Marriage Bill causes rift among Muslims

The split in South Africa’s Muslim community over the Muslim Marriages Bill is deepening. The Bill seeks to regulate Islamic marriages.

In recent weeks unnamed groups have handed out pamphlets in mosques and sent out text messages and emails to community members, calling on them to “oppose the Kufr (unbeliever’s) Bill.”

This week the Muslim Lawyers’ Association also came out in staunch opposition to the Bill, which is being processed by Parliament. In a submission to the South African Law Reform Commission, the association calls the Bill “unconstitutional at its core”, adding that it is “fundamentally opposed to the Bill” because it “alters Islamic law through impermissible state regulation”.

The association opposes the adjudication of Muslim marriage disputes by secular courts and argues that the Bill seeks to alter Muslim personal law. Its position is supported by, among others, the Muslim Women’s Association and the Majlis, which is the religious authority in the Eastern Cape.

But Waheeda Amien, a member of the Recognition of Muslim Marriages Forum, argued that opponents of the Bill feared the erosion of patriarchal power. “The main reason that this Bill is being proposed is that many men do not honour their obligations under Sharia law,” Amien said. “They fail to maintain their wives and children, they abuse their wives, they talaq (divorce) their wives arbitrarily and without notice and they enter into polygamous marriages without being able to treat their wives equally.

‘Abuses discontinued’
“The Bill seeks to ensure that such rights abuses are discontinued within our community. For example, the Bill requires a man to apply to court if he wishes to take a subsequent wife. The reason for this is to ensure that the husband can show that he can treat his wives equally, as required by the Qur’an.”

Amien insisted that the association’s claim that the Bill is not Sharia-compliant was baseless. “It seeks to regulate Muslim marriages within a Sharia framework,” she said. If women approached the Ulema (Islamic authorities) for help and failed to get it, they had no means of enforcing the law, she said.

Jennifer Williams, director of the Women’s Legal Centre, said that women suffered daily because of the lack of enforceable legal remedies and reform was urgently needed. “It is preferable to develop the law on these marriages in holistic legislation passed by Parliament than for the courts to do it piecemeal.” Williams said that women often approached her centre facing eviction “with only the clothes on their back. As their marriages are not recognised, they cannot approach the courts for a divorce, redistribution of assets or the right to stay on in the ‘marital’ home.”

But the association’s attorney, Yousha Tayob, said: “We don’t want Muslim marriages regulated and determined by non-Muslim people. [They] can never have an understanding of Sharia law. It’s not that we don’t recognise that there are problems, but this Bill will not cure them.”

Tayob said the fact that religious figures of authority made decisions on marital issues without having women’s rights in mind was “a problem that lies with individuals”. But this is based in “extreme idealism”, argued Moulana Taha Karaan of the Muslim Judicial Council. “It is admirable, but ignores the fact that the realism of Islamic law is that you need enforceability. We don’t live in a Utopia.”

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Q&A Sessions: Marcia Mayaba —Driven to open doors for women

Marcia Mayaba has been in the motor industry for 24 years, donning hats that include receptionist, driver, fuel attendant, dealer principal and now chief...

The war on women in video game culture

Women and girls make up almost half of the gaming community but are hardly represented and face abuse in the industry

More top stories

#SayHerName: The faces of South Africa’s femicide epidemic

This is an ode to the women whose names made it into news outlets from 2018 to 2020. It’s also a tribute to the faceless, nameless women whose stories remain untold.

Judges Rammaka Mathopo and Mahube Molemela among five candidates for...

Judges Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane, Jody Kollapen and Bashier Vally complete the list, while Dhaya Pillay fails to make the cut

First sanitary pad vending machine in Africa aims to end...

A new invention by the MENstruation Foundation addresses the difficulty many schoolgirls face every month — not being able to afford sanitary products

A new era of vaccine sovereignty in Africa beckons

COMMENT: The AU has laid out a clear path for the continent to produce its own vaccines

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…