Quest for truth in doccie on MK cadre

Ashley Kriel was known as the Che Guevara of the Cape Flats: a 20-year-old Umkhonto weSizwe cadre who called for militant action against the apartheid government.

He died at the hands of police in 1987 and his death has been cloaked by misinformation for 29 years. Now Cape Town filmmaker Nadine Cloete has put Kriel’s story in the spotlight again.

University of Cape Town graduate Cloete (29) was working as an intern at Rainbow Circle Films when she saw archive footage of Kriel for the first time.

“It moved me deeply. He got stuck in my head and didn’t let go. I didn’t plan for the film to be released now; it just worked out that way,” says Cloete of Action Kommandant, her film about Kriel’s life that’s screening at the 2016 Encounters documentary film festival, showing in Cape Town and Johannesburg until June 12.

“I have worked on the film for about six years and for it to be released in the year we are commemorating the 40th anniversary of June 16 1976 is a blessing.”

She has been working as a documentary-maker since one of her films screened at Encounters five years ago. Following this, she directed and coproduced two short documentaries and directed a documentary series for the SABC. A short documentary, called Miseducation, which she directed and coproduced with Steven Markovitz for the Why Poverty? series, was featured on the New York Times’s Op-Docs video channel.

Action Kommandant is her first independent feature-length documentary. It premiered at the Seattle International Film Festival on May 27.

In his testimony at the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, police officer Jeffrey Benzien said Kriel was shot accidentally during a scuffle at his home in Athlone. But Kriel’s family is adamant that his death was no accident and that he was murdered by the security police.

Action Kommandant has allowed them to tell their story and also led to the reopening of Kriel’s case earlier this year.

“I never dreamed that the Hawks would be reopening the case,” says Cloete. “I hope the release of the film accelerates these investigations.”

According to the findings of forensic scientist David Klatzow, hired by Kriel’s family to investigate his death, Kriel was shot “from a distance” and not accidentally at close range. This, plus Cloete’s film, has proved a vindication for the Kriel family.

“It was not easy for them to see some of the material,” says Cloete. “But they feel it is important that the public be exposed to the truth.”

Cloete recalls that working on the documentary was traumatic at times, particularly the photographs she uncovered as part of her research. “The most traumatising event was seeing the pictures of Ashley taken after he had been killed. Seeing him handcuffed in those images was crazy.”

But getting access to archives was not always easy and she relied on the personal records of those who knew Kriel and his story.

“Images in the film come from Benny Gool, Jimi Matthews and Craig Matthew. There is also the famous image of Ashley taken by Rashid Lombard.”

Cloete also sourced footage of Kriel’s funeral from Associated Press. “It was stressful. AP was supportive but I paid for the material to be digitised.”

Funding, she says, was a difficulty she faced throughout the making of the film. “The initial funder was the National Film and Video Foundation, which got the ball rolling by approving research and development funds in 2011.”

By last year Cloete needed R75?000 to complete her project, which she received from Independent Media.

Funding is only one of the difficulties she has had to overcome in her career. “There are moments where I am the only female of -colour in the room. Then I feel like I have to represent my entire race and gender, which is a lot of pressure to not mess up,” she says.

But, she adds, her experience as a woman of colour does enhance her work. “I’m very aware of not representing tired stereotypes and strive to tell stories from the inside out.”

This is how she has told Kriel’s story – paying homage to him and his community. “I’ve come to see Ashley as more than the icon. He is a real person to me now, and I hope that comes across in the film.”

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Come what may, the UIF will pay

The fund – the main safety net for unemployed workers – will run at an almost R20-billion deficit

‘Terrorised’ family shines a light on traditional leadership for vulnerable...

The ambiguity between traditional and constitutional leadership has been exposed by the violent banishment of an Eastern Cape family

More top stories

Zondo commission: Molefe says Glencore sold Optimum to portray him...

Former Eskom chief executive paints himself as the victim of a plot at the hands of President Cyril Ramaphosa’s former business associates

Municipal workers convicted in R3.5m ‘Christmas cheer’ fund fraud scheme

A fund that was meant to provide much-needed, end-of-year cash for municipal workers was looted by the three signatories of the account

Tshiamiso Trust makes due on silicosis payout

Beneficiaries will now be able to apply to get money from the settlement almost two years after the Johannesburg high court ruled on the matter.

Shootings on Cape Flats claim 14 lives in less than...

At least 50 more police and other law enforcement officers were sent to the area in response to the spate of violence

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…