PIC man digs himself a deep hole

Former Public Investment Corporation (PIC) head of risk and compliance Paul Magula could find himself in hot water as details emerge that he might have misled the commission of inquiry into the state asset manager when he testified this week.

Magula, who sat on the board of the now defunct VBS Mutual Bank as a non-executive representative of the PIC, told the inquiry on Monday that he had only learned about the fraudulent activities, bribes and fictitious deposits at VBS when he appeared before advocate Terry Motau SC’s forensic investigators on June 8 last year.

The PIC had a 25% shareholding in the bank.

Motau was appointed by the South African Reserve Bank to investigate allegations of fraud at the bank. In his report, titled The Great Bank Heist, Motau found that there had been “wide-scale looting and pillaging of the monies placed on deposit at VBS”.

This week, Magula told the PIC commission: “I have never participated in any illegal, fraudulent activities during my tenure as a VBS board member. Some of the things like fictitious deposits, fraudulent withdrawals, bribes, et cetera, that are said to have happened at the VBS I got to know about when I went before the prudent authority’s [Reserve Bank’s] forensic investigators. I am willing and ready to subject myself and co-operate with the law enforcement agencies.”


But Magula, who is also a subject of a criminal investigation by the Hawks and who was fired for incompetence by the PIC in April last year, seems to have been economical with the truth about his role in the looting of VBS. According to the transcript of an interview with former VBS chief executive Andile Ramavhunga, he accepted gratuities from the bank through Vele in return for turning a blind eye to its illegal activities.

Magula declined to comment when contacted and said it was better for the law to take its course.

During a marathon grilling at the Motau hearing by evidence leader advocate Ross Hutton SC on June 8, Magula confessed to receiving R7.6-million in bribes. These details are confirmed in a transcript of Ramavhunga’s interview when he appeared before Motau on July 13 last year.

Ramavhunga, who allegedly unlawfully received R15-million from Vele, attached the transcript in his audacious Constitutional Court application against Motau, the Reserve Bank and Justice Minister Michael Masutha to have the investigation declared unlawful and for the court to rule that Motau had acted beyond his powers.

In Ramavhunga’s transcript, when Hutton was cross-examining him, Hutton said Magula initially made up stories claiming that the monies he had received were loans and money he had borrowed from the then VBS chairperson, Tshifhiwa Matodzi.

“Mr Magula came here and he defended himself for almost an entire day. He gave us a false story; he told us that he borrowed money from Mr Matodzi to repay a young man who had, through his company, Hakema, lent him money. He stuck to that story until about 15h30 in the afternoon, and eventually, when the weight of the evidence that demonstrated that his story was absurd in every material respect, and that his story was extraordinarily improbable, he then said, ‘I want to tell the truth’,” Hutton said during an interview with Ramavhunga.

According to the transcript, Hutton said Magula apologised for giving false evidence and requested immunity.

“He had spent the whole day lying and the weight of his lie ultimately forced his conscience to tell the truth and he confessed to receiving bribes of R7.6-million in total. They were receiving those bribes in the same amounts and on the same days that you received what you [Ramavhunga] say was the petroleum money,” Hutton said to Ramavhunga.

A reliable source has confirmed Hutton’s claims about Magula’s confessions, adding that Magula confessed to receiving various amounts of monies, ranging
from R150 000 to R2.8-million, through an entity called Investar from VBS’s major shareholder, Vele, between December 2016 and February 2018.

The source revealed that Magula also admitted to benefiting from further payments ranging from R300 000 to R1-million that were paid into Hekima Capital, whose registered business address is Magula’s home address.

Magula confessed that the two companies, Hekima Capital and Investar, were vehicles created for his benefit and that they were also set up for future purposes as advisory companies.

Meanwhile, Ramavhunga wants the Constitutional Court to order that section 140(1)(b) of the Financial Sector Regulation Act is “irreconcilable [with] the Constitution”. The section allows an investigator like Motau to subpoena evidence even if the evidence may incriminate someone.

He also wants the court to declare that the terms of reference guiding the Motau investigation unconstitutional.

“In awarding the powers reflected at the certificate of appointment, the second respondent [the Reserve Bank] has, in effect, granted prosecuting and executive powers to the investigator and his team, which ought to be executed by the South African Police Services, in terms of the separation of powers,” Ramavhunga said in his court papers.

He also argued that the investigation did not afford a subpoenaed person an opportunity to “re-examination by a legal representative so as to correct any inaccuracies”.

Ramavhunga said what he had disclosed to Motau had been used to sequestrate him provisionally and that there was a likelihood that “the prosecuting authority will likely have regard to the finding of the investigator”.

But, in his answering court papers, Reserve Bank chief executive Kuben Naidoo said there was nothing unlawful about the VBS investigation.

“The investigation uncovered evidence of fraud and corruption in the conduct of VBS’s business. However, the investigator’s powers were limited to reporting on that evidence and then making recommendations for the further steps that may be taken,” he said. “The investigator’s recommendations include that charges should be laid against individuals implicated in the report and that the report be made available to law enforcement agencies.”

Naidoo said Ramavhunga’s application could not undo the evidence that was given and reverse the answers he gave during Motau’s investigation. He also said the application was defective because it didn’t cite the right minister [the finance minister, rather than the justice minister] and that it failed to disclose a course of action because it challenged the lawfulness of administrative action without referring to the provisions of the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Thanduxolo Jika
Thanduxolo Jika

Thanduxolo Jika is an investigative Journalist and Co-Author of We are going to kill each other today:The Marikana Story. The Messiah of Abantu.

Related stories

South Africa gets $4.3bn IMF loan. In return, the country must reform

The loan, which is repayable over five years at an interest rate of 1.1%, comes with various self-imposed conditions such cutting the public wage bill and rationalising support to the state-owned entities

All agree: Use pension funds

The state wants to increase spending on infrastructure to drive economic recovery, and South Africans’ savings could help foot the bill

ANC wants pension funds to finance infrastructure build

The party released its plan for the reconstruction of the country’s post-coronavirus economy on Friday. This would involve changes to Regulation 28 of the Pension Funds Act

The case against Floyd Shivambu

The flow of money from VBS Bank would seem to suggest that the EFF’s second-in-command was an ultimate beneficiary of proceeds of a crime

SA’s economy expected to contract by 7.2% in 2020

The economy is in a depressed state, and Finance Minister Tito Mboweni has called for cautious use of the country’s finances to avert plunging into a sovereign debt crisis

Out of our Wits: Should more be done to block club sales?

South African football is in an awkward position where it dare not refuse investment … no matter the cost
Advertising

Vaccine trial results due in December

If successful, it will then have to be manufactured and distributed

White men still rule and earn more

Women and black people occupy only a few seats at the JSE table, the latest PwC report has found

The PPE scandal that the Treasury hasn’t touched

Many government officials have been talking tough about dealing with rampant corruption in PPE procurement but the majority won't even release names of who has benefited from the R10-billion spend

ANC still at odds over how to tackle leaders facing...

The ANC’s top six has been mandated to work closely with its integrity committee to tackle claims of corruption against senior party members
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday