To enjoy the full Mail & Guardian online experience: please upgrade your browser
23 Jun 2016 00:00
A child pauses at a memorial to victims of the Pulse nightclub shooting on June 17, 2016 in Orlando, Florida. Omar Mateen killed 49 people at the popular gay nightclub. Fifty-three people were wounded in the attack. (Spencer Platt/Getty/AFP)
The Republican-controlled United States Senate rejected four competing gun control measures just days after the Orlando nightclub massacre, highlighting the feuding over an issue that’s set to resonate during a heated presidential election year.
With a month to go before Republicans and Democrats formally nominate their White House hopefuls, lawmakers failed on Monday to compromise on one of the most sensitive hot-button issues in America.
Even as they sought to appear keen to take action after the deadliest mass shooting in US history that left 49 dead at a gay nightclub in Orlando two weeks ago, Republicans and Democrats voted down four amendments – two from each party – that would have limited some gun purchases, including those by suspects on FBI watchlists.
“The recent attacks in Orlando – as much as people are concerned and upset about them – are not going to force members of Congress to fundamentally vote against their own self-interest,” said Jason Johnson, a political science professor at Hiram College.
“Their self-interest is that they want to have money from the National Rifle Association (NRA), they want to continue to have that kind of financial support running for office, and despite the fact that an overwhelming proportion of Americans, Republicans and Democrats – and gun owners – think that at least some of these four legislative ideas were reasonable policy, Congress is not going to move that way.”
The two Democratic texts sought to bar those on FBI watchlists or no-fly lists from buying firearms, and to strengthen criminal and mental health background checks for those seeking to purchase firearms at gun shows and on the internet.
Republicans are opposed to those measures. In general, they oppose any effort to limit gun rights, saying they are protected by the US Constitution’s Second Amendment.
They proposed a 72-hour waiting period for those on FBI watchlists seeking to buy weapons, so that the government has time to seek a court order to block the sale if need be.
The second Republican proposal aimed to improve the background check system.
Democrats rejected both GOP measures. Such efforts often struggle to pass the Senate, where 60 out of 100 votes are needed for legislation to advance.
“[Gun control] will continue to be talked about because … there will be another shooting,” added Johnson. The Senate voted on similar measures in the wake of the December 2012 Connecticut school massacre and the San Bernardino attacks last year, but to no avail.
“Every single senator wants to deny terrorists access to guns they use to harm innocent civilians, but there’s a right way to do things and a wrong way,” said Republican Senator John Cornyn of Texas.
Senate Democrat Dick Durbin was livid at the failure of lawmakers to come together on such a pressing issue after yet another shooting. “Tonight, the Senate turned its back on victims of gun violence from Orlando to San Bernardino, from Newtown to the streets of Chicago,” Durbin said in a statement.
There are 46 senators who are Democrats or generally vote with Democrats, and 54 Republicans. Susan Collins, a moderate Republican senator from Maine, was expected to unveil some kind of compromise legislation, but it also seemed unlikely to pass.
Presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton has spoken out at length about the need to curb gun violence in the time since the Orlando tragedy, but she had a shorter message on Monday.
Democrats know they have only a slim chance of succeeding with gun reform ahead of the November elections. Their goal for now is to push the debate on guns – and turn it into a true campaign issue.
“Ultimately, the only way that you win this issue is by building a political infrastructure around the country that rivals that of the gun lobby,” Democratic Senator Chris Murphy said on Sunday.
Last week, Murphy mounted a 15-hour filibuster on the Senate floor that prompted Republican leaders to schedule Monday’s cloture votes. “Our filibuster helped galvanise an entire country around this issue,” he said.
Republican presidential hopeful Donald Trump made waves last week when he suggested he would meet with the NRA – which has endorsed him – to push a ban on weapons sales to those on watchlists. On Sunday, Trump said the NRA was seeking to defend “the best interests of our country”, adding: “They want to make the right decision.”
Since the attack on the Pulse nightclub in Orlando, Trump controversially said he only wished more of the people in the club had guns to defend themselves.
But NRA’s executive vice-president and chief executive Wayne LaPierre contradicted Trump, saying: “I don’t think you should have firearms where people are drinking.” Trump has since walked back his comments, tweeting that he was “obviously talking about additional guards or employees”. –
News24 Wire/Al Jazeera
Create Account | Lost Your Password?