State legal adviser’s office under fire

As the dust settles after the fracas involving the extension of Chief Justice Sandile ­Ngcobo’s term last week, legal experts are querying the part chief state law adviser Enver Daniels played in the matter and criticising his office.

“The government, over a long period, 10 years or more, appears to get itself into avoidable legal predicaments. It loses far more cases than it wins, at great cost to the public exchequer. Thus, questions have to be asked of those responsible for providing the legal advice,” said Richard Calland, director of the Democratic Governance and Rights Unit at the University of Cape Town.

Last week the Constitutional Court ruled that Section 8(a) of the Judges’ Remuneration and Conditions of Employment Act 2001, the provision President Jacob Zuma invoked in an attempt to extend Ngcobo’s term, was unconstitutional. The court found that the Act delegated to the president the power to extend a chief justice’s term, a power in fact reserved for Parliament of an extension of the Constitution. But by this time, Ngcobo had stepped out of the running by withdrawing his acceptance by his term.

It remains unclear who advised the presidency to invoke section 8(a) of the act. But Daniel’s told the Mail & Guardian that after the attempt to extend Ngcobo’s term and during the litigation, his office did advise the presidency but said it would not be appropriate to comment further on the matter. The office of the chief state law adviser has the task of providing objective, reliable legal advice and legislative drafting services to the state.

Nichola de Havilland, director of the Centre for Con­stitutional Rights, said the 2001 Act, now deemed unconstitutional, was drafted and passed under Daniels.

“The Judges’ Remuneration and Conditions of Employment Act 47 of 2001 was accordingly drafted under his watch and he would have been required to comment on the constitutionality of the Act,” she said.

Daniels was adamant however that the law was drafted entirely by Parliament and did not flow from his office.

“We advise the state on a range of complex and sensitive matters. All our work is subjected to intensive peer review and by the time it reaches parliament we are assured that it will stand up to constitutional muster.”

In recent weeks, Daniels’s services in drafting legislation have come under fire, particularly the position he took on the Protection of Information Bill, currently before Parliament. Many legal experts who made submissions at public hearings deemed the Bill in its original format clearly unconstitutional.

But Daniels has refuted these arguments and was widely quoted in media as calling criticism of the Bill’s constitutionality “hysterical”.

The ANC has subsequently backtracked in Parliament on several matters, including the broad scope of the proposed legislation, key to issues of constitutionality.

“It is foolish for people such as the state law adviser to offer categorical assurances about the constitutionality of a Bill or Act. Only one body — the Constitutional Court — can do so,” said Calland.

Other pieces of draft legislation that have come under fire include the Municipal Property Rates Amendment Bill, which has implications for the amount owners of a second property will pay.

Afriforum has said the Bill may be unconstitutional, as its economic effects could have a direct impact on the ability of South Afri­can’s to access housing, a constitutionally protected right.

MPs process and deliberate on legislation but Daniels must certify the laws.

De Havilland cited other examples of ill-conceived legislation, including the Expropriations Bill, which had to be withdrawn, and the legislation that brought about the dissolution of the elite crime-fighting unit, the Scorpions, in 2008, and the establishment of its replacement, the Hawks.

The Constitutional Court ruled earlier this year that part of the legislation to set up the Hawks was constitutionally invalid, giving Parliament 18 months to remedy the problem. Daniels said his office refused to certify this legislation at the time.

Calland said the record of the state law advisers, like any other public agency, should be scrutinised to ensure the public was getting value for money.

Parliament should scrutinise the unit’s performance, either through the standing committee on public accounts or the portfolio committee on justice and constitutional development, he said.

President Jacob Zuma has nominated Constitutional Court judge Mogoeng Mogoeng as the new Chief Justice. For more news on the controversy surrounding the appointment click here.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Lynley Donnelly
Lynley Donnelly
Lynley is a senior business reporter at the Mail & Guardian. But she has covered everything from social justice to general news to parliament - with the occasional segue into fashion and arts. She keeps coming to work because she loves stories, especially the kind that help people make sense of their world.

Related stories

Fight over chief justice’s Israel comments grows

Last year South Africa closed its embassy in Jerusalem and Africa For Palestine alleged in its complaint that Mogoeng “expressed, or at least unambiguously implied” that this “political posture” was not right

Mogoeng’s Palestine stance calls into question his role at the ConCourt

We can only conclude that he ‘willingly and knowingly lent his personal credibility — and that of his office — to a white-washing of Israeli crimes’

Mogoeng on Israel: Bad faith and ‘impunified disregard’ for international law?

The chief justice needs to publicly account for his comments, by either walking them back or explaining his change of heart on international law and its institutions

R50 000 bail for Durban city manager

Sipho Nzuza had previously agreed to turn state witness

South Sudan’s guns silent – for now

They’ll roar again unless there’s justice for atrocities and the armed forces are reformed

New banks circle small businesses

TymeBank, Bank Zero and Capitec are all looking for ways to woo businesses – including SMMEs – on to their books

Subscribers only

SAA bailout raises more questions

As the government continues to grapple with the troubles facing the airline, it would do well to keep on eye on the impending Denel implosion

ANC’s rogue deployees revealed

Despite 6 300 ANC cadres working in government, the party’s integrity committee has done little to deal with its accused members

More top stories

It’s not a ‘second wave’: Covid resurges because safety measures...

A simple model shows how complacency in South Africa will cause the number of infections to go on an upward trend again

Unisa shortlists two candidates for the vice-chancellor job

The outgoing vice-chancellor’s term has been extended to April to allow for a smooth hand-over

How US foreign policy under Donald Trump has affected Africa

Lesotho has been used as a microcosm in this article to reflect how the foreign policy has affected Africa

Trouble brewing for Kenya’s coffee growers

Kenyan farmers say theft of their crop is endemic – and they suspect collusion

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday