Zondo commission: Glencore sold Optimum to portray me as a Gupta ally — Molefe

Former Eskom chief executive Brian Molefe on Tuesday claimed at the Zondo commission that Glencore off-loaded Optimum Coal Mine in a plot to paint him as a Gupta ally. He also tried to revive his recent allegations that President Cyril Ramaphosa had acted at the behest of the mining giant.

Molefe returned to the witness stand for the first time since mid-January, when he accused Ramaphosa of undermining Eskom, and the country, for the sake of his business interests in the mining sector.

On Tuesday, Molefe again sought to steer his exchange with evidence leader Pule Seleka and Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo towards the historical links of the then deputy president in 2015 with Glencore.

He said he wanted to remind the commission that on 15 January, he made “a substantive allegation” against Ramaphosa, relating to his 9.47% shareholding in Optimum before his return to active politics, and to be assured that “adequate weight” would be attached to it.

Molefe’s words were at times inaudible, but Zondo assured him that his allegations would be treated in the same manner as all others raised before the commission.

Sabotage accusations 

“Mr Molefe, I am surprised that you would think that it is being swept under the carpet, because you said it happened, and you know from your own experience that when a witness says something that implicates somebody in terms of the rules of the commission that person is given a copy of the statement.”

Molefe had, in a long, sweeping statement, accused Ramaphosa of selling the country short and, as head of the Eskom “war room”, sabotaging the work of the company’s executives as they tried to end a particularly bad spell of load-shedding.

His testimony on Tuesday returned to this point in time, when he was newly seconded to the power utility from Transnet, and Glencore and Eskom were involved in a potentially damaging standoff over the terms of the company’s long-running contract to supply the utility’s Hendrina power plant with coal.

Molefe likened Glencore’s negotiating tactics, as it tried to secure a coal price increase, to “holding a gun to my head”, and said he told the company’s executives to go ahead and pull the trigger.

Switching metaphors, he compared the situation to a poker game in which whoever blinked would lose, and said because he stood firm, Glencore eventually agreed to resume supply at the contractual price, but soon afterwards began talks to sell the mine to Tegeta.

“Except, chairperson, now they threw a curveball. They say ‘we are selling the mine to the Guptas’,” Molefe said. 

“That was a masterstroke because they were so angry with us, they were now going to start a campaign to finger Eskom, to taint us as Gupta people.”

According to Molefe, this was revenge for his refusal to “be bullied into acting against the interests of Eskom”.

“They sold the mine to the Guptas. I did not make them sell the mine to the Guptas. They sold the mine to the Guptas [of] their own accord,” he said.

State of Capture report

Molefe said then public protector Thuli Madonsela’s 2016 report, “State of Capture”, which called for the commission to be established, was part of this deliberate narrative to compromise himself and others.

Madonsela found that Eskom executives, including Molefe, went out of their way to enable Tegeta’s acquisition of the mine.

 Madonsela, with the help of Molefe’s cellphone records, found that he had spoken to one of the Gupta brothers 44 times and visited the family Saxonwold home 19 times.

The report contributed to Molefe’s tearful resignation from Eskom later that year.

On Tuesday, Molefe said Madonsela had failed to interview the people at Eskom she implicated.

“[Suddenly] the public protector came up with her report. She did not interview us, she interviewed Mr [Clinton] Effron. Mr Effron went to her to complain about us, and she instituted that report. There was a media campaign, chairperson, … to rubbish us as people who are controlled by the Guptas.”

The aim was to create a narrative that Eskom had forced Glencore to sell the mine to the Gupta empire and to find any evidence that linked the utility’s executives to the family, Molefe claimed.

“Any scrap of evidence that you were next to the Guptas at any point. I see in this commission, there is an allegation that I was in an aeroplane that had the Guptas. I was flying, I was on my way to a Brics meeting, and they happened to be in the same aeroplane,” he said.

On 15 January, Molefe blamed Eskom’s woes on Glencore trying to extract R8-billion from the company in price increases and penalty waivers after it bought Optimum without due diligence and locked itself into a disadvantageous pricing structure.

He said the company was banking on Ramaphosa’s political clout to resolve the problem in its favour, and went on to accuse the president of playing along, with devastating consequences for Eskom that included a protracted return to load-shedding.

Molefe’s allegations have proven politically useful to Ramaphosa’s foes in the factional battle raging within the ANC. 

In early February, Ernest Netshivhumbe laid charges of fraud, theft and contravening the Public Finance Management Act against Ramaphosa on the basis of Molefe’s testimony to the commission.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories


Subscribers only

No mercy for teachers who are found guilty of misconduct

New regulations give direction on what sanctions should be imposed on disgraceful teachers, including lifetime bans for serious offences

There is less full-time work than there was a year...

Over the last year, amid lockdowns and recession, the number of part-time jobs increased while full-time jobs took a cut in South Africa

More top stories

IMF launches interactive climate dashboard

South Africa’s climate change transition risk is 5.6 on a scale of one to 10, with 10 being the highest

Climate change threatens survival of endemic species the most

If Earth warms by 3°C, a third of species living on land and about half of endemic marine species will become extinct

Anger as Ace alters step-aside rules

Outraged provincial secretaries called for a meeting with Luthuli House after the ANC secretary general broadened the NEC’s step-aside resolution

Food delivery drivers seek better employee rights

A group of South African Uber drivers plan to go to court to seek employee rights including compensation for overtime and holiday pay, hoping for a similar victory to that of British drivers in March

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…