Zapiro’s hurdy-gurdy a no-go show


Shortly after Shaun Abrahams, the head of the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), announced that his office will appeal a high court ruling that corruption charges be reinstated against President Jacob Zuma, I read a Facebook post calling him out as spineless.

The corporeal nature of the criticism was taken by one viewer of the post as licence to indulge in body shaming. “His forehead is underlined!! Ha ha ha ha!!!!”

Yes, Abrahams is a chiskop, and, yes, he also has Groucho Marx eyebrows. So what. The ad hominem doesn’t take us anywhere. Except, of course, if one is an editorial cartoonist to whom bodily quirks – a bulbous nose, big ears, eyebrows like shrubbery – are grist to the mill.

This week Jonathan Shapiro, this country’s favourite critic with an ink brush, prompted outrage with a somewhat unimaginative editorial cartoon portraying Abrahams as a monkey chained to a hurdy-gurdy controlled by Zuma.

In a now familiar rehearsal of the culture wars that have been a feature of the Zuma years, pundits have branded Shapiro a racist for his use of a sullied visual trope (monkey) to land a critical punch. “Who, me?” the busy cartoonist has incredulously replied. “Never.” Cue controversy.

This contentious cartoon is not the first in which Shapiro portrays a human subject as an animal. In a 1987 cartoon for the struggle newspaper, South, he depicted a Chamber of Mines boss as a portly pig in pinstripes sucking on a cigar. It traded in a well-worn cliché, which is what cartoonists do.

Last year, in a drawing published in The Times, he offered a fair likeness of newly appointed Abrahams accepting a CV from a prospective NPA job applicant, a monkey in a suit named Naledi Homimid. It was awkwardly funny.

  • See Zapiro’s latest cartoon HERE

This is possibly Shapiro’s defining attribute. What he lacks in visual exuberance – he has never matched the ferocity and verve of this paper’s early cartoonist Derek Bauer – Shapiro effortlessly makes up for in his straightened satires of life in the “new” Republic.

Zuma’s accession to power has been a boon for him.

Given his prolific output every week, it is perhaps unsurprising that Shapiro should on occasion falter. His decision to draw on the hurdy-gurdy gag, a well-worn scenario from the history of editorial cartooning, is a case in point.

The figure of the itinerant organ grinder with his monkey was once a well-known sight on New York streets. Dating back to the mid-1800s, these low-rent circus entertainers were quickly seized upon by metropolitan cartoonists who recognised a conceit in the crafty monkey tethered to a devious master.

In 1872, the political magazine Harper’s Weekly ran a cartoon accusing the New York Tribune of touting for the Democratic Party. The idea has been serially rehearsed in American political cartoons.

Last year John Cole drew Donald Trump grinding out a tune of “bigotry, fear and lies” that a glum American media (the monkey in the cartoon) is compelled to report on. A few years earlier, syndicated cartoonist Taylor Jones depicted president George W Bush playing a Christian song from a barrel organ for a dancing monkey in a bowler hat, Tony Blair.

That the animal likeness can offend, even in well-worn genre studies like the hurdy-gurdy gag, goes without saying.

The Washington Post last year hastily retracted a benign cartoon by Ann Telnaes depicting failed Senator Ted Cruz’s two daughters as monkeys on leashes. The hurdy-gurdy cartoon was a riff on Cruz’s unctuous use of his children in his ultimately failed presidential bid.

The United States and its weird politics is an ocean away from South Africa, as are its social customs and street manners. To wit: Did Shapiro err in using an imported editorial idea to comment on a local issue? The answer: it depends how much you believe the idea of the cunning organ grinder to be an imported one, and not of this place.

Hurdy-gurdies were only outlawed in New York in 1936, by which time they had entered the cultural lexicon – one that Shapiro appears to be enthralled by. It is, however, difficult to trace reliable details of these street entertainers locally.

“Thank goodness, there were no street organs in Johannesburg, and more merciful still, no German bands,” quips journalist and stockbroker Louis Cohen in his 1924 book, Reminiscences of Johannesburg and London. His insight doesn’t quite seal the issue.

