Why debt is a human rights issue

 

 

COMMENT

The changing nature, profile and level of public debt in some of the Southern African Development Community (SADC) countries has reached alarming and unsustainable levels. As a result, essential services, such as public transport, water infrastructure, education and healthcare, as well as development projects, continue to be severely affected as governments have to use resources to pay off massive amounts of debt.

READ MORE: Double debt risk for African countries that turn to China

The situation became critical as far back as the 1990s, when most of the SADC countries experienced high levels of external debt, reaching a total high point of $62.12-billion in 2001. This was more than 100% of the combined gross domestic product of Angola, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Malawi, Mozambique, Tanzania and Zambia.

READ MORE: Fears of hidden debt in Zambia

It has not been easy for countries to use money intended to improve people’s lives to instead pay the high interest rates associated with these loans; as a result, many have defaulted on their repayments.

Some countries in SADC have benefited from the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative, a programme launched by the World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF) in 1996 to offer debt relief for nations with unsustainable debt burdens. Unfortunately, some of the countries that benefited, such as Zambia, are back in the jaws of unsustainable debt.

In response to the growing problem of indebtedness, SADC adopted a memorandum of understanding on macroeconomic governance in 2011, with the aim of reducing public debt. The memorandum also demanded that governments should be transparent about public resource management. But the results are far from offering confidence to tackle the debt conundrum.


Public debt is a human rights issue because many countries in Southern Africa that owe large amounts of money are failing to deliver on essential public goods and infrastructure. These public services are often captured in bills of rights, thus making them a constitutional obligation rather than a nice to have. Long-term development goals are, therefore, placed at severe risk.

For example, Zimbabwe, with a public debt of more than $18-billion, is in a precarious financial position. It is unable to meet many of its fundamental human rights obligations: people are being turned away from hospitals and essential basic supplies for treating cancer and other serious conditions are lacking.

The dire situation was made even worse when dozens of people died in a 2018 cholera outbreak 10 years after another outbreak killed more than 4 300 people. Such epidemics have been exacerbated by Zimbabwe’s failure to invest in and manage its basic water and sanitation infrastructure and its healthcare system, owing to servicing huge debts, as well as misappropriation of public funds.

Mozambique was plunged into a financial crisis in 2016 after the uncovering of almost $2-billion of “secret” loans, which it was suspected were part of an “illicit enrichment” scheme for politicians and international bankers. There is not much evidence that this money was used to enhance public services, and there are suspicions that a large chunk of it ended up in the pockets of highly connected individuals.

Today the country is broke and is failing to meet its obligations to the public. The government is continuing to borrow from creditors just to keep going. In addition, Cyclone Idai has meant that the country will have an added debt burden of $118.2-million through IMF and other loans.

In Malawi, a recent study found that the country signed more than 80 loan agreements, amounting to $2-billion, between 2007 and 2018. These loans, clouded in secrecy, were mostly taken with bilateral partners such as China and India and the money has not translated into advancements in education, public health and transport. Many Malawians remain desperately poor, surviving from hand to mouth.

Zambia says that its foreign debt stands at $9.4-billion, but analysts believe the number is considerably higher, at about $10.2-billion. Activists who questioned exorbitant levels of government spending have faced persecution.

In addition, Malawi, Mozambique and Zimbabwe were hit in March by Cyclone Idai, one of the most devastating natural disasters on record in the region. At least 1 200 people died and thousands were plunged further into poverty.

Government debt places a huge burden on taxpayers, who ultimately are liable for paying back the money. The concept of paying tax to achieve better public services is defeated when taxes are largely channelled towards servicing loans. At the same time, governments may be forced to cut expenditure on vital services, resulting in a double hit for citizens.

Given the changing nature of debt accumulation — where governments now access loans not only from non-traditional creditors, such as the Paris Club, and from countries such as China, which, according to estimates now holds more than 20% of the $417-billion collective African debt — there are also growing cases of governments accessing loans from commercial sources, further worsening the region’s debt burden. Reports of natural resources being used as collateral for loans have become a new are of concern, with fears that some countries, including Angola, will not maximise the potential of their natural resource wealth as the future is potentially mortgaged.

Governments in the region, together with lending states and international financial institutions, must ensure that the terms of any agreement on debt, including the financial burden of debt servicing, do not compromise states’ ability to allocate the necessary financial and other resources to guarantee economic, social and cultural rights for all their people. This begins with ensuring transparency on the terms and conditions of these loans, as enshrined in the SADC agreement so that we can hold governments, both in the region and beyond, to account.

Deprose Muchena is Amnesty International’s regional director for Southern Africa and spoke at the Southern Africa Debt Conundrum event, recently convened in Johannesburg by the Open Society Initiative for Southern Africa

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Deprose Muchena
Guest Author

Related stories

Students, we will need your critical thinking after the Covid-19 hard reset

Economically disadvantaged students suffer most from disrupted education, but they also have the most to contribute to lessening inequality when we build the new normal

The unbearable sadness of lockdown

Loneliness can seem like a hopeless hole that increases anxiety, depression, fears or thoughts of suicide

Now is the time for true innovation in education and the economy

Because of the government’s indecisiveness, we have missed the boat on charting new territory for learning

Miss Rona’s teaching the 4IR lessons

Schooling is stuck in the 1950s, but technology must be blended with the basics of education

Covid-19 is an opportunity to make our circles bigger

Xenophobia stalks us in this moment of crisis; our hope lies in humanity’s capacity to rebuild

Children will learn under lockdown

Just what they’ll learn or be taught will be outside the curriculum, which may have to happen later
Advertising

Shongweni stink: EnviroServ bosses back in court

Managers charged over landfill emissions want charges set aside

Jailed journalist a symbol of a disillusioned Zimbabwe

Hopewell Chin’ono backed President Emmerson Mnangagwa when he succeeded Robert Mugabe. Now he’s in jail
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday