Review: Thandi Ntuli’s double consciousness on ‘Live at Jazzwerkstatt’

There are maps to the Door of No Return. The physical door. They are well worn, gone over by cartographer after cartographer, refined from Ptolemy’s Geographia to orbital photographs and magnetic field imaging satellites. But to the Door of No Return which is illuminated in the consciousness of Blacks in the Diaspora there are no maps. This door is not mere physicality. It is a spiritual location. It is also perhaps a psychic destination. Since leaving was never voluntary, return was, and still may be, an intention, however deeply buried. There is as it says no way in; no return.

A Map to the Door of No Return, Dionne Brand

The loop, or noose, of displacement is exacting in its grip. And yet, the will to live dictates that we struggle for room to breath. This analogy, applied in reference to both form and intent, seems to find easy correlation with Thandi Ntuli’s new album, Live at Jazzwerkstatt .

The artist, coming off the back of her breakthrough second album, Exiled, continues the trajectory of facing her limitations and fears head on.  The tenacity on show is infectious, enabling Ntuli to cover what is, for her, novel ground in terms of compositional scope.

Recorded in early 2019 in Bern, Switzerland, the album sees the pianist performing with a group she named the Thandi Ntuli Art Ensemble, a 14-strong unit including brass and string sections with whom she workshopped the new arrangements, as part of this artist-led festival package.

Following so closely on Exiled, Live at Jazzwerkstatt inevitably functions as a pivot, with the artist taking the opportunity to recontextulise the narrative thrust and tenor of her earlier album’s sprawl. “The thing I found most challenging [with Exiled] was not so much what I was trying musically — although some of it was because I felt there were things that didn’t fall into what jazz was supposed to be; the story felt close, and putting the story across was challenging in terms of the vulnerability it demanded of me. With music, there is always a vulnerability, but words solidify ideas to a point where you can’t leave it to the imagination.”

Ntuli says she found validation in the reception of some of the spoken word interventions, in particular those of Lebo Mashile, although she had been hesitant to include the poet’s words, worrying that she’d be seen as combative or didactic. Mashile’s performance on The Void is as devastating in its execution as it is in its imagery; gathering momentum in its epic sweep, seeming to flow from within the bowels of the feathery, flute-driven score as opposed to skirting languidly on top of it. 

Conjuring images of “boys who hide inside their minds, who run across borders, who live in dimensions that should have remained in the womb”, it is an emotional high point of Exiled, message and medium forming one perfect storm. “Lebo’s approach to it liberated me by giving me the courage to put out things that might not be taken so well,” Ntuli says. “I’ve been amazed to see how many men  have taken to that poem, even though I thought it might touch a raw nerve with them. Sometimes you think you are so compassionate by not saying certain things …” 

Building a compositional vocabulary

Similarly, Live at Jazzwerkstatt deploys spoken word as a storytelling aide, using the form as part of an arsenal of compositional weapons. “When I approach arranging, I’m always thinking about what the song is saying and how the instruments at my disposal help me convey it,” she says.

Given the format of the Jazzwerkstatt festival, in which artists get to choose their preferred collaborations from a common pool of talent (with guidance from the festival personnel), Ntuli was able to pick from a list of musicians who would, more or less, fit her own musical sensibility. She had sent some music five weeks ahead of showtime, and had two days of rehearsals when meeting the unit face to face. 

From here, she faced the challenge of writing string and brass parts head on. “It was my first time writing for strings,” Ntuli says. “There were a lot of mistakes on the score. But they were very attentive to what I was feeding out, checking [in] — “Is this is what you intended to write?” —  and they would feed back with ideas. Someone who was the section leader ended up communicating to the string section that they had to reinterpret what was written. The notes were there, but in terms of how to play what was there, that was all workshopped.”

Ntuli says bassist Shane Cooper, with whom they’ve shared many a bandstand, was key in helping to orientate drummer Rico Baumann around a workable sense of groove. “I met him at the festival for the first time — I was watching videos of drummers who were available,” she says. “Knowing what type of music he’s into, if I had come across someone who is into straight-ahead and nothing else, it wouldn’t have been a good fit for my music. He kept coming to me even after rehearsal, checking in with what I was thinking about in terms of the groove. He’d been listening to Sphelelo [Mazibuko] who is on the album [Exiled].”

On Live at Jazzwerkstatt, Baumann plays with a great dynamism, disappearing into the soft spaces and lurching with a unique gait into the segments that require more brawn — a little diagonal to Mazibuko’s tidal flows of rhythm. All the while, Cooper provides intuitive foundational beds for him to land on.

All this deliberate groundwork serves what is, essentially, a circular narrative; one in which the present tries to outrun the past, but keeps coming up short.

