Police testimony discredits witnesses at Farlam commission

The seemingly innocuous and episodic police presentation of events leading up to August 16 continues to punch holes in the credibility of the police witnesses that have presented testimony before the Farlam commission of inquiry.

The police presentation, apparently giving an objective run down of events taking place between August 9 and August 16 presents little in the form of new information and yet creates a startling new picture of exactly how coordinated and regimented the police response to August 16 was.

It was perhaps fitting that, in a moment of self-conscious musing, Lieutenant Colonel Duncan Scott stopped himself after giving an unrelenting rundown of the tactical operational plan to say: "The operational commanders' understanding of the operational plan is something that needs to be tested with them."

It is a curious remark, especially considering what is now in the public domain about what transpired beyond the police’s barbed wire barrier, away from public view. The presentation, largely presented by Colonel Victor Visser before Scott handled the events of August 16 shed light on the police’s six-point plan, which they seemed resolute to carry out until the end, despite the interruption it suffered on that fateful Thursday.

The plan, implemented on August 14, involved negotiation, then negotiation with a show of force, a tactical option for resolution, the processing of arrested protestors, an intelligence-driven round of follow up arrests and a raid of the hostels to disarm the miners.


The Wonderkop hostel, where a significant number of the striking miners resided, was eventually raided in a pre-dawn operation that netted a significant load of so-called traditional weapons. The massacre then, if we accept the police report, represented stage three, as the "tactical option to resolve the situation".

While the presentation presents the police as tireless, if appropriate negotiators, it also presents their first significant witness Lieutenant Colonel Johannes Botha as an equally tireless liar, as he spent a significant time on the stand denying knowledge of the helicopter’s precise briefs, which were revealed to be to record video footage and direct tactical forces to specific locations.

While the video presents a somewhat civilised portrait of the police, it is important to note that this portrait was achieved by tactically painting the miners muti-crazed Amcu supporters.

Although the police appear humane up to this point, Thursday’s proceedings adjourned before we got to the critical point of the police unleashing firepower. The slow build up, with a team by team breakdown of weapons and manpower, raises chilling questions about exactly how, in their heads, the police saw this tactical disarmament unfolding.

Perhaps they were open to killing a few people, until scene two happened.

The inquiry continues on Friday.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Kwanele Sosibo
Kwanele Sosibo
Kwanele Sosibo is the editor of Friday, the arts and culture section of the Mail and Guardian.

Related stories

SA needs to restrain use of force by police

‘Less lethal’ weapons have resulted in deaths and severe injuries, yet there are still no guidelines

What Bernie Sanders needs to learn from black voters in South Africa

Senator Sanders must explicitly demonstrate that a US government that can guarantee universal healthcare is the best path to building long-term black wealth

Miners speak out against Sibanye

Not a year into buying Lonmin, Sibanye is accused of mistreating the mineworkers who were injured eight years ago during the Marikana massacre. But the platinum giant says it is a miscommunication. Athandiwe Saba and Paul Botes visit Marikana to find out the truth

Making myths out of music

After its run on America’s Got Talent, the Ndlovu Youth Choir became a symbol of unity. But its genesis points to South Africa’s deep inequality

The European Film Festival highlights how people respond to the disruptive changes

In this interview film festival director Peter Rorvik sheds light on his curatorial vision and some of the themes emerging from the festival.

Bringing the hidden to light

Tshepiso Mabula’s photographs interrogate the postapartheid ritual of exhumation and reburial
Advertising

Western Cape warned not to be complacent about flat-lining Covid-19...

The Western Cape, which once had the highest number of Covid-19 cases in South Africa, is seeing a steady decline in active cases

Sisulu axes another water board

Umgeni Water’s board in KwaZulu-Natal was appointed irregularly by her predecessor, the water and sanitation minister claims
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday