Court dismisses government’s Walmart appeal

The Competition Appeal Court dismissed government’s appeal to the Walmart Massmart merger on Friday.

Judge Dennis Davis, the president of the Competition Appeal Court, handed down the decision at a hearing in Cape Town today, after the appeal was heard by the court in October last year.

However Davis did acknowledge that there were legitimate concerns about the effect of the deal on small producers and employment.

The court ruled that three experts be commissioned within a month to produce a report, which will determine “the best means by which South African small- and medium-sized suppliers could participate in Walmart’s global value chain and thereby ensure that benefits from this merger will flow to this important sector of the economy”.

The court ruled that the South African Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers Union would appoint one of the experts, the three government ministries another and the merged entities the third.

The experts have three months to complete their study, or four months from the date of the judgment.

The three parties will have a month to respond to the study’s findings before it is submitted to the Competition Appeal Court for evaluation.

The costs of the study must be paid for by the merging parties.

The court also ruled that the merged entity must reinstate 503 employees who were retrenched in 2009 and 2010.

The tribunal had previously ruled that these 503 retrenched employees should be given preferential treatment when Massmart hires more staff.

Following the Competition Tribunal’s approval of the merger on May 31 2011, the ministries of trade and industry, economic development and agriculture and fisheries lodged an appeal to the decision.

The three ministries argued that they did not have a “fair hearing” before the tribunal.

They contended that the tribunal had erred in refusing to order the merging parties to discover a range of documents which had been sought by them and which, in their view, were wholly material to the determination of the merger.

Further, they argued that the tribunal had erred in making certain scheduling decisions with regard to the oral hearing which then precluded the parties, which opposed the merger from fully and adequately ventilating their concerns.

The appeal by government was attacked by critics who argued that it created the perception of government as being against foreign direct investment.

However the entry of Walmart into South Africa through the purchase of 51% of the ordinary share capital of Massmart, which was first mooted in September 2010, has faced serious opposition from Cosatu and its affiliated unions.

The tribunal hearing was dogged by regular protests outside the department of trade and industry’s head office in Pretoria, where the Tribunal is housed.

However the court’s judgment seemed to dismiss decision around job losses stating, “the evidence indicated that consumers will benefit from lower prices and that these lower prices may, in turn, generate greater job creation than the job losses that may result from the merger”.

“There was insufficient evidence to conclude that the detrimental effects of the merger would outweigh the clear benefits.”

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Lloyd Gedye
Lloyd Gedye
Lloyd Gedye is a freelance journalist and one of the founders of The Con.

Related stories


Subscribers only

The South African connection: How mercenaries aided Trump ally in...

The UN found that Trump ally Erik Prince violated the Libyan arms embargo. Here are the South Africans the report says helped him to do so

Q&A Sessions: African court ‘will be a tough job’ — Dumisa...

Lawyer, author and political activist Dumisa Ntsebeza talks to Nicolene de Wee about his appointment as judge of the African Court on Human and...

More top stories

In a bizarre twist VBS liquidators sue KPMG for R863mn

In filed court documents, the VBS liquidators are blaming auditing firm KPMG’s negligence for the alleged looting of the bank

Snip, snip: Mboweni eyes wage bill, other future spending cuts

Last year, the finance minister noted that increased government spending has failed to promote growth over the past decade

Budget: Mboweni pegs recovery hopes on vaccine efficacy, lower public...

The treasury forecasts 3.3% growth, but warns this will fall to 1.6% if the fledgeling vaccination programme fails to stem successive Covid waves

READ IT IN FULL: Mboweni’s 2021 budget speech

Read the finance minister's address on the budget for 2021

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…