Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Critique of Herman Mashaba is unwarranted


An old adage of inspiration is that the person who says it is impossible should not interrupt the person doing it. Of course, no motion for betterment goes unopposed, and for the most part, I’d say that a fire truck would be silly to stop and deal with cur dogs barking at the wheels, but never before have I seen such a poor take of such a promising proposition. The irony is lost on Mr Anthony Johnson, an American-based writer, when he offers a political critique on South Africa in “Herman Mashaba wants you to forget” (Mail & Guardian, August 9) while his country burns as the gears of its two-party system grind and rust.

That Mashaba’s time as a mayor can be quantified in figures is of little interest to his naysayers; over 800 corrupt and incompetent government officials removed from office, 5 000 title deeds delivered to Johannesburg’s poorest residents, an administration that finally addressed Johannesburg’s lucrative yet crumbling infrastructure by fixing its roads, 151-million litres of water tanks built in informal settlements, R341-million brought in by Mashaba’s law-enforcement unit, and all this under the weight of a corrupt ANC, and a Democratic Alliance that would rather he spend his time bringing lawns up to their standard than fight the corrupt system he’d inherited. 

It would be in poor taste for Mashaba to attempt to make us forget, as Johnson posits: we’d be much better off remembering what Johannesburg was like under a mayor who was actually competent and who was not hell-bent on robbing the country’s resources, as is so clearly the intent of the ANC. If he were capable of accomplishing all that he did under two oppressive regimes, his potential in an independent party is almost unimaginable. 

Johnson criticises Mashaba on three areas: trying to evict illegal occupants of buildings, trying to enforce the law and trying to help the poor — although, none of these to his standards. Perhaps we should look to the United States for their unparalleled genius in managing their poor population, or their lenient policing system. 

In between all of this, Johnson is correct in that Mashaba did not make as much progress as he, or any of his adherents, would have liked. Yet it would be ignorant to focus on the shortcomings, rather than the fact that Mashaba is one of the only honest politicians we have. It’s noble to try and fail, and, seeing where he’d failed, Mashaba took the correct course of action — he formed his own party. The DA is stringent and delusional, imagining a South Africa that resembles their dream of a white-Socialist-European “utopia” whereas the ANC is a money-hungry beast who cannot fill its pockets with tax and bailout money fast enough. To sit on the sidelines and project political shortcomings on to a man whose intentions have been proven pure, whose policies are demonstrably workable and whose experience in the area has shown him competent, would be the height of apathy.

There is no such thing as a perfect politician and, ultimately, the solutions we seek will not be found in politics, but within ourselves. Still, a good government can help. Mashaba’s policies are simple, they’re understandable and they are objectively workable: fix corruption, fix education, restore law and order, insist upon legal immigration, reform this country’s broken electoral system and incentivise the private sector to bring jobs back. Mashaba has laid out workable ideas on how all this could be accomplished. I’d rather back him up than ponder upon the difficulty of trying to better a city under the bureaucracy of the ANC or the DA.

Angelo Ryan is a South African-based freelance journalist who has covered local and American politics since 2015. He has followed Herman Mashaba since his tenure as Mayor of Johannesburg and has been backing his bid for presidency pending the launch of his party later this month. 

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and receive a 40% discount on our annual rate..

Angelo Ryan
Angelo Ryan is a South African-based freelance journalist who has covered local and American politics since 2015. He has followed Herman Mashaba since his tenure as Mayor of Johannesburg and has been backing his bid for presidency pending the launch of his party.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Shanduka shade over Free State education

Audit firm PwC said R500-million irregular expenditure incurred by the Free State education department is related to an unsolicited bid by the Kagiso Shanduka Trust to improve schools

101 party elders dominate appeals body presiding over Magashule appeal

That the majority of those who form part of the ANC’s appeals body will come from 101 elders - which faction will have the upper hand

More top stories

New consortium scores big in South Africa’s floating power station...

Powergroup South Africa wins 20-year energy contract a mere 10 months after it was formed

Fickle funding for women-led startups hurts femtech

It is difficult for startups to get off the ground, especially when they are women-focused

Semenya magic rubs off on Glenrose Xaba

Long-distance runner Glenrose Xaba ran the third-fastest time by a South African woman on home soil, winning the SA Half-Marathon

Education department to run campaign against bullying

Incidents of violence and bullying at schools have been on the spotlight recently

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…