Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

US Senate report confirms torture does not work


The Senate report on the CIA’s detention and interrogation programme represents the most authoritative and comprehensive finding since the United States launched its so-called “war on terror” more than 13 years ago that torture does not work.

That conclusion will be contested, mostly by former members of the George Bush administration and CIA officials involved in the programme. They have launched a public relations backlash to the finding. But the bulk and depth of the Senate intelligence committee report will make it much harder to win that argument.

The report finds that CIA detainees subjected to what were then called “enhanced interrogation techniques” either produced no intelligence, or they “fabricated information, resulting in faulty intelligence”. It says that the CIA’s own interrogators “assessed that the most effective method for acquiring intelligence from detainees, including from detainees the CIA considered to be the most ‘high-value’, was to confront the detainees with information already acquired by the intelligence community”.

“This is an authoritative conclusion,” said Philippe Sands, a law professor at University College London and the author of Torture Team, an account of how torture came to be used increasingly on al-Qaeda suspects in the wake of 9/11.

“The Senate intelligence commission has been looking into this for years. I know that they went into it with an open mind. Those who were engaged in the analysis followed the evidence. What it confirmed is what I was always told by US military psychologists: that torture produces information, but it does not produce reliable information.”

The Senate delivered a verdict on the debate over whether the torture of two senior al-Qaeda figures, Abu Zubaydah and Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, forced them to divulge intelligence that prevented further terrorist attacks and thereby saved lives.

They were subjected to waterboarding: 83 times in Zubaydah’s case and 183 times in Mohammed’s.

‘Phenomenal’ results
Defenders of waterboarding, which was declared to be torture by the Obama administration, claimed it led to concrete results.

They said that its use on Zubaydah led to Mohammed, the mastermind of the 9/11 attacks, and that the latter’s interrogation using waterboarding led to the location and killing of Osama bin Laden. Former vice-­president Dick Cheney claimed that the techniques produced “phenomenal” results.

The Senate report refutes the claims, which had already been denied by former interrogators at the heart of the post-9/11 manhunt.

In 2009, a former FBI agent, Ali Soufan, who had taken part in the interrogation of Zubaydah seven years earlier, said that all the useful intelligence came from traditional nonviolent questioning, and that waterboarding Zubaydah produced nothing further of value.

“Almost all the agency officials I worked with on these issues were good people who felt as I did about the use of enhanced techniques: it is un-American, ineffective and harmful to our national security,” Soufan wrote.

A former official from the US navy’s criminal investigative service, Mark Fallon, wrote on Monday: “As special agent in charge of the criminal investigation task force with investigators and intelligence personnel at Guantánamo Bay, Afghanistan and Iraq, I was privy to the information provided by Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. I was aware of no valuable information that came from waterboarding.”

The failure of the US military to corner Bin Laden at Tora Bora in Afghanistan at the end of 2001, and the al-Qaeda leader’s subsequent escape into Pakistan, led to a growing sense of urgency within the Bush administration.

The then head of CIA counter-terrorism, Cofer Black, said: “After 9/11, the gloves came off.” As the then defence secretary, Donald Rumsfeld, put pressure on the officers running the new Guantánamo Bay detention camp to come up with fast, actionable intelligence, traditional investigators like Soufan and Fallon were shouldered aside. The use of the “enhanced techniques” spread.

As another former navy interrogator, Mike Gelles, put it in Torture Team: “The problem is, once you take the dogs off the leash, you cannot put them back on.” – © Guardian News & Media 2014

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them.

Julian Borger
Julian Borger
Julian Borger is a British journalist and non-fiction writer. He is the world affairs editor at The Guardian. He was a correspondent in the US, eastern Europe, the Middle East and the Balkans and covered the Bosnian War for the BBC. Borger is a contributor to Center of International Cooperation.

Related stories


If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Subscribers only

Bloated Sassa to make staff cuts

The social security agency has ‘lost’ R2-billion on unnecessary salaries and through wasteful expenditure

SANDF’s ‘dignity’ comes with a R200mn price tag

Find out about the SANDF’s new uniform, which is costing taxpayers close to R200-million, while mission-critical equipment is not maintained

More top stories

Lipstick, blush and Boko Haram: Meet the make-up artists of...

Despite the insurgency, which has killed many people, caused the displacement of millions, confines women to traditional roles and forbids the education of girls, women are fending for their families and starting lucrative businesses. Meet the make-up artists of Maiduguri

Phiyega bid to sidestep Marikana massacre dismissed

Ex-police commissioner Riah Phiyega hoped to quash findings including colluding in a cover-up and misleading the public about what happened at the platinum mine in 2012.

Warring ANC factions united in questioning SAA deal

Four unhappy high-ranking party members say the SAA sale was never discussed at the NEC

Ice skating champion shows off the Cape Flats talent at...

A young ice-skating champion has beaten the odds and brought home a national gold medal

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…