Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Why SA is primed for fundamental political realignment

As popular protests soar amid unmet expectations in South Africa, the historic partnership between the country’s powerful labour movement and the governing ANC has begun to fall apart.

South Africa has been governed since 1994 by an ANC-led tripartite alliance that includes the South African Communist Party (SACP) and labour federation Congress of SA Trade Unions (Cosatu).

But, today, a new national political elite grapples with a powerful and often intransigent labour movement over the lack of delivery on key socio-economic issues.

The workers walk away
The Marikana massacre of 2012 triggered a wave of strikes across South Africa. They culminated in an unprecedented uprising in the rural areas of the Western Cape. It also began a process of political realignment.

The dramatic entry of the Economic Freedom Front into parliament in 2014 was to become the most spectacular.

But could the historic decision of the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (Numsa), the largest trade union in the country, to withdraw its support for the ANC, and its decision to form a United Front and Movement for Socialism, be of more long-term significance?

The “Numsa moment”, one support group boldly proclaimed, “constitutes the beginning of the end for the ANC and its ambivalence towards neo-liberalism”.

The expulsion of Numsa from Cosatu in 2014, followed by that of Zwelinzima Vavi, the long-standing general-secretary, in 2015 did not initially slow down enthusiasm for the Numsa moment. After all, Numsa was a leading social force in the struggle for liberation. Vavi had widespread support among workers.

South African Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa at the Farlam Commission into the killing of miners. Reuters/Siphiwe Sibeko

Are Marikana and the Numsa moment a turning point in South Africa, the beginning of the “next liberation struggle?” Or does it mark the disintegration of a once powerful labour movement?

In response to the re-emergence of the idea of a workers’ party inside Numsa, I participated in a nation-wide survey with my colleague Mark Orkin in 2014. Surprisingly, a third of South African adults definitely thought that:

a new political party, a workers’ or labour party, will assist with current problems facing SA.

What could the social base of such a party be? In a nationwide adult sample, 30% of the full-time or part-time employed would definitely support a workers’ party, rising to 40% of the unemployed.

The highest expression of “definite” support for the idea of a workers’ party was among the black working poor. Their household incomes were less than R8 000 a month and they have primary or secondary school education. They were in the main working age of 18-49.

By contrast, the lowest expressed “definite” support for a workers’ party was among whites, Indians and coloureds alike. Their household incomes were more than R8 000 a month; they tend to have a tertiary education and are among the oldest of those surveyed.

Lessons from elsewhere
Numsa has approached the question of a workers’ party with caution. Following independence, trade unions in post-colonial Africa have tended initially to submit to the ruling party that drove the liberation struggle.

Growing marginalisation led unions in countries such as Zambia and Zimbabwe into opposition and the formation of a separate political party. In the case of Zambia’s Movement for Multiparty Democracy the party won state power in elections.

But, there has generally been a low level of tolerance of political opposition in post-colonial Africa. The result is a culture of “us” versus “them”. Union-backed opposition parties have often been quickly labelled “counter-revolutionary” and “imperialist”.

The union-backed Movement for Democratic Change soon became the focus of organised violence inflicted by the Zimbabwean state.

A workers’ party is more likely to survive in South Africa. This is thanks to a relatively large industrial working class, strong civil society organisations and an independent trade union movement with a political culture of shop-floor democracy.

Former Cosatu general secretary Zwelinzima Vavi, centre, joins a Numsa protest in Durban, in 2014. Reuters/Rogan Ward

But what would the form and content of a working-class politics be in South Africa? Is it to involve a broad workers’ party, along the lines of Brazil’s Partido dos Trabalhadores, with links to working-class communities, academics and small farmers?

Or is it to be a more traditional labour party along the lines of the UK Labour Party, with close ties with organised labour? Is it to be a revitalised Marxist-Leninist vanguard party, a mirror image of the South African Communist Party? Or could it be the United Front?

