OWN CORRESPONDENT, Johannesburg | Monday
A US-based “Aids dissident” appointed by President Thabo Mbeki says Africans are not dying from Aids, but from illnesses that have gripped the continent for centuries.
“Africans are suffering and dying from the same things they have been suffering and dying from for generations before Aids. They are not suffering and dying from something new called Aids,” said leading scientist David Rasnick.
Mbeki appointed Rasnick to a presidential advisory panel on HIV-Aids last year and his comments were expected to generate further concern over the country’s approach to Aids.
Mbeki has attracted international condemnation for questioning the causal link between HIV and Aids, denying the use of antiretroviral drugs in the public health system on cost and safety grounds, and by appointing roughly a dozen dissidents to his 33-member panel.
Rasnick said that Aids was neither contagious, sexually transmitted or caused by HIV and that anti-Aids drugs accelerated death or made people sick with Aids.
Rasnick has described the virus as “harmless” and in his submissions to the panel argued that South Africans were now being ruled by the “tyranny” of orthodox science in the same way as the country’s white minority leaders under apartheid.
Rasnick was speaking after the release of an interim report by Mbeki’s panel, which failed to reach a conclusion on what caused Aids and how to combat the epidemic.
The UN estimates that 2.4 million people died of Aids in Africa last year and that 25.3 million people are living with the disease in sub-Saharan Africa alone.
UNAids has described the Aids situation in Africa as “catastrophic”. The health department, which acts on the premise that HIV causes Aids, estimates that 4.7 million South Africans are living with the disease, more than any other country in the world.
Orthodox science has said that the link between HIV and Aids is proven beyond doubt and have urged South Africa to drop the panel and its debate and instead concentrate on tackling the disease.
South Africa’s approach to Aids has also been marred by a row with leading drug firms over the cost of anti-retroviral drugs that could help prolong the lives of people with the disease.
Dissidents such as Rasnick argue that Aids is caused by a breakdown of the human immune system brought on by the use of recreational drugs, anti-Aids drugs or poverty. – Reuters
ZA*NOW:
Aids report: condoms or cucumbers? April 7, 2001
Thabo and Fidel: The Patent-busters March 29, 2001
NAM ministers rally on affordable Aids drugs March 27, 2001
Who head favours generic Aids drugs March 25, 2001
Mbekis panel will question Aids tests March 23, 2001
Aids far deadlier than apartheid March 22, 2001
Is that a light, or an oncoming train? March 21, 2001
Aids group demands government action March 20, 2001
Free test kits could be confusing March 19, 2001
Aids cure ploughed up as a weed March 15, 2001
Admit you lied, Phosa tells ANC March 7, 2001
Generics manufacturer enters the fray March 13, 2001
Red Cross joins Aids drug battle March 13, 2001
Mbeki mulls Aids emergency March 12, 2001
Drug firms ‘being made scapegoats’ March 10, 2001
40% drug price cut not enough March 8, 2001
Drug giants told to justify prices March 7, 2001
Court rejects indefinite drugs trial delay March 6, 2001
Aids sufferers, poor eye landmark case March 6, 2001
Power cuts delay Aids drugs trial March 5, 2001
Patients vs profits as drug wars start March 5, 2000
State, drug giants go head to head March 4, 2000