What Malusi GiGupta didn’t say

The minister of finance, Malusi GiGupta, cut a pathetic and unconvincing figure on Wednesday as he delivered a medium-term budget policy statement that simply confirms the consequences of state capture.

The aesthetics of a beautifully tailored suit could not hide the narrative of a state that is so rotten, it will take a minor miracle for the ANC to recover from the sin of not having reined in President Jacob Zuma, his fellow cronies and their Saxonwold shebeen puppet masters.

GiGupta pretended as though numbers have their own agency. He spoke — not very convincingly but with some effort — like a management consultant, perhaps one working for Trillian or McKinsey, who hopes that an analysis of numbers can shift the conversation away from the human beings behind the numbers.

But that is a trick we cannot fall for. What GiGupta didn’t tell us matters far more than what he did tell us.

To recap: he told us that the economic growth forecast is revised downwards from 1.3% this year to a paltry 0.7%, that the state failed to collect some R50.8-billion in much-needed taxes, that the budget deficit is expected to balloon from the target of 3.1% to 4.3%, and that the gross national debt could be about 60% of our gross domestic product in three years’ time. The last point would necessitate about 15% of the main budget being spent on servicing the debt we have accumulated — an expense that will outstrip what we spend on core governance priorities such as social security.

If you’re a sucker for punishment or if you’re addicted to an
anthropology of low expectations, then you might be tempted to pat him on the back for the honesty. Don’t do that. He is not innocent in the story of how we landed in this hot mess.

Which brings me to what he didn’t tell you. He didn’t tell you that the brutal and unforgiving reason for these numbers is theft by Zuma and his friends, theft facilitated by members of the Zuma government — including himself.

The mid-term budget statement described the status quo accurately. But it intentionally neglected to describe the state capture project that is wholly responsible for low economic growth, a widening budget deficit and a growing debt burden.

Obviously the South African Revenue Service (Sars) won’t collect taxes as effectively as it did five years ago, because it is a site of contestation in the battle to capture the state. Corruption explains why we have this revenue shortfall. GiGupta didn’t mention that little truth. Sars, like GiGupta himself, is a shadow of its former self.

The same goes for economic growth. I could not believe the complete and utter hubris when the minister waffled in platitudes about the theoretical role of state-owned companies as engines of growth.

What the fudge, Malusi? You enabled key state-owned companies to be hijacked from South Africa Inc by allowing dodgy board and other appointments when you were minister of public enterprises. The bulldust at SAA, the looting from Transnet and Eskom and other strategic state-owned entities happened on your watch.

That is the political legacy that GiGupta didn’t tell you about on Wednesday. His entire speech made it seem as though he is an alien who arrived on Tuesday and was given a set of terse facts, and a Ben Okri quote to perform the following day.

We wouldn’t be in this economic mess if the ANC wasn’t in the crisis-ridden state it is in.

That is the stark truth: politicians, not cold numbers and graphs, lie behind the state of our state. Unless and until we address the state capture elephant in the Saxonwold shebeen, these numbers will simply go from bad to worse.

But, of course, I didn’t expect GiGupta to keep it real. How could he? He is implicated in the state capture project.

He is beholden to the grandmasters using him as a chess pawn in a game in which the taxpayer is under massive attack because those who are meant to be on our side are actually friends and employees of the enemy.

To add insult to state capture injury, GiGupta shamelessly thanked his predecessors in the finance ministry

Really, dude? You thank folks like Pravin Gordhan who were cliffed by Atul Gupta precisely because Gordhan was an obstacle to the looting. That shout-out to Gordhan and Trevor Manuel rang hollow.

Just as hollow as the Okri references to an imagined imminent harvest. It would have been more poetically apt to quote a different Okri gift to the world, The Famished Road.

It often feels like we are characters floating between a material world and a spiritual one, with little harvest to be excited about, and plentiful dreaminess to make sense of.

GiGupta, like his boss Zuma, is part of the problem and therefore cannot be a partner with civil society in search of urgent solutions.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Eusebius Mckaiser
Eusebius McKaiser
Eusebius McKaiser is a political and social analyst at the Wits Centre for Ethics. He is also a popular radio talk show host, a top international debate coach, a master of ceremonies and a public speaker of note. He loves nothing more than a good argument, having been both former National South African Debate Champion and the 2011 World Masters Debate Champion. His analytic articles and columns have been widely published in South African newspapers and the New York Times. McKaiser has studied law and philosophy. He taught philosophy in South Africa and England.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Medical aids blame external costs as fees increase beyond inflation

Medical aid is becoming more of a luxury for many South Africans, and it’s not about to get any better

Mahikeng compounds its mess

The ailing town that wasted R2-billion appoints a municipal manager rated ‘basic’, the lowest level

More top stories

FUL mulls legal options regarding Hlophe’s presence at interviews for...

Premier Alan Winde and the Cape Bar Council asked that the interviews be postponed pending a decision on Hlophe’s fate but the JSC declined

Cape Town fire update: Mop-up operations underway, students receive local...

Clean-up operations and repairs to infrastructure are being initiated, while the full extent of the damage wrought by the fire is still being assessed

Bird flu outbreak puts poultry industry in jeopardy

Avian flu has been confirmed on two farms in Gauteng and one in North West

Absa chief executive resigns due to differences with board on...

Activist group warns of a ‘culling trend’ affecting black professionals in top positions

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…