Woolies in baby sling boo-boo

Woolworths has apologised to Cape Town business owner Shannon McLaughlin, who accused the big retailer of stealing her baby carrier design.

McLaughlin, the founder of Ubuntu Baba, is the most recent of several people who have accused Woolworths of appropriating their products.

On Monday, she posted in a blog about how, in December, she was alerted to an alleged rip-off of her product by Woolworths. She pointed out the similarities between her baby carrier and the one sold by the retailer.

By Tuesday afternoon Woolworths had quietly removed the baby carriers from its website and would not comment “before chatting with Ubuntu Baba first”.

Following the “chat” on Wednesday, Woolworths released a statement saying it had concluded its investigations and would remove the product from its online and physical stores. It also offered a full refund to customers who want to return the baby carrier.

“While there are differences in our baby carrier, there are striking similarities, which we acknowledge and take responsibility for,” it said. It blamed the situation on a lapse in its design process, which it said was “being addressed internally”.

“We are intensifying and strengthening the training of our people, our suppliers and partners on our values-based approach to the design and sourcing process.”

Ubuntu Baba has been operating since 2015, selling Stage 1 and Stage 2 baby carriers for newborns to three-year-olds.

On December 16 last year, McLaughlin received a WhatsApp message from an employee with a screenshot of a similar baby carrier being sold on the Woolworths website. Its baby carriers were in the same colours and included the labels Stage 1 and Stage 2.

McLaughlin bought a Woolworths carrier to do a side-by-side comparison of the two products. She described the results as a shameless copy of the design and pattern of her baby carrier.

According to her, the most obvious clue that her design could have been stolen was in the waistband.

“That is exact proof and there’s no other way they could have done that without our pattern. If you measure centimetre for centimetre, every piece of the waistband is exactly the same.

“The way the waistband is sewn closed on the back; if you turn the carrier upside down and you see how we put the foam in and secure the waistband shut is extremely unique to our brand. We designed it from scratch. There is no other brand that has a waistband like that,” she said.

McLaughlin found more evidence when she looked through Ubuntu Baba’s online order receipts. She found two of her carriers were ordered by people at Woolworths’ head office. An online search of the recipients showed that the head of sourcing had received the Stage 2 carrier in June 2017 and, in September 2017, the Stage 1 carrier was delivered to Woolworth’s product developer.

“We don’t know if they were just moms buying our products … It could just be coincidence, but quite a large coincidence,” she said.

McLaughlin said she had registered the name of her business but not the names of the carriers or the design.

“When I started the business, I wasn’t thinking about intellectual property. I didn’t even think about the word intellectual property until three weeks ago.”

Intellectual property chair at Stellenbosch University Professor Owen Dean said McLaughlin would not have a claim on patent or design because these trademark rights apply only if a product is registered, however, she could seek remedy using copyright which applies automatically.

“If she can show that her product is so well known to a substantial number of people that when they see the Woolworths product they believe that it is manufactured by her then she may have a claim of passing off under the common law,” said Dean.

Dean said entrepreneurs should take advantage of the protections of intellectual property law by registering their new inventions and designs before their products are on the market.

“As far as trademarks are concerned they should register their brands and the shapes of their products, assuming that they are distinctive, at the earliest opportunities and not wait until potential infringements have taken place,” Dean said adding that they should also keep good records of their operations.

Multi-jurisdictional copyright lawyer Graeme Gilfillan agreed with this adding that courts have described this as “filching of the fruits of another’s skill and labour or reaping [what] the competitor had not sown”.

“It appears that a deeper foray into competition law to misappropriation leads to a much better remedy option, which is a misappropriation of a competitor’s performance or product.”

This is not the first time that Woolworths has been accused of stealing from small businesses. In 2012, the Advertising Standards Authority ruled in favour of Frankies owner Mike Schmidt, who said that the company had imitated the look and flavours of his retro drinks.

In 2013, freelance watercolour artist and designer Euodia Roets accused Woolworths of stealing her hummingbird design for cushions.

Woolworths denied these claims, but it did withdraw the drinks range.

Tebogo Tshwane is an Adamela Trust journalist at the M&G.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Tebogo Tshwane
Tebogo Tshwane

Tebogo Tshwane is an Adamela Trust financial journalism trainee at the Mail & Guardian. She was previously a general news intern at Eyewitness News and a current affairs show presenter at the Voice of Wits FM. Tshwane is passionate about socioeconomic issues and understanding how macroeconomic activities affect ordinary people. She holds a journalism honours degree from Wits University. 

Related stories

It’s vital to get the Copyright Amendment Bill right

The currently proposed hybrid ‘fair use’ principle does not do nearly enough to protect artists, and will bankrupt them if it forces them to litigate each instance of copyright infringement

Corruption allegations: It’s a family affair at Dihlabeng municipality

The mayor, her relatives and their friends keep landing lucrative tenders and using state resources. Yet Lindiwe Makhalema has failed to declare the list of her relationships with people and companies benefiting from the municipality

Behind Ramaphosa’s rejection of the Copyright Bill

The poorly conceptualised and materially flawed proposed legislation was patched up instead of being rewritten. It will now go to Parliament, which should reject the Bill as unfixable

Coronavirus hammers global growth 

South Africa’s mining and manufacturing sectors are predicted to be down for the first quarter of 2020 because of low demand from China 

Dear Cyril, sign the Copyright Amendment Bill

Reasonable time has now passed for you to act, say the signatories of this open letter to the president and Cabinet ministers

USAf’s Copyright Bill rebuttal raises questions and answers none

Bawa’s response misses the point completely. Furthermore, it seem USAf does not represent the position of all South African universities on this issue

Subscribers only

Toxic power struggle hits public works

With infighting and allegations of corruption and poor planning, the department’s top management looks like a scene from ‘Survivor’

Free State branches gun for Ace

Parts of the provincial ANC will target their former premier, Magashule, and the Free State PEC in a rolling mass action campaign

More top stories

Why anti-corruption campaigns are bad for democracy

Such campaigns can draw attention to the widespread presence of the very behaviour they are trying to stamp out — and subconsciously encourage people to view it as appropriate

Tax, wage bill, debt, pandemic: Mboweni’s tightrope budget policy statement

The finance minister has to close the jaws of the hippo and he’s likely to do this by tightening the country’s belt, again.

SA justice delays extradition of paedophile to UK

Efforts to bring Lee Nigel Tucker to justice have spanned 16 years and his alleged victims have waited for 30 years

Former state security minister Bongo back in court

Bongo and his co-accused will appear in the Nelspruit magistrate’s court in Mpumalanga over charges of fraud, corruption and theft

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday