Monbiot’s belief that he knows what’s best for Africa is offensive

A response to a Mail & Guardian opinion piece published on June 18 2013 entitled "Monbiot: Bono can't help Africans by stealing their voice"

Does George Monbiot actually believe he represents my and other African voices better than we can? It is ironic given that he points to Africans constantly being written out of the story by others but yet feels he can speak for us despite his inaccurate, often unverifiable "facts" about ONE. Mr Monbiot's claims that The ONE Campaign steals African's voices and does not challenge power could not be more wrong.

As ONE's Africa director, I've spent three years building a solid grassroots movement of amazing African thinkers and extremely bright new voices. They are educated, aspirational and confident about their own destiny. In three years this network has grown from 17 000 to more than 300 000 and it includes many civil society partners representing a range of African voices such as smallholder farmers among others. A movement that is taking back its continent on its own terms, holding its own leaders to account on promises they have made to their citizens.

I am proud that ONE recently amplified the voices of the 200 000 southern African citizens we polled about what they thought the new millennium goals should be; we took their views to world leaders and lobbied for these African voices to not only be heard but included in the design of the next Millenium Development Goals.

And last week, leading African activists, including ONE's policy advisers Rakesh Rajani and John Githongo, met with British Prime Minister David Cameron in a meeting ONE organised, to lobby him on tax and transparency. Helping African voices get heard by political leaders is central to our business. We delivered a letter from 37 African farming groups to Mr Cameron two weeks ago calling for more support for African-led agriculture.

Monbiot claims people are "furious" about the New Alliance. I'm offended that Monbiot believes that he knows better what is good for Africa than the democratically elected African leaders of the seven New Alliance countries like President Joyce Banda when she says in her recent post that "Malawi's membership of the G8's new alliance is a chance to accelerate investment in agriculture … My government views agriculture as a means to attaining food security as well as a business through which our farmers can generate wealth, improve their livelihoods and transform Malawi's economy".

If Monbiot did some research he would discover that ONE worked to reform the New Alliance so it better reflects smallholder farmers, especially women, better supports secure land tenure, strengthens transparency and accountability and most importantly operates within the existing framework of the Comprehensive African Agriculture Development Program (CAADP) as we work towards 2014 African Union Year of Agriculture.  He would discover that the Grow Africa initiative, which supports the New Alliance, reports that more than $60-million invested so far has helped smallholder farmers develop their businesses. Approximately 270 000 metric tonnes of commodities were sourced, generating $300-million in sales for farmers. Nearly 800 000 smallholders have benefited from training, service provisions, and market access. We share concerns about land grabs in Africa, and we've worked to address this. But the New Alliance is not dominated by large global corporations; many sizeable investments are driven by African firms and small and medium-sized enterprises. 

As for ONE's board, Mo Ibrahim and Ngozi Okonjo Iweala are fearless Africans whose voices are ceaseless in defending, promoting and empowering our citizens. ONE is privileged to have them directing what we work on. Their involvement enhances ONE's efforts to promote many other critical African voices.

Do we challenge power? How about challenging the most powerful lobby group in the world – the combined might of the global petroleum lobby – and winning? With our partners in the Publish What You Pay coalition, ONE just did that through United States and European Union legislation covering transparency in the oil and gas sector.

The important debates happening now on the continent are firmly led by ourselves, as President Barack Obama will hear loud and clear when he gets here. We can speak for ourselves and hold the leaders we voted into power to account. Allow us to take our own decisions, and correct them if we need to. But whatever you do, please don't patronise us!

Dr Sipho Moyo is the Africa Director for The ONE Campaign

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Sipho Moyo
Sipho Moyo works from Africa. Factivist Original #StrongGirl It's my Continent! Global Agenda Council @WEF Sipho Moyo has over 3289 followers on Twitter.

Related stories

Shange paid the price for her honesty

Her book gifted me a vision of myself and many black women who carried my world

Bono’s charity admits to ‘toxic’ bullying at South Africa office

​The ONE Campaign―the anti-corruption charity fronted by U2 lead singer Bono― is embroiled in a major bullying scandal

Weheartbeat’s niche brand packs a punchy pulse

Weheartbeat prides itself on its intimate performances. This year the collective is set to expand

Papa Wemba leaves in style

Kwanele Sosibo remembers the flamboyant Congolese performer who died at 66.

Prince: So long you sexy motherf*cker

Three South African musicians talk about the spell of the purple one.

The politics of Prince

Rhodes University’s Vashna Jagarnath explains why she teaches her history students about Prince.

Jailed journalist a symbol of a disillusioned Zimbabwe

Hopewell Chin’ono backed President Emmerson Mnangagwa when he succeeded Robert Mugabe. Now he’s in jail

Sisulu axes another water board

Umgeni Water’s board in KwaZulu-Natal was appointed irregularly by her predecessor, the water and sanitation minister claims

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday