Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

There’s still no answer to Please Call Me. Now they want the arbitrator to hang up

The clash over Nkosana Makate’s payout from cellphone giant Vodacom has taken yet another nasty turn.

This time, a senior advocate has landed up being the subject of a high court application; Makate’s funders are questioning his experience as an arbitrator to preside over such a big money case.

Michael Mabena SC was appointed by the chairperson of the Pretoria Bar Council to oversee a dispute between Makate and funders of  his case against Vodacom. The arbitration proceedings started months before Makate’s victory at the Constitutional Court in April.

The parties are embroiled in an ongoing dispute over whether Makate had validly cancelled his funding agreement involving the Sterling Rand, a nominated company, Raining Men Trade and businessman Chris Schoeman. In the first blow since Makate won his case against Vodacom in April, his funders took him to court last month claiming he was in on a plot by various lawyers to oust them from the deal.

Now Schoeman has launched a second high court bid. This time he wants the court to set aside Mabena’s appointment, citing a lack of experience and the complexity of the case. Mabena, who attained silk status in 2011, declined to comment because of his work in the matter.

Norman Davis SC, chairperson of the Pretoria Bar Council, also cited as a respondent in the case, said because no relief was being sought against the Bar, it would not oppose Schoeman’s application. This decision may be reviewed if new information came to light. Davis said the Bar, as a rule, only appointed arbitrators it deemed competent.

Schoeman, who previously claimed he virtually emptied his bank account when he took up Makate’s case in 2011, facilitated additional funding through Sterling Rand while Raining Men Trade was then allegedly installed as the nominated company to handle the case.

But lawyers for Makate have charged that the funders had, at some point, failed to make payments to cover Makate’s case, thereby invalidating the initial funding agreement. This is the subject of the arbitration hearing.

Schoeman’s attorney, Amish Kika, said the outcome of the latest application would determine the next step in the Please Call Me matter.

“This application is fundamental to the integrity of the adjudication of the issues between the funders and Mr Makate and will deal with important legal issues like the interplay between litigation funding and the contingency fees act.”

The funders and some of the lawyers involved are in line for a substantial slice of Makate’s expected payout. By order of the court, 50% of the proceeds of the settlement will be held in trust until the dispute with funders is resolved.

Schoeman wants the high court to order that this arbitration be heard in open court by a retired judge or a panel of two judges instead of Mabena.

The reason, Schoeman states, is: “The conduct and credibility of senior members of the legal team will be an issue. I submit that is not desirable for a colleague, albeit a senior counsel, to have to make such findings. The conduct of all parties concerned should be openly ventilated and scrutinised before a judge of the high court and not hidden behind a veil of secrecy in arbitration.”

He also contends that the law firm, Umika Gopichund Attorneys, nominated to hold half the proceeds from his settlement with Vodacom in trust until the dispute between the funders and lawyers is resolved, is unlikely to have the required indemnity cover to hold funds of R500-million and R1-billion, respectively.

He said the firm was registered with the Law Society for the Northern Provinces only one day before it was nominated, that it operated from a residential property and uses a mobile number.

Attorney Umika Gopichund said she was aware of this latest application and intends opposing it insofar as it relates to her or her firm.

Schoeman, she said, has made “frivolous comments in his application against myself, which I take exception to, and reserve my rights to institute an action for defamation against him”.

Gopichund said she is not involved in Makate’s case against Vodacom and has been instructed only to hold 50% of the funds payable, pending the outcome of the current dispute.

“The true nature of Umika Gopichund Attorneys is that it is a registered law firm, which has complied with all the requirements of the Law Society of the Northern Provinces, and holds a certificate of good standing from the said law society. I am a competent attorney with more than 13 years of post-admission experience, whose credentials have never been questioned throughout my career. I have administered trust accounts for clients previously and have an unblemished record with the law society,” she added.

Makate’s lawyer, Wilna Lubbe, said: “In this application Mr Schoeman wants to set aside the arbitration which he had initiated himself. Bizarre! It is not an urgent application, it is vexatious.” Her instructions, she said, are to oppose it.

Makate, the man at the centre of it all, is undeterred: “I remain resolute. I’ve won a bigger battle. This is by no means insurmountable. We just have to ensure that there is progress so negotiations with Vodacom can resume.

“But we need to make sure we stick to principles.”

Subscribe for R500/year

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and get a 57% discount in your first year.

Jessica Bezuidenhout
Jessica Bezuidenhout joined the Mail & Guardian as an investigative reporter in March 2016 after 20 years at the Sunday Times working on news and investigations. She has been the joint winner of several local and international journalism awards, including Nat Nakasa, Mondi, Vodacom regional journalist of the year and Misa, and runner-up for the 2003 Natali Prize.

Related stories


If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Subscribers only

Capitec Bank flies high above Viceroy’s arrow

The bank took a knock after being labelled a loan shark by the short seller, but this has not stymied its growth

Zondo may miss chief justice cut

The deputy chief justice is said to top Ramaphosa’s list but his position as head of the state capture commission is seen as too politically fraught

More top stories

Council wants Hawks, SIU probe into BAT’s Zimbabwe scandal

The cigarette maker has been accused of giving up to $500 000 in bribes and spying on competitors

How Alpha Condé overthrew Alpha Condé

Since the coup d’état, Guinea’s head of state has been in the custody of the military officers. But it was the president who was the primary architect of his own downfall

‘The Making of Mount Edgecombe’: A view of history from...

Indian indentured labourers’ lives are celebrated in a new book, Sugar Mill Barracks: The Making of Mount Edgecombe

Case of men arrested with 19 rhino horns is postponed

Alleged rhino kingpin and a Mpumalanga businessman appeared in court on charges of the illegal possession and selling of rhino horns

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…