Muthambi hits back at Phumla Williams

Former minister Faith Muthambi said that Phumla Williams’ testimony before the commission of inquiry into state capture may well have jeopardised its outcome by reducing her testimony to “a personal, inappropriate and unjustified attack”.

In a statement to eNCA, Muthambi responded to the allegations levelled against her by the acting government communication and information systems (GCIS) at the commission on Monday. Williams accused Muthambi of bullying her and attempting to destabilise the department.

On Monday Williams told the commission — headed by Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo — that she believed that Muthambi, as the then communications minister, had attempted to create the conditions at GCIS in which procurement processes could be flouted.

READ MORE: ‘Muthambi wanted me out’ — Phumla Williams

“She wanted that procurement at all costs. She wanted to steal at all costs. That removing of all those functions was a ploy to remove the finance and procurement away from me,” Williams said.

Muthambi responded by describing Williams’ testimony as self-serving: “As is always the case with Ms Williams, she has once again taken the opportunity to undermine an important institution to make it all about herself. This was the usual all consuming sense of entitlement, the wilful distortion of faces to paint herself as a victim …”

Much of Williams’ testimony was dedicated to recounting the alleged bullying she experienced under the leadership of Muthambi. She detailed how Muthambi had pushed her to the brink of early retirement after the minister had first demoted and then had effectively made Williams’ new position redundant.

In the process, Muthambi had rendered GCIS nearly dysfunctional, Williams told the commission. She called Muthambi’s attempts to undermine her position a strategy to co-opt GCIS finances and the department’s supply chain.

“I don’t think that woman was interested in preserving the resources of the country. And that is why I then said that I would be failing the people of South Africa if I allow the thief to get away with it,” Williams said.

At one point during her testimony, Williams was close to tears as she explained that her Muthambi’s treatment of her had caused her to relive her experience of torture during her 1988 arrest.

“The effects of my torture were back. Chairperson, I was no longer sleeping. I was having nightmares. I was realising my situation. My facial twitches were back,” she said choking up.”I had panic attacks. I saw torture going through my body again. I never thought in this government, people could do such things. I was tortured for weeks, and Muthambi did the same to me … And that is why I wrote this letter; as a way to try and get her to understand what she was doing.”

READ MORE: #StateCaptureInquiry: ‘Muthambi wanted to steal at all costs’ — Williams

Muthambi called Williams’ comparison between her torture at the hands of the apartheid police and her experience under Muthambi “entirely inappropriate” and “emotionally manipulative”. “It is evident that we are dealing here with an emotionally unhinged person,” she said of Williams.

Muthambi said she would be seeking legal advice regarding Williams’ testimony. “A very different truth will emerge, and her lies and reactionary agenda will finally be exposed for all to see,” she said.

At the beginning of Williams’ testimony on Friday, Advocate Kate Hofmeyr, who led the witness, indicated that Muthambi had not applied to cross-examine the witness.

But on Monday, Hofmeyr pointed out that Williams had made allegations that went beyond her initial statement to the commission and that the legal team would alert those implicated of this should they wish to apply to cross examine Williams.

Williams could not be reached for comment at the time of writing.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Sarah Smit
Sarah Smit
Sarah Smit is a general news reporter at the Mail & Guardian. She covers topics relating to labour, corruption and the law.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Matrics fail at critical subjects

The basic education minister talks of quality passes achieved by the class of 2020, but a closer look at the results tells a different story

Step-aside guidelines are not about Ace, says Mathews Phosa

The guidelines must be ‘timeless, uniting and not capable of being abused,’ says ANC veteran

More top stories

Sisulu dissolves housing agency board, again

The HDA is once again under administration, and its acting chief executive gets to stay on

Pangolins pushed to the brink of extinction

The trafficking of scales is no longer a ‘niche’ criminal activity, but a serious and organised crime that threatens to make all eight species extinct within 20 years

Durban residents want answers after refinery emission

People living near the refinery were subjected to two hours of dirty smoke from the refinery, the South Durban Environmental Alliance said on Saturday.

Parents ‘key to best grade 12 results’

For the past four years, the matric results in Tshwane South has been the leading district in Gauteng. The formula to success has been involving the parents

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…