Translation drawn into question in Terre’Blanche trial

The work of a translator who mediated between police and a youth accused of killing right wing leader Eugene Terre’Blanche was called into question in the Ventersdorp High Court on Wednesday.

The boy’s lawyer, Zola Majavu, tried to show how information could be misinterpreted or misunderstood.

The minor and Chris Mahlangu are accused of beating Terre’Blanche to death in his North West farmhouse in April 2010.

Both have pleaded not guilty to murder. Mahlangu claims he acted in self-defence. The teenager has denied involvement in the crime.

Majavu asked Reservist Detective Constable Emmanuel Mthembu to translate phrases from Tswana to Afrikaans, as he would have done when he explained the youth’s rights to him and his mother before the teenager pointed out the crime scenes.

Mthembu struggled to do so correctly at all times. When he translated incorrectly, the court translator explained that Mthembu’s version was not verbatim but a simplified version.

Lost in translation
Majavu was questioning the accuracy of Mthembu’s translations between Lieutenant Colonel Frans Jacobs, the youth and his mother.

Mthembu said he occasionally had to ask Jacobs to clarify what he had said during the translation but he felt the family and youth had understood what was said.

Mthembu admitted that it was possible for some information to have been lost in translation. He also admitted it was the first time he had acted as a translator.

Mthembu was testifying in a trial within a trial to determine the validity of evidence given by the two accused.

Earlier on Wednesday, the minor disputed the signature he purportedly made on a statement to the police.

Majavu said his client denied the signature was his.

Assessment
However, Jacobs, who went with the teenager to point out crime scenes, said he had asked the teenager if the signature was his and he had said it was.

The teenager’s mother had also confirmed it was her fingerprint on the statement as she could not write.

Majavu asked why a probation officer had not been appointed to assess the minor within 24 hours, in accordance with the law, but only after the crime scenes were pointed out.

Sergeant Samuel Kutumela was the last witness to be called on Wednesday.

He read the minor his rights at the Klerksdorp Police Station before he was handed over to Jacobs.

He said he read the certificate containing the rights and thereafter explained it to the youth in Tswana and asked if he understood.

Clarity
“He and I were talking in Tswana. After he said he understood I asked him to sign on the document,” he said.

He said the minor’s mother could not write and therefore police had to take a thumb print as her signature.

They received a copy of the certificate.

Majavu cross-examined Kutumela on his translation of the rights and whether the minor and his mother would have been able to understand the rights which were written in English.

“The accused and his mother understood me very well,” Kutumela said.

The trial continues on Thursday. — Sapa

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Related stories

WELCOME TO YOUR M&G

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

Advertising

Latest stories

South Africa’s moonlight sonata: The illicit cash cow draining specialist...

Specialist doctors at many state facilities aren’t showing up to work despite earning millions a year in taxpayer money. The consequences for patient health can be devastating but not everyone agrees on the solutions

ANC leaders raise alarm over energy crisis

Last week, the country was plunged into stage six load-shedding when Eskom workers went on strike. A wage settlement was reached on Tuesday, but Eskom warned that it will take time to recover

UK PM Johnson on the brink after ministerial resignations

The 58-year-old leader's grip on power is becoming more precarious by the minute

Gansbaai’s great white shark debate: New evidence in killer whale...

But the apex predators also face threats from human activity in South African waters and their numbers are fast dwindling as a result
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×