Five significant findings from the South African Human Rights Commission’s #EducationProtestReport

The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) has released its report on how protest action impacts the right to basic education. With the tough task of balancing the right to protest along with a student’s right to basic education, the SAHRC made significant findings based on hearings with various stakeholders.

The report was compiled after the SAHRC put together a panel who listened to submissions made by the department of basic education, the South African Police Service (SAPS), and non-governmental organisations such as Basic Education For All, a voluntary organisation in Limpopo. The hearings came about in the aftermath of the protests in Vuwani, Limpopo earlier this year when a number of schools were torched.

Some of the key findings mimic what happened in Vuwani such as how, in many cases, protesters are not centering their protest on education.

1. Most protests have nothing to do with education 
The SAHRC found that although schools and access to schools may be affected by protest action, education is often not the point of the protests. In South Africa, there are least 13 000 protests in a year which involve a rage of issues including water, electricity, proper sanitation services, housing and unemployment.

“The commission finds that the right to a basic education is affected by protest-related action arising from causes that in most cases may be unrelated to the provision of basic education. Protesters who deny access to education are violating the right to a basic education of the affected pupils,” the report said.

2. Schools get burned because leaders don’t listen 
More than 8 million South Africans are without jobs. In their presentation to the commission, Basic Education For All said the Limpopo government had failed to address deep-rooted community concerns and the “matter was left to fester”. In the report, the SAHRC finds that adequate responses from leadership are not a problem unique to Limpopo.

“The investigative hearing noted that the challenges of unemployment and poverty that face South Africa have created high levels of frustration among young people. The extent of frustration does not appear to be sufficiently recognised by people in all levels of leadership,” the report said.

“The panel identified a growing sense of despair, frustration and discontent that is in part a result of people not being able to experience the changes promised by the democratic transition.”

3. Protesters haven’t experienced the better life basic education promises 
In its report, the hearings noted that people don’t always deliberately target schools, but they do it because government responds quicker when schools are affected. Those who don’t target schools – but who may affect protests by disrupting transport services or access routes – may have less sympathy for basic education because they have not witnessed a change in their own lives.

“It appears that the disregard for the right to a basic education may also be based on a view that education is not necessarily a guarantee of a better life. This is a view expressed particularly by some who live in conditions of poverty, unemployment and joblessness,” the report said.

Thus, the report concluded that the right to basic education isn’t always respected. The education department, in its submission to the panel, recommended that guidelines for greater awareness around the importance of basic education be developed and implemented.

4. Authorities like the education department and the SAPS are slow to respond
The report indicates that both the SAPS and the basic education department aren’t always prepared for protests and there is no uniform policy in place to mitigate the effects of protests on pupils and schools. The education department admitted that it had been “surprised” by the incidents in Vuwani.

“The department of basic education was overwhelmed by the situation and did not imagine that so many schools would be affected. The department is seeking expert assistance from outside it to help identify alternative solutions and interventions,” the report said.

The SAPS, in its submission at the hearing, gave a detailed response which included that measures had been taken to protect schools in the aftermath of Vuwani. However, the SAPS said they are under-resourcedand are struggling to manage public order when there are at least 13 000 protests a year. The SAPS resources include 28 units with 4 227 members, and there are 25 720 schools around the country. There is currently a three-year plan in place to increase Public Order Policing (POP) units and the members in these units.

The SAPS have been heavily criticised for the violent manner with which they have responded to protests in the past, but the report gave a reminder as to what the mandate of POP units in the SAPs is.

“The role of POP is to manage protest. POP is not supposed to suppress the rights of people who protest but rather to ensure that protests do not interfere with the realisation of other people’s rights,” the report stated.

5. The impact on pupils 
The report found that most pupils affected by protests are poor and are relying on an education system that does not provide them with the best quality education. As such, they are deeply affected when exam time is near.

“Most of the schools targeted in protest-related actions are located in the most marginalised sections of society where conditions at schools and the attendance of pupils are already precarious,” the report stated.

Teachers too have a harder time performing their jobs and in some cases, pupils are roped in to protests to achieve the political objective of older protesters.

The report did, however, fail to get much insight from pupils themselves. Many of the submissions were made by government departments, community leaders and other institutions. People who protest were also largely excluded from the hearings, which meant that much of the insight gathered on why schools become enmeshed in protest action is not told directly from people who protest at schools.

Among one of its key recommendations was that the education department develop a National Public Protest Response Team that will include relevant departments to establish early warning systems and provide clarity on the roles and policy of each department when protests take place.

The report is set to be tabled in Parliament so that the recommendations can be implemented.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Raeesa Pather
Raeesa Pather
Ra’eesa Pather is a Cape Town-based general news and features journalist.

Related stories

The future of learning is here — and it’s mobile

The smartphone is a crucial tool for enabling lifelong learning and has the potential to democratise education, particularly with internet penetration and access to data both continuing to rise

Institutions of higher learning should commemorate their casualties

The bust of Matikweni Nkuna at Tshwane University of Technology is an example of how we should honour those who fought for equal access to education

International rankings don’t measure what matters

The privilege-protecting systems we use for grading universities are simply poor science

Q&A Sessions: ‘A good teacher must love the kids’

As a child, Mokhudu Machaba had to cross a flooded river on her way to school in rural Limpopo. She fell pregnant at 15 but returned to complete her matric and found employment as a domestic worker to pay for her tertiary education. The dedicated educator, who has been shortlisted for the Global Teacher Prize talks to Lucas Ledwaba

Invest in children to boost SA’s recovery

Providing effective, population-scale family support and 21st century transformative education is a nonnegotiable if we are to have any chance of eradicating violence, poverty, and inequality.

Young academics need mentors and sponsors

New lecturers and researchers need guidance on achieving targets, or risk being thrown into the deep end without being taught how to swim

Subscribers only

The shame of 40 000 missing education certificates

Graduates are being left in the lurch by a higher education department that is simply unable to deliver the crucial certificates proving their qualifications - in some cases dating back to 1992

The living nightmare of environmental activists who protest mine expansion

Last week Fikile Ntshangase was gunned down as activists fight mining company Tendele’s expansions. Community members tell the M&G about the ‘kill lists’ and the dread they live with every day

More top stories

Fifteen witnesses for vice-chancellor probe

Sefako Makgatho University vice-chancellor Professor Peter Mbati had interdicted parliament last month from continuing with the inquiry

Constitutional Court ruling on restructuring dispute is good for employers

A judgment from the apex court empowers employers to change their workers’ contracts — without consultation

Audi Q8: Perfectly cool

The Audi Q8 is designed to be the king in the elite SUV class. But is it a victim of its own success?

KZN officials cash in on ‘danger pay for Covid-19’

Leadership failures at Umdoni local municipality in KwaZulu-Natal have caused a ‘very unhappy’ ANC PEC to fire the mayor and chief whip

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday