What is reconciliation in the South African context?

The word “reconciliation” is often used in our public discourse. In many instances it is used synonymously with the term “transformation”. This highlights some of the ambiguity which exists about the meaning of the term. This presents us with a number of challenges, which include linguistic misunderstanding and as a consequence, how we measure progress.

If one looks at the information from the South African Reconciliation Barometer, this confusion is apparent. In 2021, there were 16 different understandings of the concept. At the top of the list is the understanding of reconciliation as forgiveness. This is understandable but problematic. 

An Ipsos Mori poll of 2017 showed 88% of South Africans say that religion is important to their lives. We are a country with deep spiritual roots and it is thus not surprising that reconciliation is linked to forgiveness. Christianity is the largest religion and, following that tradition, forgiveness of others is seen as an important precondition to forgiveness of self (“Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive the trespasses of others”). 

This link was heightened with the association of Archbishop Desmond Tutu with the truth and reconciliation process. The association between religious understanding of forgiveness and reconciliation was indelibly etched onto the national consciousness. 

In our context, however, the association is particularly unhelpful. Forgiveness places the burden of work on the oppressed. It is up to those who are wronged to “find it in their heart” to forgive the unspeakable acts committed against them. While some faith traditions emphasise a reciprocal restorative process, this is not always the case. 

This can be seen in the findings of the 2021 reconciliation barometer where 9% of respondents said that only those who were oppressed by apartheid are responsible for reconciliation, and 23% said that mostly those who were oppressed are responsible. This means that about a third of South Africans believe that the onus is on the victims to forgive in order for there to be reconciliation.

In a similar way, “moving on” is seen as the meaning of reconciliation. One quarter of South Africans believe this to be the meaning of reconciliation. While looking to the future is an important element of reconciliation, it can be argued that “moving on” is the result of reconciliation and not the core of what it means. The concerning element of this definition is that “moving on” implies leaving the past behind. This fundamentally ignores the reality of the trauma and wounds that remain unaddressed and unhealed. 

Looking at countries in transition, it is evident that where countries have not dealt with the past, lasting sustainable peace is elusive. One of the key elements of reconciliation needs to be truth-telling and the full exposure of the extent of the abuses which have taken place. Memorialisation and recognition are important aspects of acknowledging what has happened and allowing people to process the atrocities. The Pact of Forgetting in Spain has not resulted in closure, but rather in the lingering of pain and suffering.

It is important to recognise that reconciliation is not one thing: it is a combination of processes which, taken together, have the desired results of addressing the past, building trust, building social cohesion and creating sustainable peace.

In looking at the way in which South Africans view reconciliation, it is important to note that many of the elements of transitional justice are mentioned. Peace, making amends, respect, improving relationships, truth, justice, democracy, addressing racism, retribution, dialogue and memorialisation are all mentioned in the 2021 barometer.

Findings of the 2019 South African Reconciliation Barometer indicated that 77% of South Africans believe that reconciliation is still needed; 66% believe the Truth and Reconciliation Commission was a good foundation for reconciliation; 57% said that progress has been made since the end of apartheid but only 51% indicated that they, their friends of family have experienced reconciliation since the end of apartheid.

These figures indicate that South Africans have a variety of understandings of what reconciliation is, making it difficult to measure progress and success. It can be argued that reconciliation is key to the future of a peaceful, fair, democratic and inclusive society. As such, it is important that as part of our national conversation we discuss what it is and  what it means so that we can develop a common understanding with which we can tackle the legacies of the past.

The views expressed are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the Mail & Guardian.

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Felicity Harrison
Felicity Harrison is the head of department for sustained dialogues at the Institute for Justice and Reconciliation.

Related stories

WELCOME TO YOUR M&G

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

Advertising

Latest stories

Mkhwebane would not hear of Gupta links to Estina: witness

The suspended public protector told him she would pleased if the probe into the scam delivered no adverse findings, Reginald Ndou tells inquiry

Editorial: The ANC won’t listen to its own conscience, the...

The party’s top officials seem to have no real inclination to follow through with the integrity commission’s recommendations on corruption

Nxesi: The changing definition of work demands a review of...

The labour minister noted many informal workers had been excluded from the country’s Covid-19 relief scheme

Tazné van Wyk murder accused admits to absconding parole

Moyhdian Pangkaeker evaded the justice system for about four years during which time he twice absconded while on parole. He faces 27 charges, 24 of which he allegedly committed while on parole.
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×