W Cape schools will not be closed

Western Cape High Court judges Andre le Grange and Nape Dolamo ruled that the reasons given for the closures were brief and that the public consultation process that followed was inadequate.

They set aside Western Cape education minister Donald Grant's decision, made in October to go into effect from December 31.

Read more:

He and his department were ordered to pay the legal costs of the schools and their governing bodies.

The South African Democratic Teachers' Union (Sadtu), which was listed as an applicant, was ordered to pay its own costs.

Le Grange found that the reasons Grant presented for possible closures were largely inadequate and irrational.

"The applicants have demonstrated in the papers filed that the schools the provincial ministers decided to close have remarkable similarities to those he decided to keep open," he said in the judgment.

"The difference between the provincial minister's initial and final reasons for closure at certain schools … in my view gives further credence to the applicants' complaint of irrationality."

Argument dismissed
The court found the public consultation process an "artificial formality" that fell short of what was reasonably expected.

"The manner in which these proceedings were conducted further strengthened the applicants' case.

The officials simply allowed the affected parties to say what they wished to say rather than engage, raise, and discuss the reasons."

In a minority judgment, Judge Lee Bozalek said he would have set aside Grant's decision only for Beauvallon Senior Secondary School, and that the other schools had failed to make a case.

All three judges dismissed the applicants' argument that the section of the South African Schools Act dealing with school closures was unconstitutional.

Section 33 of the act empowers a provincial minister to close a public school by notice in the provincial gazette.

Grant announced last year that 27 schools faced possible closure for various reasons.

After representations were made at public hearings, he decided to close 18 schools and transfer pupils to "receiving schools".

'Sad day for education'
One of the schools, Tonko Bosman Primary in Somerset West, agreed to the closure. The schools' governing bodies and Sadtu approached the court for a review of Grant's decision on the closures.

The review application was heard last month and judgment was reserved. Grant said on Tuesday that the ruling marked "a sad day for education".

"The judgment has compromised the education opportunities for the learners at the 17 schools. The department will, however, continue to support these schools."

He said pupils at Tonko Bosman Primary, the school which agreed to the closure, had received better opportunities.

"The learners now attend Raithby Primary School, where they receive single-grade tuition and improved education facilities, such as a computer lab and sports and extra-curricular playing fields."

Grant believed the closure decisions were made in the children's best interests.

"We will study the judgment carefully and will take into consideration the recommendations made by the court in terms of procedures followed with respect to school closures."

Grant did not reveal whether he would appeal the court's ruling. – Sapa

Jenna Etheridge
Jenna Etheridge
Journalist, writer and editor

South Africa could use a communist party

The SACP is not building socialism, or even social democracy. Sadly, it has become just another party advancing the politics of patronage

Netflix and the smash hit tax dodge

‘The Laundromat’ is a film about corporates and the superrich using tax havens, something the streaming service itself allegedly excels at

Press Releases

MiX Telematics enhances in-vehicle video camera solution

The company has launched the gold MiX Vision Bureau Service, which includes driver-coaching tools to ensure risky driver behaviour can be addressed proactively and efficiently.

Boosting safety for cargo and drivers

The use of a telematics system for fleet vehicles has proved to be an important tool in helping to drive down costs and improve efficiency, says MiX Telematics Africa.

Silencing the guns and firearms amnesty

Silencing the guns and firearms amnesty

Gender-based violence is an affront to our humanity

Gender-based violence is an affront to our humanity

UK-Africa investment summit 2020: Think Africa Invest SA

UK-Africa investment summit 2020: Think Africa Invest SA

MTN unveils TikTok bundles

Customised MTN TikTok data bundles are available to all prepaid customers on *136*2#.

The changing role of marketing

Marketing is an exciting discipline, offering the perfect fit for individuals who are equally interested in business, human dynamics and strategic thinking. But the...

Upskill yourself to land your dream job in 2020

If you received admission to an IIE Higher Certificate qualification, once you have graduated, you can articulate to an IIE Diploma and then IIE Bachelor's degree at IIE Rosebank College.