Court rules that Erasmus commission is unconstitutional

The Erasmus commission, set up to probe alleged irregularities in the City of Cape Town, is unconstitutional, a full bench of the high court ruled on Monday.

Judges Kevin Swain and Chris Nicholson, sitting in the Cape High Court, also said the appointment of a serving judge to chair the commission is incompatible with the principle of separation of powers, and is therefore unlawful and invalid.

The commission was set up by former Western Cape premier Ebrahim Rasool ostensibly to probe the legality of the City of Cape Town’s bribery investigation into renegade councillor Badih Chaaban.

However, the judges said Rasool’s motive had in fact been the ”improper one” of seeking to embarrass his political opponents, in particular the Democratic Alliance (DA), which leads the city.

Rasool’s actions in establishing it had been arbitrary and unlawful, and his decision therefore ”falls to be set aside”.

The judges said Western Cape police Commissioner Mzwandile Petros broke the law when he handed over information gained in police raids to Rasool.

The court challenge was launched by the city, which was then joined by the DA.

They claimed Rasool, an African National Congress appointee, had purely political motives in appointing the body, and that the use of a serving judge — Nathan Erasmus — to head it, is unconstitutional.

The case was heard by Swain and Nicholson, who are from the KwaZulu-Natal bench, because Erasmus is a Cape judge.

The Erasmus commission had suspended its sittings pending the outcome of the case. — Sapa

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

What comes after the ANC?

We need to reimagine South Africa without the ANC and if we do not, we will either live with false hope or the country’s crisis will intensify

Police fail parents who babies died in alleged negligence incident,...

A lost police case docket and a hospital failing to report alleged medical misconduct adds to parents’ grief after losing twins.

OPINION| Black writers and publishers are South Africa’s ‘linguistic orphans’

The challenges we face in the world of scholarly and leisure reading and writing are not unique to our country but it is crucial to overcome them if we want to be as good as we look in our Constitution

‘A Still Life’ goes to root of the connection of...

An homage to selected dying trees, ‘A Still Life’ provides viewers with an opportunity to consider a moment of connection between humans, trees and the natural environment

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…