Bottom-up development must start taking root in South Africa

As we approach local government elections, much of the talk will turn to the importance of voting – and approaches to development at the local level.

More and more people these days talk about bottom-up development.

It was ordinary people who built the mass struggles against apartheid. But we can trace many of our problems in post-apartheid South Africa to a lack of commitment to meaningful, participatory, bottom-up development – despite having the legal and other provisions in place.

People have been protesting against top-down development with even more vigour. But elites have often struggled to grasp this and have tended to label much of this anger at the exclusion of ordinary people as “service delivery” protests.

South Africans’ demand for a bottom-up and democratic approach to development has, for many years, had a wider international resonance. Development specialists have taken a critical look at top-down approaches and advocated more democratic models.

Innovative participatory approaches in places such as Bolivia, Porto Allegre in Brazil, Kerala in India and Naga City in the Philippines are cited as evidence for the effectiveness of bottom-up models of social planning.

United States President Barack Obama spoke about bottom-up development during his election campaign several years ago. His campaign for the Democratic Party nomination often eschewed corporate support in favour of a grass-roots-up campaign. The fact that he was able to win the Democratic nomination on the back of the work of people in community organisations is testament to the power of people.

Increasingly, technocratic, top-down development is being questioned and investigated more critically and the flaws of such a developmental approach are fast being exposed.

In recent years, Kerala was known to have extreme poverty, malnutrition and high infant mortality rates. Later, when the state embarked on a model that was participatory and bottom-up, Kerala made mind-boggling progress. Today, it has social development indicators that are comparable with Western Europe and North America.

With an academic interest in participatory governance, I have sat in on conferences around the world where entire segments of the conference have been dedicated to “participatory governance”. In Madagascar, where I attended a development conference two weeks ago, participatory governance is high up on the civil society agenda.

One begins to think that there just may be hope for a solid challenge to the technocratic, top-down approach to dealing with peoples’ development.

When it comes to bottom-up development, there are encouraging and fascinating models from India, Bangladesh, Brazil, Philippines and Mexico – and we have our own story to tell.

South Africa has all the legislative and constitutive provisions in place, but we are not seeing a truly bottom-up development. In principle, we are world leaders; in practice, we are way behind many countries.

It is a sad fact that in our country, despite all the good laws, opportunities are very seldom created for affected groups to obtain information on a proposed policy process, to reflect on proposals and options, articulate preferred options and mandate representatives to speak on their behalf, with measures created for accountability and feedback.

It is an equally sad fact that very often poor people’s movements have faced considerable repression when they try to access information and processes that are theirs by right in terms of law and policy.

It is critical to assess who participates in decision-making, and whose voice is heard, particularly at the local level. The relative inaccessibility of information on government decision-making and the resources and abilities required to engage in participatory processes result in the domination of such spaces by the elite and those with access to resources, such as select nongovernmental organisations, business and other similar interest groups.

NGOs are important but poor peoples’ organisations and social movements should not be excluded. Often this causes consternation among those who believe there are three sectors in society – government, business and civil society – and that participation simply means that all three sectors must be included.

But this model is deeply flawed. At times, they have very different modes of working, interests and constituencies.

Although most states expect participation on their own terms, poor people’s movements tend to be ignored and have come to be seen as social pariahs because they have opted to use the murky space of popular protest, which is often confrontational. But this is where genuine grass-roots democracy is forged.

Today, the strong belief in social justice that has advanced organisations of the poor is much cloudier.

South Africa has a great deal to learn from examples around the world, where grass-roots movements have been effectively involved at the local level, such as the successes in involving street hawkers in Ghana and farmworkers in India. There is also a wide range of fascinating examples of participatory budgeting in Latin America.

Despite the negativities that sometimes come with international gatherings, somehow it also fills one with hope – that the chances are that the poor may just have a future after all.

Imraan Buccus is a senior research associate of the Auwal Socio-Economic Research Institute, a research fellow in the school of social sciences at the University of KwaZulu-Natal and academic director of a university study abroad programme on political transformation

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Imraan Buccus
Imraan Buccus works from Durban North. academic, columnist, researcher, writer

Related stories

Rich vigilantes have no fear of consequences

The City of Cape Town tacitly condones it when wealthy landowners behave illegally, something that is not the case if you’re poor

More than 70 000 homes built for Gauteng citizens

MEC urges construction companies to work on weekends and in evenings to speed up delivery

‘It’ll happen again’ say Silver Town  fire victims

Residents claim politicians flock to Khayelitsha in times of tragedy, but leave with empty promises

Shack fires bring more legal woes for De Lille

A Gauteng businessman blames De Lille for costing the city millions of rand in relief efforts for shack fires that could have been avoided.

These inhospitable living conditions are the reason the #HoutbayProtests erupted

At least one person died after being caught in a hail of rubber bullets and tear gas when protests broke out in Imizamo Yethu, Hout Bay.

Violence spirals as Ekurhuleni metro destroys shacks

The rumour of killings was false, the authorities said, but by then it was too late.

Subscribers only

Toxic power struggle hits public works

With infighting and allegations of corruption and poor planning, the department’s top management looks like a scene from ‘Survivor’

Free State branches gun for Ace

Parts of the provincial ANC will target their former premier, Magashule, and the Free State PEC in a rolling mass action campaign

More top stories

Q&A Sessions: ‘My north star is the patient’

Rhulani Nhlaniki is Pfizer’s cluster lead for sub-Saharan Africa. As Pfizer starts phase III of the clinical trial of their Covid-19 vaccine candidate, he tells Malaikah Bophela that if it is successful, the company will ensure the vaccine will be available to everyone who needs it

In terms of future-telling failures, this is a Major One

Bushiri knows how to pull a crowd. Ace knows a ponzi scheme. Paddy Harper predicts that a new prophet may profit at Luthuli House

Ghost fishing gear an ‘immortal menace’ in oceans

Lost and illegal tackle is threatening marine life and the lives of people making a living from the sea

Vitamin therapy is for drips

It may be marketed by influencers, but intravenous vitamin therapy is not necessary and probably not worth the hype, experts say

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday