Letters to the editor: June 5 to 11 2015

Judge morals, not race

Jacob Zuma’s mimicking of a white accent in the pronunciation of “Nkandla” was unacceptable. And this was after a statement by Kgalema Motlanthe to the effect that the ANC caucus is treating opposition parties in a rough and inappropriate manner, something that has not happened since 1994 (Animal Farm has nothing on Nkandla briefing).

The ANC clapped hands in full view of TV cameras and viewers. It tells us something of the character, political maturity and standard of political education of these MPs. Both Zuma and the man who was once an ally, Julius Malema, use witgevaar to advance the so-called national democratic revolution.

White people such as Denis Goldberg, Harold Wolpe, Rick Turner, Anton Lubowski, Ruth First, Beyers Naudé, Barbara Hogan and Marion Sparg fought and some of them died for us to be free. Helen Suzman, Frederick van Zyl Slabbert and those who went to Dakar to meet the ANC also contributed.

Ben Turok, Raymond Suttner, Ronnie Kasrils and other stalwarts of the struggle such as Jay Naidoo and unionists such as Zwelinzima Vavi and Irvin Jim, to name a few, are vocal in their protestations against the looting.

It is not a white race matter, it’s about morals, ethics and good governance.

Cyril Ramaphosa tried to bring calm to Parliament, but before the ink had dried, the president invited chaos and embarrassment into the august house.

It is in this Parliament that he revealed the “security reasons” why his wife’s tuck shop had to be built for R500 000. Later, he said he was not aware of these upgrades. – Delisile Nhlumayo, Secunda


Stick to the provable facts on shootings

David Bruce (Top policeman touts his own agenda) is selective in his response to the points I raised a week earlier. He tries to obfuscate the discussion by introducing more statistics and, again, relies on a subjective interpretation of events. For example, there is no empirical evidence to prove correlation between utterances by politicians or others and an increase in police shootings.

He refers to “evidence against the unit” but fails to elaborate what it is; relying on an interview five years ago with an Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) member. I am privy to all the “evidence”. I invite Bruce to become familiar with it too. It is irresponsible to rely on unstructured interviews and statements to reach conclusions.

In addition, an IPID member who testified in my hearing, was caught lying and refused to be cross-examined. Her evidence was rejected. This witness resigned from IPID shortly after the start of an internal disciplinary hearing into her conduct.

Bruce advances reasons why the case against the “Cato Manor unit” may fail. If the prosecution succeeds, his imputations will be proven. If not, blame instability in IPID, Hawks and the National Director of Public Prosecutions. Has it occurred to him the members may be innocent?

Accusing me of having an agenda is insulting. The only agenda proven was discerned by the independent chairman in my hearing. Advocate Nazeer Cassim ruled I was a victim of an agenda to get rid of me. That deputy national director of public prosecutions Nomgcobo Jiba faces criminal charges for unlawfully authorising my prosecution indicates sinister elements. I share Bruce’s concerns about the police’s excessive use of force. But it’s incumbent on him as a researcher not to unscientifically conflate diverse issues. He should stick to empirically proven theories. – Major General Johan W Booysen, Amanzimtoti

Editor’s note: This correspondence is now closed.


Stop District Six whites’ re-eviction

Your journalist Daneel Knoetze (Cape’s eviction history repeats itself in the name of money) is the first person in a third of a century to remind us that the dozen whites remaining in District Six were also evicted under apartheid – even if, in their case, they were relocated not a dozen kilometres away but only 1km, to the flats on De Waal Drive.

Your journalist should urge the septuagenarians Judith and Ralph Pace to also register with the District Six trust as evictees. They are unlikely to read your newspaper, nor to know which legal and bureaucratic steps to take.

It would be bizarre if, precisely when coloured and African claimants are returning to District Six housing, the few white evictees are evicted for the second time, instead of being reintegrated. It would be a double irony if this re-eviction is at the hands of the Democratic Alliance Western Cape government.

Similarly, Fuad Isaacs (54) should be urged to approach the District Six trust as an undocumented evictee of apartheid. – Keith Gottschalk, Cape Town

Keep the powerful accountable

Subscribe for R30/mth for the first three months. Cancel anytime.

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.

Related stories

WELCOME TO YOUR M&G

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

Advertising

Latest stories

Bring Patrice Lumumba home

The return of Patrice Lumumba’s remains must not be an occasion for Belgium to congratulate itself, but for a full accounting of the colonial violence that led to the assassination and coverup

Nedbank features negatively in state capture report; Standard Bank defends...

So far, one of South Africa’s ‘big four’ banks faces a serious allegation levelled in the Zondo report — and more revelations may follow

President puts Mondli Gungubele in charge of State Security Agency

The presidency said the move required input from legal experts but analysts suggests it may in some way have been precipitated by the fire at parliament

Constitutional democratic order under attack: Ramaphosa

The president said slurs against the judiciary, sabotage against institutions and the findings of the Zondo commission showed the need to protect democracy
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×