Mining companies are using delay tactics in a bid to slice silicosis payout costs

On June 24 the high court refused the gold mining industry permission to appeal against its judgment last month, which allowed gold miners’ silicosis compensation claims to proceed as a class action. (The industry can renew its application with the Supreme Court of Appeal.) The high court gave the industry permission to appeal its ruling that, in the event of a miners’ death, his claim for damages for pain and suffering would be transmitted to his estate. 

The objective of minimising the amount of the inevitable payout underpins the industry’s legal strategy. Continuing the procedural wrangling substantially delays the litigation, which is indefensible if the industry does not genuinely intend to defend silicosis litigation on its merits.  That would effectively entail defending the allegation that their negligent failure to control dust exposure on the mines had caused a silicosis epidemic among black gold miners. But the industry has repeatedly expressed a desire to settle the class action. 

Moreover, the two class action defendants with the largest potential silicosis liabilities, Anglo American South Africa and AngloGold Ashanti, have twice settled different silicosis cases, in which we were involved, shortly before trial, indicating a lack of conviction in their defences. These were the President Steyn miners’ test cases in 2013 and the litigation for 4 365 gold miners, which settled in March this year, the latter leading to the establishment of the Q(h)ubeka Trust. Unless these same defendants have suddenly had a change of heart and now intend to defend such claims to trial, the issue of whether or not a class action mechanism is appropriate is artificial.

At the same time as this artificial legal argument is progressing at a snail’s pace through the legal system, the silicosis victims — the cause of whose predicament the industry does not deny — will continue to suffer and die at an ever increasing rate. Their average age is about 60 and their health is fragile. As an aside, 20 years ago we began the Cape Plc litigation for South African asbestos victims.

The majority of the following eight years, prior to the case settling, were spent arguing over whether the case should be tried in England, even though it was obvious that the case would never reach trial. By the time the case had settled, 1 000 of the 7 500 victims had died. In the class action judgment the high court changed the law of South Africa by deciding that in the event of a claimants’ death, compensation for pain and suffering will be transmitted to his or her estate. This is the position under British law, a point that we had highlighted for more than a decade. The industry has been allowed to appeal this ruling.  

Yet, even if the ruling stands, the next of kin would still need to prove that the deceased had contracted silicosis, which would be difficult unless he had been examined during his lifetime or had undergone a post-mortem. It is worth noting that transmission of damages was agreed to by Anglo American and AngloGold in our litigation.

The threat of ongoing procedural delays serves a financial purpose from the perspective of the industry and its shareholders. This is to pressure the claimants into accepting a settlement of a lower value, full compensation being too distant a prospect. Alternatively, if the claimants fight on, increasingly more of them will die and the overall compensation bill will decrease. 

Either way, prolonging the legal process is advantageous to the industry. The other beneficiaries of protracted litigation are the vast array of corporate lawyers recruited by the industry, who will be relishing the prospect of endless rounds of hearings and appeals as to whether a class action should be permitted and thereafter, if it is ultimately permitted, further academic arguments over what form it should take and how it should be managed.

Claimants frequently accept damages that are less than their full entitlement rather than holding out for “jam tomorrow” and to secure speedier payment, avoid litigation risk and reduce legal costs. In the case of silicosis, where the culpability of the industry is so clear, the consequences of delay so dire and the power imbalance so great, the continued delay in compensating the victims is morally reprehensible.

The industry argument that settlement is not feasible pending determination of the likely number of eligible silicosis claimants is no longer tenable. The industry has been anticipating claims by gold miners for 20 years and has had ample time to investigate and make reasonable projections.  For the purposes of the Q(h)ubeka litigation, we conducted a random sampling exercise which indicated that up to 60% of the group of 4 365 claimants were likely to have silicosis. The industry can estimate and set aside an overall amount of money using a similar approach and principles. 

In any event, 32 mining companies between them have deep enough pockets to establish an industry-wide settlement along the lines of the Q(h)ubeka Trust.  They should end their obfuscation and do so now.

Richard Meeran is a partner at Leigh Day law firm.

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever. But it comes at a cost. Advertisers are cancelling campaigns, and our live events have come to an abrupt halt. Our income has been slashed.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years. We’ve survived thanks to the support of our readers, we will need you to help us get through this.

To help us ensure another 35 future years of fiercely independent journalism, please subscribe.

Richard Meeran
Richard Meeran works from London. Head of International Claims Dept at @LeighDay_Law. We act for people harmed by the conduct of UK multinationals and the UK government overseas Richard Meeran has over 662 followers on Twitter.

Where is the deputy president?

David Mabuza is hard at work — it’s just not taking place in the public eye. The rumblings and discussion in the ANC are about factions in the ruling party, succession and ousting him

Zuma turns on judiciary as trial nears

Former president says pre-trial correspondence is part of another plot

High court declares Dudu Myeni delinquent

Disgraced former SAA chairperson Dudu Myeni has been declared a delinquent director by the...

SANDF inquiry clears soldiers of the death of Collins Khosa

The board of inquiry also found that it was Khosa and his brother-in-law Thabiso Muvhango who caused the altercation with the defence force members

Press Releases

Obituary: Mohammed Tikly

His legacy will live on in the vision he shared for a brighter more socially just future, in which racism and discrimination are things of the past

Openview, now powered by two million homes

The future of free-to-air satellite TV is celebrating having two million viewers by giving away two homes worth R2-million

Road to recovery for the tourism sector: The South African perspective

The best-case scenario is that South Africa's tourism sector’s recovery will only begin in earnest towards the end of this year

What Africa can learn from Cuba in combating the Covid-19 pandemic

Africa should abandon the neoliberal path to be able to deal with Covid-19 and other health system challenges likely to emerge in future

Coexisting with Covid-19: Saving lives and the economy in India

A staggered exit from the lockdown accompanied by stepped-up testing to cover every district is necessary for India right now

Covid-19: Eased lockdown and rule of law Webinar

If you are arrested and fined in lockdown, you do get a criminal record if you pay the admission of guilt fine

Covid-19 and Frontline Workers

Who is caring for the healthcare workers? 'Working together is how we are going to get through this. It’s not just a marathon, it’s a relay'.

PPS webinar Part 2: Small business, big risk

The risks that businesses face and how they can be dealt with are something all business owners should be well acquainted with

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday