Zondo commission receives #GuptaLeaks hard drives as evidence, with conditions

Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo — the chair of the commission of inquiry into state capture — ordered on Friday that #GuptaLeaks electronic data be received as evidence before the commission.

The data, which is physically located on hard drives, consists of hundreds of thousands of emails that allegedly detail the extent of the Gupta family’s alleged role in state capture.

The commission is in possession of the original hard drive — named HDD-H — as well as two forensic images, a technical term for copies. The two copies are referred to as HDD-H1 and HDD-H2 respectively.

As part of his order, Zondo said that no person or party outside of the commission shall have access to the original data or its copies until the data is presented by the legal team at a public hearing of the commission.

Zondo further ordered that if anyone wishes to have access to the hard drives before the time specified (when the legal team presents its work on the data), “the leave of this commission will be required.”

The commission’s legal team started presenting its arguments for the admission of the hard drives on Thursday but Zondo remained unconvinced of the relevance of admitting the data at the end of the sitting.

At the start of Friday’s sitting, Zondo was still not sure about the application on the basis that investigations into the hard drives still needed to be done.

READ MORE: Whistle-blowers, clones of hard drives and secret meetings

“For purposes of investigation, if there is still going to be investigation, it might be difficult to say whether something is relevant.”

Zondo mentioned how in a court of law, investigations of the evidence would be done first before the evidence is admitted but that since the commission is not a judicial arena, it is important that everyone keeps going back to “basic proposition that this is not a court of law”.

Zondo also raised the point that since the hard drives are in the possession of the commission, he doesn’t see why the legal team and investigators cannot do their work without the evidence being admitted first.

“It is not clear why, from the affidavit, that has to be so,” Zondo said.

However, the legal team managed to convince the commission’s chair by making amendments to their original application.

In the original motion, the team sought to have the hard drives admitted as evidence but on Friday, evidence leader Advocate Kate Hofmeyr conceded that the term ‘admitted’ has “loaded connotations” because it suggests a judicial process. Hofmeyr said upon reflection, the legal team deemed this term as “not helpful”.

Hofmeyr referred to section 6.2 of the commission’s rules which stipulates that the commission may receive evidence, instead of admit it.

“This means the commission can receive evidence relevant to its investigation”, Hofmeyr said.

Hofmeyr further argued that one of the major reasons the application was brought to the commission now rather than later was to inform the public “that this is what we have and will be working on”, so that anyone who wants to come forward can do so.

She also said the HDD- H data is relevant because many of the emails come from former Gupta-owned Sahara Computers which is “squarely in the terms of reference” of the commission.

The commission will resume on October 3 to hear evidence from Finance Minister Nhlanhla Nene. 

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Come what may, the UIF will pay

The fund – the main safety net for unemployed workers – will run at an almost R20-billion deficit

‘Terrorised’ family shines a light on traditional leadership for vulnerable...

The ambiguity between traditional and constitutional leadership has been exposed by the violent banishment of an Eastern Cape family

More top stories

High court grants Dlamini-Zuma leave to appeal adverse ruling on...

The court held that the ongoing state of disaster meant there was public interest in the legal test applied to measures taken to contain the pandemic

Concourt to hear Zondo commission’s application for contempt order against...

The former president has one week to file answering papers in the application that also seeks a prison sentence imposed on him

Koko maintains he had no idea he was exchanging emails...

On his fourth appearance before the commission, the former Eskom CEO maintains he was tricked into sharing company information with a third party

Zuma foundation claims ex-president was prepared to testify, but Zondo...

Zuma’s namesake organisation twists facts and the law – he told Zondo he would answer questions but only in private to the deputy chief justice

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…