More flawed Metrobus tenders found

Internal audit reports reveal more irregular Metrobus procurement dealings — flawed tender awards that go against the government’s strategic objectives.

The Mail & Guardian reported last week that Johannesburg’s Metrobus ignored audit advice and proceeded to award a R200‑million fuel supply tender, despite concerns that many processes had been openly disregarded.

This week, the M&G has gained possession of two reports by audit company PwC this year, which found several irregularities in Metrobus awarding two three-year contracts to Prestige Motor Spares Wholesalers CC in 2016 for the supply and delivery of batteries and various Mercedes Benz parts.

PwC said the awards compromised “the principles of fairness, transparency, nonbias towards a predetermined outcome, competitiveness and cost-effectiveness”.

“Evaluators may not have received adequate training before evaluating tenders, resulting in biased allocation of scores, as well as suppliers may have been incorrectly qualified for further evaluation. The prescribed criteria is very subjective and open to interpretation … As a result, scoring between evaluators differed,” PwC said in one of the reports.

Sabatha Makoele, former acting managing director of Metrobus, requested PwC to review the commercial process followed for the procurement of the goods, because the same supplier was shortlisted and recommended for both contracts.

“This awarding of contracts to one supplier is noncompliant with government’s strategic objective of ensuring that there is an even spread between suppliers,” PwC said.

The reports also reveal that the bidding process for the awarding of the tender was flawed. An inspection of the bid compliance checklist compiled by Metrobus’s commercial evaluation team reveals that five suppliers submitted proposals and went through to the next stage of evaluation. But three of them should have been disqualified because they did not submit original tax clearance certificates.

The team was found to be inconsistent, deviating from initial mandatory requirements, to allow some of the bidders to proceed for the second leg of evaluation.

“The process may be deemed unfair, biased and not competitive, resulting in possible litigation from suppliers, as not all tenders were evaluated correctly. Metrobus’s reputation may be compromised and may result in negative media scrutiny,” PwC said.

“Management should consider formal training for all procurement practitioners so that they have the ability to identify original documents from the colour copies to ensure consistency in evaluation,” it said.

Johannesburg Mayor Herman Mashaba said he was worried about the extent of the corruption at Metrobus.

“Metrobus is one of those entities that have worried me from the moment I took office. The transport service has been burning the city’s money for years and it is showing no signs of letting up. We have been monitoring them for a while and we have consequently put in place a few short-term solutions to try to deal with what’s happening to the entity, because the situation there is not something that you can turn around overnight,” he said.

He added, though, what the city will launch an investigation into Metrobus.

“We are the only metro with an investigations team. The team is led by General [Shadrack] Sibiya [head of the city’s internal investigations] and, believe me, once we have gathered all the relevant facts, we will launch an investigation.”

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Poachers in prisons tell their stories

Interviews with offenders provide insight into the structure of illegal wildlife trade networks

Covid-overflow hospital in ruins as SIU investigates

A high-level probe has begun into hundreds of millions of rand spent by the Gauteng health department to refurbish a hospital that is now seven months behind schedule – and lying empty

More top stories

The politics of the Zuma-Zondo showdown

Any move made by the Zondo commission head or by former president Jacob Zuma must be calculated, because one mistake from either side could lead to a political fallout

Museveni declared winner of disputed Uganda election

Security personnel out in force as longtime president wins sixth term and main challenger Bobi Wine alleges rigging.

Pay-TV inquiry probes the Multichoice monopoly

Africa’s largest subscription television operator says it is under threat amid the emerging popularity of global platforms like Netflix and Amazon Prime

​No apology or comfort as another Marikana mother dies without...

Nomawethu Ma’Bhengu Sompeta, whose funeral will be held this weekend, was unequivocal in calling out the government for its response to the Marikana massacre

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…