Junk status is inevitable for South Africa, say economists

Should South Africa avoid having its credit rating cut to junk in the next two weeks, it could just be staving off the inevitable.

More than half of 12 economists surveyed by Bloomberg said S&P Global Ratings will strip the nation of its investment-level rating. The median probability of South Africa retaining its current assessment in December is 45%, falling to only 20% in 2017, the survey shows.

The economy faces a cut to junk on its foreign-currency credit rating as output is forecast to expand at the slowest pace this year since a 2009 recession, delaying the government’s plans to narrow the shortfall on the budget and rein in debt.

While the economic growth outlook has improved marginally and a similar Bloomberg poll six months ago showed 12 of 13 economists said the nation’s credit rating will be cut to junk by the end of the year, political turmoil, including now-dropped fraud charges against Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan, has overshadowed some the government’s efforts to boost investor and business confidence.

“I don’t think it’s high enough on the priority list that we are seeing enough being done,” Christie Viljoen, an economist at KPMG LLP in Cape Town, said on Thursday by phone. 

“It might be enough at the moment to avoid an immediate downgrade in December, but if it is avoided in December, it’s going to happen next year.”

Fitch visit
S&P is scheduled to announce its assessment, which is at the lowest investment grade and has a negative outlook, on December 2 and Moody’s will publish the review of its rating, currently one level higher than S&P’s, on November 25. Officials from Fitch, which has a stable outlook on its BBB- rating, visited South Africa this week and are concerned about the nation’s ability to stick to its fiscal targets and about the lack of economic growth, according to Deputy Finance Minister Mcebisi Jonas. Fitch hasn’t set a date for its assessment.

“We will be able to maintain the current expenditure ceiling, we think we will, and I dare say, we convinced them we can,” Jonas said on Thursday. 

“My sense is that there was general acceptance of our constraints and the good work we are doing.”

Gordhan has been leading efforts to avoid a downgrade to junk with meetings between the government, business and labour and by talking to foreign investors. However, the standoff between him and President Jacob Zuma over control of treasury and delays in passing new mining and anti-money laundering laws and overhauling employment legislation have fuelled perceptions of political turmoil and policy uncertainty that S&P and Fitch warned against in June when they left their ratings unchanged.

‘Moving sideways’ 
We aren’t deteriorating, we are just moving sideways at the bottom,” Thabi Leoka, an economist at Argon Asset Management in Johannesburg, said by phone. 

“The political noise is a problem and it’s the biggest risk, I even think that it’s a bigger risk than growth.”

A cut by S&P would move the company’s assessment of the nation’s creditworthiness to below investment grade for the first time in 16 years and put South Africa in line with Russia and Indonesia. Investors already consider South Africa more risky than Russia. The cost of insuring against non-payment of debt for five years using credit-default swaps is 23 basis points higher than for Russia.

Still, a cut to junk on the foreign-currency rating may not lead to significant forced bond selling by foreign investors.

South Africa’s local-currency ratings, which are usually referenced for inclusion in global benchmark indexes such as Citigroup’s World Government Bond Index, are several notches above junk. However, a foreign-currency downgrade may hurt sentiment and add to woes for the rand in a year of domestic political turmoil and emerging-market uncertainty fuelled by Brexit and the election of Donald Trump as United States president.

The currency weakened 0.7% to 14.5262 per dollar as of 1.57pm on Friday. Yields on rand-denominated government bonds due December 2026 rose 6 basis points to 9.05%.

“While S&P is likely to remain quite bearish and quite negative on South Africa, there is sufficient scope for them to keep our rating at a BBB- level,” Mohammed Nalla, head of strategic research at Nedbank, said by phone. 

“Potentially, this buys us another six months’ worth of time. It doesn’t mean we are out of the woods.” – Bloomberg

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Zuma tells ANC top six not to hold their breath

Former president Jacob Zuma will only meet ANC leaders if deputy chief justice Raymond Zondo recuses himself from the state capture commission

‘Captured’ water utility exec holes up

Thami Hlongwa seems to be in hiding after a blacklisted technology company scored millions from Umgeni Water and the owner was murdered

More top stories

Pregnant women should be vaccinated, doctors say

New research shows that there has been an increase in maternal deaths during the Covid-19 restriction

Simeone is Atlético’s secret weapon

El Cholo remains true to himself — consistent, totally committed and prepared to graft — and these values are retained by the team

The private-sector players who facilitated public-sector fraud

Let us never forget the private-sector players who facilitated public-sector fraud

Semenya confirms she’s taking testosterone battle to European Court of...

Caster Semenya’s latest legal challenge follows a series of setbacks that seemed to have ended her chances of competing in her preferred events

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…