A darker meta-narrative

Within the  story of Ntuli’s personal search for a multidimensional voice, is a darker meta-narrative about a people entrapped by flag freedom. Ntuli and the ensemble  — sonically and lyrically — gesture at the promises of the new country, even signifying an optimism, a desire to meet its ideals halfway. Musically, there is a logical linearity to the sequencing, a blooming of hope in narrative terms, but, metaphorically, this too is soon kicked to the ground. 

For example, there is a double consciousness suggested by the ebullient sonic register of  Rainbow (Live), on the one hand, and its jaded lyrics on the other.

I see a rainbow with colours soiled, exchange of promise the sale is void.

Who was the painter that changed its face, took all your heros to give it fame? They talk of freedom, what do they know? This integration is all for show.

Recorded at Jazzwerkstatt in Switzerland, the album recontextualises the themes explored in her previous album Exiled (Image: Lunga Ntila)

No understanding inherit blood, and when the bomb ticks rebuild those walls.”

It is a disappointment and doubt suggested by the breakdowns and the twists in the music, neutering the initial  optimism of the new country’s incoherent foundational myth.

The take-aways from the project have been numerous for Ntuli, especially given that she didn’t walk into the process expecting to walk out with a live album (it all happened sort of retrospectively). Among the nuggets is a sense of having achieved a new set of skills with which to return to the studio. “When you think of [re]arranging music, that’s how producers think in studio, but they have a lot of tools available to them. I feel this tunes me more into that kind of element. It felt like a production: the music was not just melodies and solos, but it brought the feelings along richly.”

The radiance of this turn has been enough for Ntuli to temper the Covid-19 blues, somewhat; taking a part in some live-streamed concerts, but still allowing herself time to ponder what it all means, while also flexing her pen for other artists. 

“I must honestly say that I don’t enjoy it, per se,” she says of streamed gigs. “I find it very hard to imagine energy that is not there. It almost feels like rehearsing a conversation with someone who is not there and imagining their responses. The vitality of an audience: you sense it when you play for different crowds. They feel different, and yet we don’t think of the audience as a vital part. How do I unlearn this part of what an audience/performance used to be?”

Whatever the future holds, and however long the future is held hostage, Ntuli is not worried about falling off the radar. “People have been relying on doccies, series, books — whatever it is — artistic things to keep themselves balanced. I’m worried about making sure we get through this and being able to help people.  I foresee a need for what we do as artists, for whatever after corona is.”

Live at Jazzwerkstatt is released by Ndlela Music Company and is available on digital music platforms.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Kwanele Sosibo
Kwanele Sosibo
Kwanele Sosibo is the editor of Friday, the arts and culture section of the Mail and Guardian.

Related stories

‘Before Night Falls’: Reinaldo Arenas breaks down (in) Fidel Castro’s Cuba

Reinaldo Arenas’s memoir reveals the contradiction of a revolutionary society ruled by an autocrat

Myesha Jenkins: A sister who always said it with feeling

Poet and activist Myesha Jenkins (1948-2020) took her craft, including her teaching, extremely seriously

The Portfolio: Naftali

Naftali has just released his debut single, ‘Kea Shwa’. He tells us a bit about his music-making journey.

George Hallett: Nomad, raconteur and photographer who ‘became the camera’

The renowned South African photographer understood how to look for the tucked-away spaces that were the sources of both light and dark

A place called home: Jazz and the new normal at the National Arts Festival

Several jazz offerings at the virtual festival focus on journeys and identity

Writers on lockdown

Melinda Ferguson has gathered essays and stories from 40-plus contributors for Corona Chronicles

Subscribers only

Toxic power struggle hits public works

With infighting and allegations of corruption and poor planning, the department’s top management looks like a scene from ‘Survivor’

Free State branches gun for Ace

Parts of the provincial ANC will target their former premier, Magashule, and the Free State PEC in a rolling mass action campaign

More top stories

Why anti-corruption campaigns are bad for democracy

Such campaigns can draw attention to the widespread presence of the very behaviour they are trying to stamp out — and subconsciously encourage people to view it as appropriate

Tax, wage bill, debt, pandemic: Mboweni’s tightrope budget policy statement

The finance minister has to close the jaws of the hippo and he’s likely to do this by tightening the country’s belt, again.

SA justice delays extradition of paedophile to UK

Efforts to bring Lee Nigel Tucker to justice have spanned 16 years and his alleged victims have waited for 30 years

Former state security minister Bongo back in court

Bongo and his co-accused will appear in the Nelspruit magistrate’s court in Mpumalanga over charges of fraud, corruption and theft

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday