‘True Detective’ looks at our darker nature

Here's a prediction: at the end of the year, when television critics are drawing up their perennial top 10 lists, True Detective will be widely seen as the best new series of 2014. Perhaps it's hubristic to make such a guess now – it's only February – but True Detective is such a remarkably ambitious series that it seems foolhardy to bet against it.

True Detective stars Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson, who are the latest examples of bona fide Hollywood stars to try their hand at television, play detectives Cohle and Hart investigating a politically-charged murder in rural Louisiana.

Cohle is an outsider; an existential nihilist in a police department full of Christian conservatives. McConaughey plays the role with a volcanic intensity that is mesmerising and, at times, discomforting. He argues that voluntary self-extinction would be the best path for humanity, and admits that he would probably kill himself if he didn't "lack the constitution for suicide".

Meanwhile, Harrelson is given the challenging task of playing McConaughey's everyman counterpart. Hart styles himself as a family man and is outwardly appalled by the darkness of his partner's world view. But he has vices of his own: he mistreats his wife and condescends to his mistress, with whom he is having a kinky sexual affair.

True Detective sometimes feels like the spiritual descendent of a previous HBO crime drama, The Wire, which is still considered by many critics to be the best television show ever made.

But while The Wire was a merciless commentary on big-city politics – including the policy failures of American liberalism – True Detective is a useful reminder that similar problems exist in the Republican-leaning heartland. The detectives are stymied by constant political interference from their superiors, who want to portray the murder as an "anti-Christian hate crime", despite strong evidence to the contrary.

On a deeper level, however, this series isn’t just about crime, or even the politics of crime. It's about philosophy, and the oldest questions that people have asked themselves: what is the right way for human beings to live? It forces its audience to consider whether Cohle's pessimism or Hart's stoic conservatism is the rational response to the world in which we find ourselves.

True Detective is frequently beautiful, in the same way that a well-composed Instagram photograph is beautiful. But the subject matter is disturbing enough to make one wonder at times whether McConaughey's character might actually be right about everything.

True Detective airs on at Fridays at 21:30 on M-Net

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Laurence Caromba
Laurence Caromba works from Pretoria, South Africa. I teach International Studies at Monash SA. I tweet about culture, politics, technology, foreign affairs & anything else that interests me. Views my own. Laurence Caromba has over 165 followers on Twitter.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Eskom and unions reach wage agreement, workers back at work

The power utility warned that the system would take some time to recover because maintenance work had been postponed because of the unprotected strike

Start of State Security Agency R1-million theft case delayed

Thuso Oesi, a former SSA administrator accused of fraud, did not arrive in court for medical reasons

Why government would fall short of cash if the fuel...

But restructuring the Road Accident Fund levy would reduce pressure on consumers

Gordhan’s Eskom ‘blame game’ underwhelms ANC leaders

Sources at a meeting of the national executive committee said a call was made to shift the power utility to Gwede Mantashe’s ministry of minerals and resources

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…