Judge Kroon backtracks on ruling that ‘rogue unit’ was unlawful

The former head of a South African Revenue Service (Sars) advisory board admitted to the Nugent commission that they were wrong to say the so-called “rogue unit” was unlawful and that he had approved the restructuring of the revenue service’s operating model without knowing a thing about the one that was currently operational.

The commission — headed by retired Judge Robert Nugent — has from the start of its proceedings, heard how reports of an alleged rogue unit were used by suspended commissioner Tom Moyane to purge some of Sars’ executives. Moyane also detrimentally restructured Sars’ operational model on the advice of consulting firm Bain & Company, undercutting its efficiency.

In 2015, retired judge Frank Kroon was appointed to head up a committee in a bid to restore the integrity of Sars and advise it in the wake of turmoil at the revenue service. This followed a report by senior counsel Muzi Sikhakhane, who was appointed to investigate allegations of impropriety by former Sars investigator Johann Van Loggerenberg.

READ MORE: Tax boss’s actions under scrutiny

Sikhakhane’s panel found that the so-called rogue unit had been unlawfully established. It was on the basis of this report that Moyane suspended former deputy commissioner Ivan Pillay and group executive of strategic planning and risk Peter Richer.

Kroon confirmed the findings of the Sikhakhane panel’s conclusion on the establishment of the unit, saying Sars did not have the statutory authority to gather intelligence “covertly”.

On Friday, Kroon told the commission that the statement released by the board, that said the covert unit was unlawful, was not “thought through properly and in fact, were incorrect … certainly, the establishment on its own would [be] quite lawful”.

Kroon said at the time they had relied entirely on information given to them by Moyane, former chief operating officer Jonas Makwakwa and the Sikhakhane report as well as the now withdrawn KPMG report. In addition to saying the unit was unlawful the reports also said that the unit had spied on former president Jacob Zuma, state officials and that it owned a brothel.

READ MORE: Sars official struggles to answer why Pillay was purged

“Did you make your own inquiries at the level of law as to whether or not advocate [Muzi] Sikhakhane is correct in his conclusion that the establishment of the unit was unlawful,” asked Steinberg.

“No,” Kroon said.

“We could not say that the unit was unlawfully established, we did not have the full information as to when and how it was established,” he added.

Kroon said they had apologised to Pravin Gordhan because he was the commissioner when the unit was formed and said it would be beneficial for an institution like Sars to re-establish that unit.

Kroon also approved Moyane’s proposal to restructure Sars’ operating model. The new model, designed by Bain, has been largely discredited in the testimony of numerous Sars officials who have spoken at the hearings.

He said he relied on a presentation given to them by Bain and oral and written submissions of Moyane and Makwakwa, when they approved a proposal to restructure Sars.

Carol Steinberg asked how he then approved the restructuring of the model if they could not determine if that would have been an improvement on the model to which Kroon said: “In retrospect, it would be fair to say that we should have investigated further”.

“I sent a letter posing that as one of the questions. I don’t believe we ever received a direct answer to that,” he continued.

Adviser Michael Katz asked Kroon if the board did not find it strange that Moyane, who was the commissioner of correctional services and had no tax background, would after a brief period at Sars wanted to make extensive changes to an institution with a successful reputation.

READ MORE: Nugent’s adviser links to Sars case

He added if the board was not concerned that there was something behind the proposal to restructure Sars?

“That thought did not cross my mind,” said Kroon, who adding that he was only surprised that Moyane with a prison service background was appointed to the head of a tax institution.

The commission continues.

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Tebogo Tshwane
Tebogo Tshwane

Tebogo Tshwane is an Adamela Trust financial journalism trainee at the Mail & Guardian. She was previously a general news intern at Eyewitness News and a current affairs show presenter at the Voice of Wits FM. Tshwane is passionate about socioeconomic issues and understanding how macroeconomic activities affect ordinary people. She holds a journalism honours degree from Wits University. 

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

WATCH LIVE: 200 Young South Africans 2022

M&G will showcase SA’s most versatile, innovative young professionals to inspire, ignite and prepare upcoming youth for a new world

Banning abortion criminalises femininity as it does race and poverty

Unpacking the reversal of Roe v Wade and the ruling in Dobbs v Jackson reveals a pushback against gains made by women

Flying the flag for the youth

Emmy-nominated actress Thuso Mbedu credits inclusivity, equality, and sustainability to getting her career to where it is today. As a Mail & Guardian Top 200 Young South African, the actress encourages the youth to collaborate for a better future

Is the US establishing a military base in Zambia?

Dr Fred M’membe, president of the Socialist Party in Zambia, says such a facility will be established ‘over our dead bodies’

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…