In the 1870s, when names such as John Molteno and Saul Solomon inflamed passions the way Zuma and Abrahams do today, a local cartoonist drew a hurdy-gurdy gag attacking their campaign for responsible government. The two men are shown dancing to a tune for Sir Henry Barkly, the new governor of the Cape Colony.

The idea of the hurdy-gurdy flits in and out of focus in our musical culture too. “In 1953, sportsman-turned-singer Jake Ntuli, the newly crowned Empire flyweight boxing champion, guested with the Manhattan Brothers on the boogie-woogie song Organ Grinder Swing,” writes Gwen Ansell in her book Soweto Blues.

This celebratory song is not without cheek. It dangerously flirts with racial stereotypes when the Brothers invoke a refrain from the children’s song Eeny, meeny, miny, moe to account for Ntuli’s fighting prowess. It works.

More recently, Watkin Tudor Jones, aka Ninja of Die Antwoord, summoned the spirit of the hurdy-gurdy in his song Organ Grinder. Does it validate the blackface allegation pitched at Jones, or – as they say on the hill where Rhodes fell – trouble it?

Perhaps Brett Murray’s controversial 2012 painting The Spear might hold some clues. Writing at the time of the hullabaloo, Achille Mbembe remarked: “To pretend to critique contemporary forms of patriarchy with the categories used in the past to dehumanise the black man is, at best, stupid – a cruel lack of imagination.”

So how does one imaginatively stick it to the man without reiterating old clichés? One source of a possible answer lies in the joint settlement agreement reached between Zuma and Murray. Both sides agreed “deep wounds created by apartheid have divided South Africans on racial lines”. There is no revelation in this, but its truth value is plain and clear – and traduced every other day by Penny Sparrow & co.

The warring parties in 2012 also agreed that the dispute involved “balancing between two competing constitutional rights, to human dignity and freedom of artistic expression, both of which have a crucial place in our democracy”.

This, on the one hand, means parking sensitivities about criticism – we are ruled by a thin-skinned and litigious potentate. But it also makes clear that images of people portrayed as animals, however funny, key into colonial arcana that continue to haunt our present.

Is Shapiro done with? Murray’s career didn’t end with his painting, just as Zuma’s indiscretions didn’t stop. The same is true of Shapiro. His service record is, in the main, exemplary.

But even a seasoned critic like Shapiro can make a mistake, one that reveals not only the faultlines of a divided nation, but also, possibly, the looming horizon of career obsolescence.

It would be a shame to see Zapiro go, but our current impasse demands new and imaginative ideas to puncture the fatal tyranny of power.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Sean Otoole 1
Guest Author

Related stories

Women are South Africa’s changemakers and they deserve more

The truth is the economy still largely revolves around men, especially white men like me, writes Alef Meulenberg.

The mechanism of contagion in racism

How race came to function as fuel to an exploitative economic system. Take the case of South Africa…

Black Lives Matter – turning point at a historic moment

The protests that have taken place in the United States confront the racialised edifice that built the modern world

Beware of Big Business bearing gifts

Large corporates whose business has thrived because of inequalities, could be hijacking the anti-racist movement by offering money and not tangible changes

What is the future of black lives in historically white, elite schools?

These schools, to varying degrees, have an intense attachment to the values of authority and obedience — it is an attachment which numbs critical thought

Black lives must matter in Africa too

Although Africans must continue to support the Black Lives Matter movement, there is also the need for them to raise their voices against injustices in other African countries

New education policy on gender violence released

Universities and other higher education institutions have to develop ways of preventing or dealing with rape and other damaging behaviour

Cambridge Food Jozini: Pandemic or not, the price-gouging continues

The Competition Commission has fined Cambridge Food Jozini for hiking the price of its maize meal during April

Sekhukhune’s five-year battle for water back in court

The residents of five villages are calling for the district municipal manager to be arrested

Vaccine trial results due in December

If successful, it will then have to be manufactured and distributed

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday