Trengove probes ‘absurd’ claims at Breytenbach hearing

Trengove continued with his cross-examination of the National Prosecuting Authority's (NPA) witness lawyer Ronnie Mendelow at the NPA's head office in Silverton, Pretoria. Mendelow represents Imperial Crown Trading (ICT) in its high-profile prospecting rights dispute with Kumba Iron Ore subsidiary, Sishen Iron Ore Company.

Both the NPA and ICT have alleged that Breytenbach lacked objectivity when she was involved in the fraud investigation into ICT, and that she had an "unnaturally close relationship" with Kumba's advocate Michael Hellens.

Breytenbach is further accused of being "one-sided" in that she did not take seriously a counter-claim of fraud made against Sishen Iron Ore Company, while she was involved in investigating the ICT fraud allegation.

In October 2011, Mendelow on behalf of ICT, laid a complaint against Breytenbach with the national director of public prosecutions which effectively acted as a catalyst for her suspension from the NPA in April last year.

On Tuesday morning Trengove put it to the hearing: "What I am going to demonstrate is that the one complaint was a substantial complaint and the other one [department of mineral resources complaint against Sishen Iron Ore Company] wasn't."

'Flimsy evidence'
Trengove explained that while not all the evidence was necessarily relevant "it goes to the heart of Mendelow's evidence in chief".

"It is true, this witness did not dwell on the incriminating evidence against his client [ICT] but he did testify at length on the claim against ICT. The charge against Breytenbach is that she took the one accusation seriously and not the other.

"I am trying to demonstrate it was a very serious allegation, whereas the complaint against Sioc [Sishen Iron Ore Company] was based on very flimsy evidence and it was absurd," Trengove said.

He further claimed that the there was "substantial evidence" that ICT committed fraud, and further that there was "an abundant amount of evidence that the department of mineral resources officials were involved in ICT's application".

Hawks investigator Colonel Sandra van Wyk was involved in the investigation into allegations that ICT allegedly colluded with the department's officials to commit fraud, forgery, uttering and corruption in respect of ICT and Sioc's applications for rights to the Sishen iron ore mine in the Northern Cape.

Stake award
Both Breytenbach and Van Wyk are accused by ICT and the NPA of engaging Hellens in drafting affidavits for an application for a search and seizure warrant of ICT's offices in July 2011. The warrant was a culmination of problems, which began when the department awarded a 21.4% stake in Sishen mine to ICT.

Sioc took the matter to court where the company applied for a review application of the department's decision to grant ICT the prospecting rights. The North Gauteng High Court then ruled that the stake belonged to Sioc and Kumba. The matter is being appealed.

Trengove put it to the hearing that it is the "contention of the witness [Mendelow] and the contention of the NPA that the investigating team – Breytenbach and Van Wyk – only took seriously the accusations against ICT and did not take the counter accusations against Sioc equally as seriously".

Trengove noted: "For instance, Mendelow's evidence in chief: 'Well I say this was clearly a one-sided attempt only on nailing ICT. There was no interest in the investigation against Kumba, [which] was ignored.'"

The accusation against Sioc was that it had tampered with ICT's application for the prospecting rights which had to be lodged by May 4 2009. Mendelow testified that Breytenbach showed no interest in pursuing the allegation that Sioc had committed fraud.

Allegations are 'absurd'
But Trengove shot back that the allegations that Sioc had intereferred with ICT's application form was "absurd" and that "there was a strong case against ICT".

At one point Trengove referred to the allegation made by ICT that Sioc had surreptitiously "slipped" false copies of title deeds into ICT's application for the prospecting rights, which Trengove said was "not supported by a scrap of evidence" and that it was merely a "contention" made by a desperate ICT.  

Mendelow tried to claw back saying: "Mr Trengove is insinuating that this explanation of ICT is absolutely absurd, and I am explaining that Sioc went to these lengths; they would not have sat on their hands on 4 May [2009] to see whether there were any competing applications. They would have gone all out to do whatever they could, to retard any competing application."

Cross-examination continues.

* Got a tip-off for us about this story? Email [email protected]

The M&G Centre for Investigative Journalism (amaBhungane) produced this story. All views are ours. See for our stories, activities and funding sources.

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever. But it comes at a cost. Advertisers are cancelling campaigns, and our live events have come to an abrupt halt. Our income has been slashed.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years. We’ve survived thanks to the support of our readers, we will need you to help us get through this.

To help us ensure another 35 future years of fiercely independent journalism, please subscribe.

Sally Evans
Guest Author

ConCourt settles the law on the public protector and interim...

The Constitutional Court said it welcomed robust debate but criticised the populist rhetoric in the battle between Busisiwe Mkhwebane and Minister Pravin Gordhan

Where is the deputy president?

David Mabuza is hard at work — it’s just not taking place in the public eye. The rumblings and discussion in the ANC are about factions in the ruling party, succession and ousting him

Press Releases

Empowering his people to unleash their potential

'Being registered as an AGA(SA) means you are capable of engineering an idea and turning it into money,' says Raymond Mayekisa

What is an AGA(SA) and AT(SA) and why do they matter?

If your company has these qualified professionals it will help improve efficiencies and accelerate progress by assisting your organisation to perform better

Mining company uses rich seam of technology to gear up for Covid-19

Itec Direct technology provides instant temperature screening of staff returniing to the workplace with no human contact

Covid-19 and Back to School Webinar

If our educators can take care of themselves, they can take care of the children they teach

5G technology is the future

Besides a healthcare problem Covid-19 is also a data issue and 5G technology, with its lightning speed, can help to curb its spread

JTI off to court for tobacco ban: Government not listening to industry or consumers

The tobacco ban places 109 000 jobs and 179 000 wholesalers and retailers at risk — including the livelihood of emerging farmers

Holistic Financial Planning for Professionals Webinar

Our lives are constantly in flux, so it makes sense that your financial planning must be reviewed frequently — preferably on an annual basis

Undeterred by Covid-19 pandemic, China and Africa hold hands, building a community of a shared future for mankind

It is clear that building a community with a shared future for all mankind has become a more pressing task than ever before

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday