Time to look north as Super Rugby keeps dropping ball

While the Stormers and the Bulls tussle to win the South African Super Rugby conference, no matter how ugly they look doing it, a storm is brewing off the field.

Oregan Hoskins, the normally self-contained president of the South African Rugby Union (Saru), has had enough of inconsistent judiciary rulings.

And, quite remarkably, Hoskins has described himself as at his wits’ end after the heavy punishments meted out to Sharks bully boys Bismarck du Plessis, Jean Deysel and Francois Steyn, yet chokeholds by the likes of Liam Messam, a knee to the head by Hurricanes lock James Broadhurst and multiple red cards for James Horwill of the Reds either went unpunished or were met with a mere one-week ban.

This week, Force scrumhalf Ian Prior received a scant three-week ban for a horrific tip tackle that was late and well after the whistle.

What has particularly irked Hoskins is that Steyn’s initial lack of punishment was appealed by Sanzar, whereas no other decision has apparently met this murky threshold for a governing body appeal against its own judicial officer. And now Hoskins is determined to get to the bottom of this.

Almost burned itself out
To be honest, Hoskins’s comments have barely made news because the inconsistency has been going on so long that discussion of it, akin to a Clinton scandal in the United States, has almost burned itself out. There is almost no media oxygen left for any meaningful discussion to take place.

Perhaps the reason for Hoskins’s frustration is that he is finally realising what has long been obvious to any dispassionate observer – New Zealand and Australia take their African partner for granted.

We provide the bulk of Super Rugby’s audience, exhaust our players with incessant touring, put up with the conference system and then receive the short end of the stick in almost every facet of tournament decision-making.

To be sure, the inconsistency does not excuse some of the thuggishness of our players. For some reason, there is a certain brand of South African player that explodes when sufficiently needled. It has something to do with the rather bizarre fervour with which we play and support the game.

For example, no New Zealand team runs out in numbered order, nor do they form the team huddles on the field that so many South African teams use to get themselves into the frenzy that is apparently required to play the South African way.

But all that does not alter Hoskins’s point. Wrong-headedness needs to be punished fairly on both sides of the Indian Ocean.

The fact that this does not seem possible in the current Sanzar set-up, in which there is no acknowledgement that there even is a problem, is symptomatic of the wider fracturing of what used to be a highly beneficial partnership.

Super Rugby was once the greatest rugby tournament on Earth. Supporters would wake up early on weekend mornings to catch the old Australasian afternoon games in our predawn hour. It is probably a good thing all the overseas games are now played at night.

Killed the old romance
The fact is the conference system and endless expansion has killed the old romance. Super Rugby is now a poor man’s National Football League – a behemoth tournament that has no Super Bowl.

It is time to look north.

Australasia’s natural allies will soon be Japan and the South Pacific islands.

In the television age, it makes little sense to divide the rugby world into north and south, and thus partner with countries across wide time zones. It is also probably fair to say our rugby culture has more in common with the northern nations than Australia and New Zealand.

Even more crucially, the northern hemisphere nations have been able to create an entertaining European Cup and still maintain the prestige of the French Top 14 and the English Premiership.

Neither Australia nor New Zealand has meaningful internal domestic competitions and so we have allowed the incessant derbies of the Super Rugby conference system to devalue our Currie Cup.

Super Rugby has always been slightly disjointed in this fashion – most big team sports tend to aim to preserve the local competition while internationalising their sport in the form of a champions’ league. We have done the opposite.

Reversing this should be the aim of our administrators. South African rugby needs a strong Currie Cup that can be linked with a “central hemisphere super-league” of sorts.

Obviously this may cost Saru money. But it is becoming increasingly obvious that Super Rugby has some serious long-term issues – of which the judiciary is but one of the symptoms.

Changing course now may be the only way of ensuring our local game does not go the way of domestic cricket – into irrelevance.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories

Lala kahle Kaunda Ntunja

South African rugby has lost a gentle giant in Kaunda Ntunja. His commentary in isiXhosa poetically ushered in the Springboks’ first black captain and ‘popped champagne’ after Mapimpi’s magic

How Schalk Brits built his fantasy

The Springbok hooker built his long career on his ability to adapt — and will likely do so again now that he’s finally retired from rugby

Sport audit 2019: How SA’s national rugby team performed

The highlight of South Africa's year was the Springboks Rugby World Cup victory

Rennie: All Blacks left it too late to offer me coach job

New Zealand has said its new coaching team will be named before Christmas, but it has now missed out on at least three high-profile candidates

EDITORIAL: Sport is for the people

Administrators, from club to national level, would do well to take the example set this month as a reminder that the people is their primary mandate

Boks speedo up against cancer

Faf de Klerk captained the challenge to team mates and other men to get themselves screened

Treasury presents Covid-19 corruption action plan

Reports of corruption, over-pricing and the delivery of sub-standard PPE have become the norm over the past five months as the country grapples with the Covid-19 pandemic

Metro cops, SAPS clash over control

Tensions between the City of Cape Town and the police service over responsibilities mirrors the strain between national and local government

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday