To enjoy the full Mail & Guardian online experience: please upgrade your browser
08 Apr 2008 10:26
The top United States general and diplomat in Iraq testify in politically charged hearings in Congress on Tuesday, and face a grilling from three senators vying to inherit the war as the next US president.
General David Petraeus and ambassador to Baghdad Ryan Crocker will appear before the Senate Armed Services and Foreign Relations committees to update progress in the war and President George Bush’s troop-surge strategy.
Their keenly awaited testimony will be especially intriguing as the next US president, Republican John McCain or Democrats Barack Obama or Hillary Clinton, are heavy-hitting members of the two Senate committees.
The hearings represent the latest fierce political tussle over Iraq policy, which has seen anti-war Democrats repeatedly try and fail to force Bush to bring US troops home from the war.
Republicans say the surge of 30Â 000 extra troops into Iraq last year cut sectarian violence and stabilised the country, and they approve of Petraeus’s calls to pause troop withdrawals at pre-surge levels to evaluate the situation.
“If our nation abandoned efforts to stabilise Iraq, not only would terrorism follow our troops home, but it would lead to chaos in the Middle East that would wreak havoc on our national and economic security as well,” John Boehner, the top Republican in the House of Representatives, said on Monday.
A pause in troop withdrawals is likely to be unpopular with the US public, after the US death toll in Iraq passed 4Â 000 and as the conflict stretches into its sixth year.
Democrats praise US troops, but argue their sacrifice has not prompted serious efforts by the Iraqi government to profit from improved conditions to forge political reconciliation.
“They haven’t made the real political progress,” Democratic Senator Jack Reed said on Monday.
“It comes down to the bottom line of, we need a strategy that will clearly shift the burden to the Iraqis, that’ll begin to take the pressure off our forces.”
Hours before the hearings were to start, a draft agreement between the US and Iraq surfaced in London, according to which the two countries foresee an open-ended US military commitment in Iraq.
The document is designed to replace the current United Nations mandate, which expires at year-end, according to the Guardian newspaper, which cited a copy of a draft strategic framework agreement dated March 7 that it obtained.
According to the Guardian, the agreement allows the US to “conduct military operations in Iraq and to detain individuals when necessary for imperative reasons of security” without including a time limit.
Testimony on Iran’s role in Iraq will also be significant on Tuesday.
London’s Daily Telegraph reported that British diplomats feared Petraeus could use his appearance to advocate military action against the Islamic Republic, which Washington accuses of fanning unrest in Iraq.
Democrats argue that the fierce recent clashes between the forces of Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki and militias controlled by radical Shi’ite leader Moqtada al-Sadr show how precarious political gains are.
Both Clinton and Obama have vowed to end the war and bring troops home if they win November’s general election: McCain, a supporter of Bush’s troop surge, says America has a moral duty and strategic imperative to stay and prevent chaos.
“I do not believe that anyone should make promises as a candidate for president that they cannot keep if elected,” McCain said in a speech in Kansas.
“To promise a withdrawal of our forces from Iraq, regardless of the calamitous consequences to the Iraqi people, our most vital interests, and the future of the Middle East, is the height of irresponsibility. It is a failure of leadership,” he said.
Obama hit back that “John McCain was wrong about the war from the beginning, he’s wrong to call for more resources in Iraq while the American people are struggling”.
Clinton said McCain’s policy in Iraq would mean “four more years of the Bush-Cheney-McCain policy of continuing to police a civil war while the threats to our national security, our economy and our standing in the world mount”.
The much-awaited Petraeus and Crocker report follows their last Congress briefing in September, after which Bush announced that five brigades would be pulled out of Iraq by July.
By then the number of US troops in Iraq is set to have dropped to about 130Â 000, from about 160Â 000 at their height earlier this year.
After a full day of testimony, Petraeus and Crocker will testify before House of Representatives committees on Wednesday.—AFP
Create Account | Lost Your Password?