Aliki Karasaridis: A test of our constitutional rights

I knew it was going to be controversial. A tweet the day before had prepared me … I thought. It wasn't the supposed "vulgarity" that made me gasp but his daring to once again test the legitimate boundaries of artistic expression despite the president's R5-million defamation lawsuit still hanging over his head.

Its success is that it got me thinking about what is personal, public, political and racist.  What constitutes fair comment? And does the severity of our political discourse warrant the severity of this comment?

The government didn't think so. It called on Zapiro to withdraw the cartoon saying it was a "defamatory attack" on the president's character and violated his right to dignity.

Is this the case?  Is the president attempting to perpetuate power through suppressing any political expression he deems subversive?

An issue that arises is how to balance the values of freedom of expression, a free press and the right to dignity in a democratic society.

Zapiro says The Spear matter has not been resolved properly and I agree with him. Silencing our artists and purging ideas signals the beginnings of a fascist state. And we know what that looks like.

"The ANC bullied the Goodman Gallery and the City Press into compromising. Freedom of expression suffered a blow," he said.

"Dissident views are essential for real change. Irreverence toward leaders who take themselves too seriously is a vital part of democracy."

Political and artistic expression is protected by the Constitution and should be afforded greater protection in the courts. This is how Zapiro puts Zuma – his and our collective president – under the spotlight, not "Zuma the black man" as some would like to argue. What constitutes legitimate debate in other countries often shapes up along racial lines here.

The success of any democracy depends on the robust criticism of politicians, because of the inordinate power and influence they yield. The ANC's social cohesion summit sought to waft over diverging views when the discussion we should have been having is what we would like to be seeing and hearing from our leaders.

Zapiro is not challenging the president's right to dignity. I like to think he is challenging him to deliver rights of substance – economic rights – upholding the right to dignity and equality of every South African.

Journalists and artists in Africa continue to face restrictions to the free exercise of their profession. Zapiro is one such artist who deserves our constitutional protection.

Keep the powerful accountable

Subscribe for R30/mth for the first three months. Cancel anytime.

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.

Aliki Karasaridis
Aliki Karasaridis is the Mail & Guardians Women and Thought Leader editor. In between juggling bloggers, trolls and running after her toddler, shes desperately trying to get some sleep. Technicolor films make her happy and she loves a good digital or home-made feed.

Related stories

WELCOME TO YOUR M&G

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

Advertising

Latest stories

Montana backs Prasa-fraud accused Mthimkhulu as court hears how he...

Montana testified that ‘unqualified’ Mthimkhulu was the right engineer for the state rail agency, despite his acquisition of allegedly faulty locomotives

The rogue daughter, mounting bills, mum trustees: How Mandela’s artefacts...

The Mandela family saga has not abated: Makaziwe faces criminal charges; trustees, including Moseneke, are silent; and Madiba’s possessions were saved from auction only at the last minute

​​Shrewd management of future Covid waves is key to the...

Stakeholders are cautiously optimistic about 2022, citing relaxed restrictions and discussions with the government as reasons for hope.

‘The Girl in the Yellow Jumper’ is the first Ugandan...

The Ugandan film, directed by Loukman Ali, teaches that the good thing to do is not always the right thing
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×