Left-leaning economists must stop hiding and challenge peddled misconceptions

Right-wing economists get way too much airtime in South Africa. This is both because of laziness in the media and because left-leaning economists appear to take a vow of silence on crucial political economy debates.

The effect is that one has to listen to the likes of Dawie Roodt, for example, going completely unchallenged in claiming that the exploitation of hundreds of thousands of workers is not exploitation and that it makes economic sense.

Take the debate on the proposed national minimum wage as an example. The amount of R20 an hour is what most of the stakeholders appear to be signing up for.

Labour federation Cosatu hasn’t done so yet but agrees that a minimum wage is necessary. They remain worried about the exact figure and how it is to be implemented. Or, at least, that is what they are mumbling when queried about why they have not yet signed the deal.

If you look at the labour market, we currently have hundreds of thousands of workers who earn less than R20 an hour. We are not going to break the back of poverty nor massively reduce inequality by protecting these workers with a legally enforceable minimum wage level of R20 an hour. But it certainly will make some difference to many families for whom, literally, every single cent counts.

Right-wing economists pit the jobless against the exploited workers. They insist that the only way for a farm labourer’s unemployed cousin to get employed is not to impose any minimum wage on the farmer.

That is sheer madness. Obviously, if a business owner has no regard for a fair distribution of the value that is created in his or her business and economic sector, they will try to keep down their wage bill.

Cost structures are minimised by capitalists to maximise profits and ensure the greatest levels of returns on shareholder investment. That is the very essence of capitalism. A labour market that is not regulated by the state has no regard for considerations of fairness or justice. Markets are, at best, efficient allocative mechanisms and, at worst, treated as if they have the agency and authority of actual human beings who dare not question where these markets settle the cheapest unit price of labour.

The result is that gross income inequality would go unchallenged if labour markets were to be fetishised as inherently fair. They are not inherently fair. Fairness is not built into market dynamics. Markets are simply a device for supply and demand to find each other.

In a country with our history, in which workers have very little real negotiating power, it is bonkers to pretend that an individual worker has the meaningful freedom to negotiate a fair wage for herself. In unskilled job sectors in particular, workers are “wage takers”. In that context, it is crucial that we approximate a living wage by topping up what the unit price of labour is determined by the market.

We are not even, mind you, talking here about a “living wage”. There is a gigantic gap between the proposed R20 an hour minimum wage figure and what is required to afford to live decently. And still the right-wing economists callously disregard considerations of justice in their framing of these trade-offs.

There is also, of course, a reality here about the relationship between the unemployed and the exploited worker’s social relations that is overlooked. When you introduce a minimum wage, you help to scaffold the burden of the exploited worker whose wage is shared in a household of other poor workers and unemployed relatives.

Because right-wing economists do not live among the people they theorise about, they make theoretical assumptions that do not track reality.

You do not have, in one corner, a group of people called “unemployed South Africans” and, in the other, “employed South Africans”. In one family, you will find a mix of people who are unemployed, whose sole “income” is a social grant, and the odd person who is an unskilled or semiskilled worker earning an appallingly low wage.

This means that, in the real economy, an imposed minimum wage will actually uplift the entire household. It won’t fatten the unskilled worker and leave the unemployed cousin outside the hut, perishing.

Obviously, we need to break the back of the unemployment crisis too. We have the unenviable crisis in our country of simultaneously having to grow the economy, reduce unemployment and ensure that labour markets are structured as fairly as possible.

We cannot disregard urgent historical questions about immoral labour practices just because the unemployment levels also need to be solved. We must increase productivity, regulate gross profit distributions to the top tier of workers in the economy, protect the exploited at the bottom of the employment rung, and scaffold small and medium enterprises.

The public debate would be enhanced if left-leaning economists would stop hiding. These lefties should also leave the ideology talk for us liberal arts types and rather challenge right-wing economists’ numbers and models.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Eusebius Mckaiser
Eusebius McKaiser
Eusebius McKaiser is a political and social analyst at the Wits Centre for Ethics. He is also a popular radio talk show host, a top international debate coach, a master of ceremonies and a public speaker of note. He loves nothing more than a good argument, having been both former National South African Debate Champion and the 2011 World Masters Debate Champion. His analytic articles and columns have been widely published in South African newspapers and the New York Times. McKaiser has studied law and philosophy. He taught philosophy in South Africa and England.

Related stories

Economists should really look wider before speaking about schools

‘We believe that opening schools without addressing an unfair and unequal education system that disadvantages poor, working class and rural children will increase inequality.’

Gig workers are at the front line of pandemic

There is evidence that platform workers worldwide have unfair work conditions and lack benefits and protections afforded to employees

Would wage transparency work in SA?

In Scandinavian countries, citizens can look up what any other citizen earns in an online national database. Could South Africa use a version of income transparency? Economists, as usual, are divided.

EDITORIAL: Jo’burg’s ‘horror factory’

Workers at the factory were found to be toiling under appalling conditions for only R65 a day.

CCMA case increases from national minimum wage

Cases referred to the organisation increased by 4% since last year

Bare minimum is just not enough

The stipend for the community work programme is R780 a month — but they want the basic minimum wage of R3 500 a month that some workers now get

Subscribers only

Free State branches gun for Ace

Parts of the provincial ANC will target their former premier, Magashule, and the Free State PEC in a rolling mass action campaign

SAA bailout raises more questions

As the government continues to grapple with the troubles facing the airline, it would do well to keep on eye on the impending Denel implosion

More top stories

Hawks swoop down with more arrests in R1.4-billion corruption blitz

The spate of arrests for corruption continues apace in Gauteng and the Eastern Cape.

Catholic NGO boss accused of racism and abuse in Sudan

The aid worker allegedly called his security guard a ‘slave’

Agrizzi too ill to be treated at Bara?

The alleged crook’s “health emergency” — if that is what it is — shows up the flaws, either in our health system or in our leadership as a whole

SANDF hid R200m expenditure on ‘Covid’ drug it can’t use

Military health officials are puzzled by the defence department importing a drug that has not been approved for treating coronavirus symptoms from Cuba

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday