Flush with success: Controversy pulls in SA’s voters

The unprecedented turnout of almost 57% for the municipal elections — the highest ever for an election of this nature in South Africa — can be attributed to an exciting election campaign and the tight contests that were expected in key areas, analysts and politicians say.

At 2pm on Thursday, 51 642 of 58 158 result slips had been captured by the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC). That constituted 71,1% of the results that by then had been released. “Preliminary voter turnout based on results released thus far [2pm Thursday] stands at 56,4% and spoilt ballots at 1,96%,” said IEC chief executive Pansy Tlakula.

At 4pm on Thursday, when 71% of the votes had been counted, the highest turnout was in the Western Cape, where 64,9% of registered voters came out to vote, while only 44,31% of registered voters in Limpopo went to the ballot box.

Overall, the ANC had secured 62,5% of the votes, the Democratic Alliance 23,3% and Congress of the People 2,4%. The Inkatha Freedom Party received 3.6% and its breakaway party, the National Freedom Party, secured 2,4% of the votes.

In the previous local government elections held in 2006, the ANC won 66,3% of the vote, the DA 14,8%, the IFP 8,1% and the then almost defunct Independent Democrats 2%. According to Wits University political analyst Susan Booysen, controversies such as the “toilet wars” and “politicians on all sides embarrassing themselves” made this election the most exciting municipal election South Africa has ever seen.

“It was a high-profile campaign about different issues and people are unhappy. If you think your vote will make a difference, you’ll vote,” Booysen said. ANC secretary general Gwede Mantashe told the Mail & Guardian that South Africans tend to become more politically active when the going gets tough, in spite of political theory that prescribes that voters tend to stay away in such circumstances.

The DA won traditionally black wards in Mpumalanga (2), North West (1) and Limpopo (1).

“It does show the DA is cracking the glass ceiling of race,” said Justin Sylvester, a researcher at Idasa.

For Booysen, the DA “had not managed to penetrate the ANC fortress” but the party would build on small gains to extend its black support. “It will parade these results like it parades Midvaal and use it to further bite into ANC support. But all in all, it is a small result for a very big campaign,” she said.

Unconfirmed reports at the time of going to print said the DA had lost two seats in the Johannesburg metro and two more in Ekurhuleni. Results from Soweto were not available.

The DA did, however, secure most of the municipalities in the Western Cape, taking Saldahna, Hessequa, Knysna and Langeberg from the ANC and retaining Baviaanskloof in the Eastern Cape. This was because the of “coloured vote” outside Cape Town, Sylvester said. “It is the effect of Cape Town, which is now catching on to people who live further away from it.”

Of the Western Cape municipalities, the ANC had at the time of going to print secured only Oudtshoorn and Beaufort West, where controversial former mayor Truman Prince is on the ANC’s proportional representation list. Bitou (Plettenberg Bay) was tied between the ANC and the DA.

Only 2,4% of the support the ANC dropped went to the DA and Cope remained the largest reason for the ANC decline in some areas, Booysen said. Although Cope had secured only 2,4% of the vote by Thursday afternoon, it will be the kingmaker in at least one municipality in the Northern Cape: Hantam was declared a tie between the DA and the ANC.

All metros except for Cape Town remained in ANC hands, while Cape Town was expected to secure an outright majority of 52%. The highly contested Nelson Mandela Bay was retained by the ANC with about 51%.

“We won all the metros except Cape Town, even the new ones,” Mantashe confidently declared on Thursday.

Early on Thursday morning, the voter turnout in Mpumalanga stood at 9%, causing mild panic among ANC leaders, but it picked up during the course of the day and was about 50% at the time of going to press.

The ANC also retained control of Moutse, the Limpopo town in which residents are demanding to be integrated with Mpumalanga. The ANC secured a landslide victory in Limpopo with 82,77% of the vote. The DA won 6,64%, Cope 3,73% and independent candidates 1,03%.

In the Free State the DA had a better showing with 22,6% but the ANC took more than two-thirds of the vote at 69,47%. In KwaZulu-Natal, the ANC had secured 55,09% of the votes while the IFP managed 19,55% and the National Freedom Party 12,64%.

As the results rolled in on Thursday, the beleaguered IFP’s control of 32 of KwaZulu-Natal’s 61 municipalities was under serious threat. Of the 16 municipalities that the IEC could confirm results for on Thursday afternoon, the IFP had lost its majority in six to the ANC.

To the north of the province, early results suggested that the NFP, which broke away from the IFP, had split the latter’s traditional support base. In Zululand towns such as Vryheid and Phongola, results were running neck and neck between at least two of the three main political protagonists in rural areas of the province. The scene will be set for coalition in several of these rural municipalities.

For exclusively M&G articles and multimedia on the local government elections 2011 click here:

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Mandy Rossouw
Guest Author
Niren Tolsi
Niren Tolsi is a freelance journalist whose interests include social justice, citizen mobilisation and state violence, protest, the Constitution and Constitutional Court, football and Test cricket.
Mmanaledi Mataboge
Guest Author

Related stories


press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday