Neighbourhood watch turns to mob justice

A series of reported mob justice and vigilante incidents has gripped South Africa in recent weeks, fuelling the perception that the once popular “Township Act” for dealing with political spies and hooliganism is on the upsurge.

In one weekend, mob justice incidents left at least four people dead and three injured. By Wednesday, in two separate incidents, members of the public had killed a suspected thief and assaulted two others.

Yet, say researchers, increased media attention does not necessarily reflect an increase in vigilante activity.

Recent reports quoting data from the Independent Complaints Directorate (ICD) depict a rise in vigilantism. The ICD reports that, from March last year to March this year, the number of deaths in police custody as a result of injuries prior to custody rose by 184% to 71 deaths.

But the category of deaths as a result of prior injuries also reflects people who are shot in self-defence by members of the public, explains David Bruce, a senior researcher at the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation (CSVR).

Additionally, the statistic does not measure vigilante acts in which the suspect is dead upon police arrival.

“If you compare levels of vigilantism now with the late 1990s, it has gone down,” says Themba Masuku, another senior CSVR researcher.

The difficulty in monitoring vigilantism is partially a problem of definition.

According to a paper on post-1994 vigilantism by Anthony Minnaar, of the Institute for Human Rights and Criminal Justice Studies at Technikon SA, vigilantism refers to a diversity of acts, ranging from people catching petty thieves, beating them and then handing them to the police, to mobs stoning suspects to death or organised groups assassinating individuals. As community responses to real and perceived inadequacies in policing and the judicial system, they are all acts of vigilantism.

“Vigilantism is a last resort based on the perception that institutions are not delivering,” explains Munuku.

Last Sunday, residents of Olievenhoutbosch, in Tshwane, assaulted three men accused of robbing and raping a woman in a nearby area.

The people responsible for the assault were members of the neighbourhood watch, which residents had formed to help the police combat crime.

One of the committee members, who would only identify himself as Lawrence, recognises the need to educate members of the neighbourhood watch about not assaulting suspects.

Lawrence, trying to contextualise the actions of the committee, says the incident took place in the light of a “judicial system that is not delivering”.

But, says Bruce, the emotional context of vigilantism may prevent the guilt of suspects from being established.

“People are overwhelmed by [anger and frustration] and the need for a proper process to be followed in identifying the person, so innocents are not victimised, goes out the window.”

In one such incident in Khutsong, Carletonville, a mob recently stoned Papi Diale (23) to death, alleging he had stabbed and killed a 17-year-old boy.

“My son was mentally unstable and did not deserve to die like this,” asserts his mother, Pauline Diale, who maintains his innocence.

The Khutsong police have opened a murder case, but no arrests have been made.

Bruce says, according to the orthodox community-policing model, it was envisaged that community members would become involved in community policing forums, “but that this would stop short of direct involvement in policing activities”.

But, he says, police efforts to combat vigilantism may come into conflict with their attempts to build relationships with the community.

“One of the lessons of the past 10 years has been that winning the respect of the community is not just about community structures but [also about] consistent standards on police delivery.”

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Tumi Makgetla
Guest Author

Related stories

Designers with precious mettle

Local jewellery design needs more than creativity to become a vibrant sector of the economy, writes Tumi Makgetla

Bling school welcomes you

Tumi Makgetla profiles Intsika, a jewellery school in the East Rand

Botswana’s small step for fashion

Tumi Makgetla speaks to fashion designer Mpho Kuaho from Botswana who has dressed models for the Durban July horse race.

The true measure of a latté

The flush <i>Mail & Guardian</i> reader might not mind spending almost R40 in Angola on his or her favourite weekly newspaper, but he or she would get better value in Malawi, where the paper is only R12,96. In South Africa the <i>M&G</i> costs R14,90. Looking at the purchasing power of different currencies can provide a more meaningful understanding of how they compare than the official exchange rate.

Single currency for Southern Africa?

The same currency will be traded from Kinshasa to Kimberley, if the vision of the Southern African Development Community (SADC) is realised. The SADC hopes to create a free trade area by 2008, a customs union by 2010, a common market by 2015 and an economic and monetary union by 2018. As envisaged, the monetary union would resemble the European Union.

‘Our demands are simple and straightforward’

Public servants expressed their determination to continue their indefinite strike this week, closing down schools across the country and interrupting hospital and other government services. Union organisers planned to "shut down the government" on Friday, buoyed by support from the Congress of South African Trade Unions central executive committee.

Sekhukhune’s five-year battle for water back in court

The residents of five villages are calling for the district municipal manager to be arrested

Vaccine trial results due in December

If successful, it will then have to be manufactured and distributed

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday