Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Healthcare Bill passes first US Senate test

A sweeping healthcare overhaul narrowly cleared its first hurdle in the US Senate on Saturday, with Democrats casting 60 party-line votes to open debate on the biggest healthcare changes in decades.

In the first Senate test for President Barack Obama’s top domestic priority, Democrats unanimously backed a procedural motion to open debate over the opposition of 39 Republicans. Republican George Voinovich did not vote.

Democrats needed 60 votes to approve the motion in the 100-member Senate and had no margin for error — they control exactly 60 votes.

The Democratic victory was assured earlier in the day when the party’s last two holdouts, Blanche Lincoln and Mary Landrieu, said they would support the motion but would not commit to backing the final Bill without changes.

”I believe that it is more important that we begin this debate to improve our nation’s healthcare system for all Americans rather than just simply drop the issue and walk away,” Lincoln said in a speech hours before the vote.

The debate will begin on November 30 and is expected to last at least three weeks. The House of Representatives has passed its own version, and differences in the two would have to be reconciled in January before Obama could sign a final measure.

The healthcare reform Bill would expand coverage to millions of uninsured and bar insurance practices like denying coverage to those with pre-existing conditions.

The legislation would spark the biggest changes in the $2,5-trillion healthcare system — which accounts for one-sixth of the US economy — since the 1965 creation of the Medicare government health insurance plan for the elderly.

The stakes are high for Obama, with his political standing and legislative agenda on the line less than a year into his first term. White House spokesperson Robert Gibbs said Obama was gratified by the vote and ”looks forward to a thorough and productive debate”.

During a formal roll call, senators sat at their desks and called out their votes as their names were read. Visitors in the galleries cheered when the final tally was announced.

The healthcare overhaul still faces significant challenges, with Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid trying to accommodate competing views in his party on issues like abortion, a government-run insurance plan and efforts to cut costs.

Republicans also have vowed to delay or block the Bill, which they condemned as a costly government intrusion in the private sector that would raise insurance premiums, reduce consumer choices and raise taxes.

Debate under way
”The healthcare debate is now officially under way on this 2 074 page, multi-trillion-dollar healthcare experiment,” Republican Senate leader Mitch McConnell said.

He said the final Democratic holdouts had to ”twist themselves into a pretzel” to justify voting to move ahead on the bill. Almost all Senate Bills that clear the first hurdle eventually pass, he said.

”The easiest time to change this Bill, if you were serious about it, is right now,” McConnell told reporters. ”The time of maximum leverage would have been before tonight’s vote.”

Landrieu and Lincoln, moderates from conservative Southern states where the overhaul is unpopular, said they simply wanted the debate to begin so they could work for more changes.

Lincoln, who faces a tough re-election battle next year, said she opposes the government-run insurance option included in the Bill and will not vote for final passage if it remains.

”I’m not thinking about my re-election, the legacy of a president or whether Democrats or Republicans are going to be able to claim victory,” she said.

Landrieu said she wanted to change the Bill to make healthcare more affordable, ease the burden on small businesses and rein in the growth of costs.

”There are enough significant reforms and safeguards in this Bill to move forward, but much more work needs to be done before I can support this effort,” Landrieu said.

Landrieu and Lincoln had been showered with attention by Reid and Obama administration officials as they pondered their vote.

In her Senate floor speech, Landrieu defended her successful effort to win more funds in the Bill for Medicaid, the government health programme for the poor, for her home state of Louisiana.

”I am proud to have fought for it,” she said. ”But that is not the reason I am moving to debate.”

The Senate Bill would require virtually all Americans to buy insurance and would set up exchanges where they could choose among various options. It would offer subsidies to help low-income workers pay for the coverage.

Republicans have criticised its tax increases to help pay for the expanded insurance coverage. It would also raise the Medicare payroll tax on high-income workers, which is used to finance Medicare, and impose a tax on high-cost ”Cadillac” insurance plans. – Reuters

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them.

Related stories


If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Subscribers only

‘Exciting’ ramp-up for Covid jabs

As more vaccines arrive in the country, South Africa could administer 420 000 doses a day

Mokgoro was party to talks of his resignation

The North West premier has defied the interim provincial committee’s decision

More top stories

‘Exciting’ ramp-up for Covid jabs

As more vaccines arrive in the country, South Africa could administer 420 000 doses a day

Mokgoro was party to talks of his resignation

The North West premier has defied the interim provincial committee’s decision

Richard Calland: Cyril’s wicked cabinet conundrum

Three weeks ago, a second term for the president seemed a safe bet, but the insurgency has thrown the puzzle pieces in the air

ConCourt finds that protection of LGBT+ rights was intrinsic to...

The court also found that the term hurtful should be excised from the Equality Act in that it did not meet the justification threshold in the Constitution and gave Parliament 24 months to do so

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…