Conflicting witness evidence in Bongo graft case — Hlophe

Two more state witnesses took the stand in the corruption case against the former state security minister, ANC MP Bongani Bongo, in the high court in Cape Town on Friday. 

Bongani faces charges of corruption relating to allegations that he offered to bribe advocate Ntuthuzelo Vanara, the evidence leader in the parliamentary inquiry into state capture at Eskom, in October 2017. Vanara was allegedly offered a bribe “to collapse the inquiry” into mismanagement at Eskom. 

On the third day of trial, state witnesses advocate Modibedi Phindela, secretary to the National Council of Provinces, and Penelope Tyawa, acting secretary of parliament and head of administration, gave evidence. 

Phindela was approached by Vanara after the alleged phone call by Bongo “to collapse the inquiry” in 2017. After meeting Vanara, Phindela reported the matter to Tyawa as head of administration. After Vanara compiled a report Tyawa handed it over to the executive authorities of parliament for further action. 

Bongo’s legal representative, Michael Hellens, was persistent in the matter of why the witnesses did not report the incident to the police or the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (the Hawks), but instead reported it to parliament. 

Phindela and Tyawa argued that they raised it in a political forum and not as a criminal matter. They said they acted in line with legislation in parliament when they reported the incident.

Hellen argued an error in the affidavit Tyawa signed on 14 August 2018 wherein she refers to Bongo as the minister of intelligence. Hellen said Bongo was relieved from his role as minister of state security on 26 February 2018. 

The Western Cape judge president, John Hlophe, questioned why Tyawa’s evidence sheet did not correspond to her affidavit. In her affidavit of 2018 she wrote, “on 10 October 2017 Mr Vanara said honourable Bongo approached him for corruption” and “he was promised a bribe”. But in her charge sheet she does not include “he was promised a bribe”. 

She attributes it to the time lapse between the affidavit and the charge sheet.

But Hhlophe said she did not mention it during her examination, cross-examination or re-examination. He noted that Phindela said, “he was offered a bribe”, and that he did not make any reference to corruption. Hhlophe then said that Tyawa’s evidence is in conflict with Phindela’s. 

The court adjourned to resume on Monday, 22 February, when the state is expected to close its case after possibly two more witnesses give evidence. 

Outside the court Bongo was met by followers pledging their support for the ANC MP. 

Bongo was relieved from his role as a minister in 2018 after just four months in the position, when incoming President Cyril Ramaphosa chose his new cabinet members. Bongo was arrested by the Hawks in 2020 for a range of charges including fraud, corruption and theft.

Keep the powerful accountable

Subscribe for R30/mth for the first three months. Cancel anytime.

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.

Eunice Stoltz
Eunice Stoltz is a junior daily news reporter at the Mail & Guardian. She was previously a freelance journalist and a broadcaster at Maroela Media and Smile90.4FM.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Kenya to make Covid vaccination mandatory

The unvaccinated will be denied use of public services on 21 December, but only 5% of the population has been vaccinated

Lethal remedy: Concern over African trade in traditional Chinese medicine...

The Environmental Investigation Agency, an international NGO, says growing demand is a prescription for disaster for some endangered animals such as leopards, pangolins and rhinos

Motsepe’s mine in reparation row

For 13 years, the former residents have battled with Nkomati mine over the relocation of graves and the destruction of cattle kraals and homesteads

BMW X3 review: An SA favourite returns with a makeover

The German carmaker gives you a good reason to choose the X3 over its many competitors

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…