Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Doctors give NHI a qualified thumbs up

Last week, Bhekisisa reported that 350 private doctors will start working part time for the country's national health insurance (NHI) system this month at public health facilities. The clinics and hospitals are based at the NHI scheme's 11 pilot sites. 

The health department's director general, Precious Matsoso, said they will be paid directly by the national health department and with a system that uses a ­combination of "fee for service" (the current method of payment in the private sector) and "capitation" (a fixed salary based on the potential number of patients a doctor sees) remuneration systems. 

Private doctors will not be allowed to see state patients at their private surgeries, but will have to travel to government health facilities. 

According to Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi, the ideal is "for state patients to be able to go directly to general practitioners' surgeries, particularly when it's closer", but he said South Africa is not yet ready for that, citing the high incidence of private doctors claiming for work hours in public health facilities when they had, in fact, been absent from work or claiming for significantly more hours than they had actually worked. 

This week we bring you the results of an online survey of private doctors. We asked GPs how they would like to be involved in the NHI scheme. Nineteen doctors responded to our online questions. Most (95%) said they would like to work for the NHI in a part-time capacity. More than half, however, pointed out that they wouldn't be happy to work from state facilities and would prefer to be based at their own rooms.

Almost three-quarters indicated that they believe that doctors would cheat with work hours under the NHI system by claiming for hours they didn't work. 

Most were uncomfortable being paid via a capitation system, which generally leads to a smaller income than the private sector's current fee-for-service system.

What the practitioners say
On whether GPs in the NHI should work from state or private facilities: 



"It will depend on the location of the practice and the facilities and services available to a specific region. It is impossible to have a one-size-fits-all [approach]." – Dr Marmol Stoltz, Cape Town 



"Contract out to the GPs' practice. They are set up to handle patients and their practices are equipped to do the job properly. State services often run out of essential equipment, making it difficult to guarantee good services for the patients when contracting in." ­– Dr Rob Morgan, Johannesburg

On whether GPs will cheat with work hours: 


"There's no way to avoid [GPs claiming for hours they haven't worked]. There are plenty of doctors employed by the state on a full-time basis who also claim for hours they have not worked. Remember that private GPs generally follow the trend of doctors in public hospitals … There must be a clocking-in system and state doctors should be paid for the hours they work. Many state-employed doctors cut corners and get paid for hours they have not worked." – Dr Nozipho Msimang, Durban


On how the NHI should pay private doctors:

"Government should pay per patient. Each patient must carry an NHI-type card that must get swiped to confirm treatment was given by the GP." – Dr Lourens van Zyl, Pretoria. 



Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and receive a 40% discount on our annual rate..

Mia Malan
Mia Malan
Mia Malan is the founding director and editor of the Bhekisisa Centre for Health Journalism at the Mail & Guardian. She heads up a team of fifteen permanent and freelance staff members. She loves drama, good wine and strong coffee, not necessarily in that order.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Shanduka shade over Free State education

Audit firm PwC said R500-million irregular expenditure incurred by the Free State education department is related to an unsolicited bid by the Kagiso Shanduka Trust to improve schools

101 party elders dominate appeals body presiding over Magashule appeal

That the majority of those who form part of the ANC’s appeals body will come from 101 elders - which faction will have the upper hand

More top stories

ANCWL dumps Magashule as party leadership meets to discuss his...

ANCWL urges Magashule to humble himself and stop damaging the already weakened ruling party

Mashatile, Mabuza accused of pocketing ANC donations

The ANC’s financial crisis has been intensified by President Cyril Ramaphosa refusing to once again bail out the party

Fickle funding for women-led startups hurts femtech

It is difficult for startups to get off the ground, especially when they are women-focused

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…