economics here; too many graduates chasing too few jobs in a labour market slimmed down by government austerity measures. 

Many who have taken out the loans can't find jobs, so they don't pay, but those who do find employment are paid so little in an over-supplied market that they don't reach the threshold at which they have to pay. And, of course, those who can will arrange their affairs so that whether or not they become eligible to pay never becomes apparent. The market is a harsh place. Consumers soon tell you if the pricing policy is wrong.

But there shouldn't be such an aggressive pricing policy here at all. What we see are the sorry effects of incompetently applying crude market theory to higher education. 

This government never saw a social activity it didn't think could be improved by exposure to market forces. That is its philosophical default position. 

But marketising activity essential to the social fabric doesn't always work in practice. Markets are mechanical. They are incapable of making social and moral judgments. Politicians are supposed to control the markets to extract the best outcomes for society. But, in fact, the markets control our politicians.

Unpaid loans
There are many criticisms to be made and here are two: consider the damage to the public finances so far. On the basis of prices we have ourselves inflated, we pay £10-billion a year in loans. By 2042, £90-billion of the overall £200-billion in student loans will remain unpaid. That's a lot of schools, hospitals, rail lines, houses. 

But also think of this; we are not long past the crash, probably the biggest global catastrophe of our age, caused by credit and debt and by the inability of people to understand the connection between virtual money they have never seen and real-life spending. The lesson we were told to draw from that was never again to get comfortable with unseen money and excess debts. 

But, at the same time, we have sought to instil in a generation that living with debt is no big problem. It's not much, we tell them. You'll hardly notice. Oh, and by the way, why don't you also take out a mortgage?

Credit to them that so many see this for the sophistry that it is, for the whole debacle once again flags up a simple truth. 

Education is a communal good, an economic necessity and a collective responsibility too important to be hived off to the markets. For the finance and organisation of such things, above other fripperies, we pay tax. — © Guardian News and Media 2014

Hugh Muir is the Guardian's diary editor

Subscribe for R500/year

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and get a 57% discount in your first year.

Related stories


If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Subscribers only

South Africa’s mothballed ‘supermall-ification’ sets strip malls up for success

Analysts agree that the country has enough malls and that, post-Covid, the convenience of local centres lure customers

Mabuza’s Russian jaunts and the slippery consequences of medical tourism

For more than five years the deputy president has remained steadfast in his right to travel abroad to receive medical treatment

More top stories

Deputy president Mabuza begs Tshwane voters: ‘Don’t abandon the ANC’

Angry Atteridgeville residents hurl insults at ‘dysfunctional’ ANC full of ‘corrupt individuals’ as Mabuza fails to placate them with party T-shirts and doeks

Taxi operators clash with cops over disputed Route B97 in...

Three suspects remain in custody following their arrest on charges of attempted murder and assault after eight taxis were impounded

SA teens, you’re next in the queue for a vaccine...

Teenagers between the ages of 12 and 17 will be able to register to receive their Covid-19 jab from 20 October. This group will be given only one dose of the Pfizer vaccine, for now

Former US secretary of state Colin Powell dies aged 84

The 84-year-old died as a result of complications from Covid-19

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…