COMMENT
The horrific shootings targeting the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual and intersex (LGBTI) community in the United States sent a chilling message that was heard with crystal clear clarity around the world. The murders triggered a fresh and passionate debate about gun laws in the US and shone a light on the ever-present challenges the LGBTI community faces worldwide.
The events in the US are no more terrifying than the reality of the LGBTI community in South Africa and throughout the continent.
A glaring example surfaced just last week in the Ivory Coast. A group of gay men were threatened, terrorised, beaten and forced to leave their homes. The reason? They were identified as being part of the “LGBTI community” in an online photo showing them signing a US Embassy book of condolences for the Orlando victims.
No matter how much progress we think we have made in extending basic human rights to every corner of the LGBTI community, we have an intolerably long way to go. The simple truth is that hate crimes against queer people have increased steadily in South Africa over the past few decades. That is why the country’s Parliament is now considering a Hate Crimes Bill.
It is ironic that 20 years after South Africa’s Constitution banned discrimination against the LGBTI community and paved the way for the legalisation of same-sex marriage, plus the freedom for same-sex couples to adopt children and the right of gay people to serve openly in the military, being LGBTI in South Africa is increasingly dangerous. Just a few months ago, Lucia Naido, a young lesbian woman, was stabbed to death in Katlehong on the night of her birthday. Her death came barely four months after the body of Bobby Motlatla was discovered in his flat. He had been stabbed multiple times, probably because of his sexuality. We can’t forget Duduzile Zozo, who was brutally raped and murdered in 2013 because she was a lesbian; Thapelo Makhutle whose body was found badly mutilated in the Northern Cape in 2012; Neil Daniels who was stabbed and set alight in Cape Town that year; and Nontsikelo Tyatyeka, found dead in a dustbin because of homophobia and hate.
What happened in Orlando can and does happen here.
Legislation is not enough to end the hate
The world’s largest HIV conference will be held in Durban in July. It has been held on African soil once before — in 2000. The issue of persistent stigma, violence and discrimination will be firmly on my mind when I attend the conference. My fervent hope is that I will not be alone.
Back in 2000 at the first Aids conference, the focus was on bridging the gap between the level of access to HIV medication and other treatments in the developed world and the lack of resources in the developing world. This combination of the world’s spotlight and the efforts of many brave social justice activists, who literally put their lives on the line to fight for access to antiretroviral drugs, had a huge effect. Sixteen years later, we can take some measure of satisfaction in having the largest public health antiretroviral programme in the world.
This time around, however, we must broaden the discussions. We need to move beyond treatment for HIV to a deeper conversation about how to eradicate hate, stigmatisation and isolation of LGBTIs. Just as we know that access to treatment does little to change attitudes that fuel the marginalisation of sex workers, drug users who inject drugs and men who have sex with men, we also know that legislation addressing domestic violence and rape does little to stem the violence directed at women in South Africa. Legislation, essential as it is, has its limits.
Real social change is in the air
What to do? Fortunately, there is momentum for real social change in the air. We should be encouraged by the wave of homegrown leaders, movements and activists that is sweeping across the continent and bringing with it solutions for Africa’s LGBTI people. Their efforts and alliances with other human rights movements have resulted in palpable change in legislation, court decisions, health policies and shifting public opinion across Africa.
In the past few years, Mozambique has decriminalised homosexuality. In Botswana and Kenya, courts have given LGBTI organisations the right to register and operate. The African Commission on Human and People’s Rights has explicitly condemned violence and discrimination against LGBTI people and granted the Coalition of African Lesbians formal observer status.
These and many other steps in the right direction should be celebrated. They demonstrate that change is possible and tell a story of pride, dignity and activism that counters the narrative of gloom, doom and hopelessness. The world needs to support this movement — with an emphasis on the word “support.” Too often in the past, well-meaning organisations, including my own, have tried top-down approaches to change and one-dimensional solutions to complex intersectional problems. That needs to change.
The Global North must preach less, listen more
For one thing, the Global North has to do a whole lot less preaching and talking and a whole lot more listening and learning. We’re so busy giving advice and implementing solutions that come from New York, Geneva and Brussels that we’ve lost touch with the needs and realities of the LGBTI community.
At their core, the problems of the LGBTI community centre on inequality and injustice. Looked at through that prism, you start to see how the discrimination, violation and oppression faced by people who do not conform to social expectations of gender and sexual orientation are inextricably linked to the struggles of people who are oppressed on the basis of race, class, disability and geography.
If we treat these challenges as isolated issues, we’ll get partial solutions. If we design solutions without real engagement with those we seek to support, we’ll head down a lot of dead ends. And if we focus on quick fixes, we won’t get lasting change. That’s why the Ford Foundation is making some bold bets that are relevant to this discussion.
To start, we have transferred responsibility for our global LGBTI strategies from our headquarters in New York to our office in Johannesburg. This is to reflect our belief that leadership from the Global South will ensure that our strategies and support are channelled where the needs are the greatest.
We are also giving more control and decision-making to our local partners and financing them for longer periods of time. Local actors need more agency and voice in determining the pace and trajectory of social change, which is a complex and messy process.
The third bold bet is to use inequality as our lodestar for tackling social justice issues, including the challenges that the LGBTI community face. This means we will work in a more integrated and holistic way with a view toward shifting harmful cultural and social narratives; promoting and protecting human rights; ensuring government and private sector accountability and focusing on the unique challenges faced by LGBTI youth.
This is an ambitious agenda but the LGBTI community deserves no less. We need to break out of our old mind-sets, be open to new ideas and actions, think big and act boldly. If we do, we can honour the memory of African martyrs such as Lucia Naido, Bobby Motlatla, Duduzile Zozo, Eudy Simelane and the countless others, in the same way as Americans are honouring those massacred in Orlando.
Nicolette Naylor is the Southern Africa regional director of the Ford Foundation.