A national working committee of the United Front was established in December 2014. It is designed to link unions to struggles in the community. It has a large number of loose social justice and environmental justice affiliates, so it is yet to be formally launched nationally.

But, its political direction remains uncertain: should it be openly socialist, or a broad front similar to the United Democratic Front of the 1980s?

Is it a step towards a workers’ party or is it an autonomous body connecting a range of community-based organisations? Should it engage in electoral politics or should it remain at arm’s length from party politics?

Importantly, the local-level militancy that emerged over the past decade is fragmented. It is different from the social movement unionism of the early to mid-eighties. The link between the current township protests and Numsa is tenuous.

Labour’s dilemma
Labour’s dilemma in post-colonial countries is how to express its distinct interests in a way that it does not have a confrontation with the state. It also does not want to alienate itself from those who continue to support the dominant national democratic tradition.

Interestingly, the Ghana Trade Union Congress has chosen the path of non-alignment with any specific political party. It prefers to develop its own political demands, lobby for them and advise its members to vote for the party that supports its programme.

A similar approach has been adopted among some informal worker organisations in India. Informal worker movements, US based sociologist Rina Agarwala demonstrates, are most successful when operating within electoral contexts where parties compete for mass votes from the poor.

She calls this competitive populism. These informal worker organisations are not attached to a particular party nor do they espouse a specific political or economic ideology.

We are entering a new kind of politics, what some have come to call the “politics of precarity.” There is, as sociologist Jennifer Chun argues:

growing interest in a new political subject of labour … women, immigrants, people of colour, low-paid service workers, precarious workers … Groups that have been historically excluded from the moral and material boundaries of union membership.

Whether the left activists of the labour movement have the political imagination and energy to take advantage of this new terrain remains to be seen. What is clear is that the old labour order is no longer sustainable and building an alternative is going to require long-term organisational work.

Looking back, 30 years after the death of trade unionist Neil Aggett, who was the only white person to die in detention in apartheid South Africa, I believe we can learn from his work and life: to encourage the different political traditions to openly compete in parliamentary and extra-parliamentary forums.

What he wrote in those painful final days of his life, while being tortured, should guide us in the present:

What the workers and the people need are open democratic organisations in which they can participate.

This article is based on the Second Annual Neil Aggett Labour Studies Lecture: The Death of Neil Aggett: Unions and Politics, Then and Now delivered by the author on September 21 2015 at at Rhodes University, South Africa.

Edward Webster, Edward Webster is Professor Emeritus in the Society, Work and Development Institute, University of the Witwatersrand

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and receive a 40% discount on our annual rate..

Edward Webster
Edward Webster is a Distinguished Research Professor, Southern Centre for Inequality Studies. He is the founder of the the Society, Work and Development Institute (SWOP) at the University of the Witwatersrand and directed it for 24 years.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Q&A Sessions: Zanele Mbuyisa — For the love of people-centred...

She’s worked on one of the biggest class-action cases in South Africa and she’s taken on Uber: Zanele Mbuyisa speaks to Athandiwe Saba about advocating for the underrepresented, getting ‘old’ and transformation in the law fraternity

Update: Standard Bank rejects climate proposal

Climate considerations are pressing Standard Bank shareholders to push for the recusal of those with fossil fuel ties.

More top stories

Wildlife farming vs Creecy’s panel

The departments of environment and agriculture legislation are at odds over modifying the genes of wild animals

Drugs and alcohol abuse rage in crime stats

Substance abuse has emerged as a reason for the spike in crimes during the first quarter of 2021.

UPDATE: Magashule tries to tip the scales on Ramaphosa in...

The suspended secretary general argues that the rules the party relied on to sideline him are invalid but those informing his attempt to suspend the president are lawful

Modack charged with Kinnear murder

Nafiz Modack is the second person to be charged with killing Charl Kinnear and five others are accused of conspiracy to commit murder, among 61 other charges

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…