Carbon tax outrage darkens Labor’s future

They call Wollongong “carbon central”, but in Australia’s polarised climate change debate, this mining hub is not central at all, but firmly positioned at one extreme.

Eighty kilometres south of Sydney in New South Wales, the city is home to 300 000 people and millions of tonnes of coal. The steep hills around it afford views of endless queues of ships on the watery horizon, waiting for their cargo of black gold. Coal has been the lifeblood of the city for 150 years and the backbone of its steel industry. In spite of the climate extremes, the droughts, wildfires, cyclones and floods that are ravaging Australia locals do not want to give it up and government plans to introduce a carbon tax have provoked a furious backlash.

“It’s all right for greenies to say this carbon tax has to happen, but we can’t all hug trees for a living,” said Brett Withers, who has worked for 20 years as an industrial cleaning contractor in the steelworks.

“It might just be the straw that breaks the camel’s back. If the tax comes in, this area will be devastated. It’s not just the steel industry, it’s the butcher, the hairdresser and the baker. Everyone will suffer.”

Labor Prime Minister Julia Gillard, who needed support from Greens in a hung Parliament, proposed the levy on pollution.

The idea has divided Australia like no other issue in recent years.

An opinion poll last week showed Gillard’s disapproval rating at 62%. Another survey suggested barely one in four Australians would vote for her, making her government the most unpopular in 40 years.

Cities such as Wollongong have led the assault, as blue-collar voters, who have done well on the back of the mining boom, desert the prime minister in droves.

Australia is the world’s largest producer of iron ore and coal, much of it bound for China’s hungry construction industry. As commodity prices have rocketed, so have profits.

Australia’s commodity export earnings are expected to rise 18%, to a record $270-billion, in the next year. It is an industry that sustains a lot of livelihoods and a lot of voters.

“If the polls as they stand now persist, then Labor will suffer a landslide thrashing in two years’ time,” said Nick Economou, senior lecturer in politics at Melbourne’s Monash University. “They’re in terrible, terrible trouble.”

Gillard is not the first Australian leader to be unsettled by the climate and carbon debate. Her predecessor, Kevin Rudd, dropped his planned emissions trading scheme after failing to get it through Parliament. It was the beginning of the end of his tenure.

In last year’s election campaign Gillard promised there would be no carbon tax if she was elected. But then came the hung Parliament, with a majority of just one. With her political survival suddenly based on support from the Greens, she quickly changed her mind.

Post-election, Gillard set up a multiparty committee to hammer out the details of the carbon tax. The scheme will start with a government-fixed price on carbon, moving to a market-set price after three years. The committee is expected to finalise the details of the tax within days, but negotiations have dragged on for months, further damaging the ­government’s credibility.

Last weekend Gillard announced that petrol would not be included in the tax. But there is still uncertainty about the price of carbon under the scheme, which industries will be hit and what the compensation to households will be.

Many voters have stopped listening to Gillard. The conservative opposition — led by climate sceptic Tony Abbott, who once described the notion of human-induced climate change as “crap” — has capitalised.

Abbott has drilled home a slogan about a “great big new tax on everything” and the message that the carbon tax will hurt ordinary Australians. His party has proposed “direct action” to meet the bipartisan agreed target of reducing CO² emissions by 5% by 2020 (based on 1990 levels). Abbott’s voluntary scheme includes, among other things, planting 20million trees.

Right-wing shock jocks have also pushed the anti-tax message, arguing that whatever Australia does will make little difference to the world’s climate. They have called Gillard “Ju-liar” and launched scathing personal attacks on senior government advisers on climate change.

The growing number of climate change deniers put recent events like this year’s devastating floods in Queensland and the most powerful cyclone in Australia’s history (cyclone Yasi in February 2011 was as powerful as hurricane Katrina) down to freaks of nature rather than climate change.

From his inner-city veggie patch, Sydney resident Greg Bearup despairs at the government’s handling of the carbon-tax debate. “I just can’t see how we went from 60% to 70% support for action on climate change to a position where Gillard looks like she could lose her job over it,” he said.

Bearup’s street is just 15 minutes from the city centre. The area has been gentrified, but remains a concrete jungle of World War I-era houses. Two years ago he and his neighbours dug up the concrete in front of their homes and planted gardens. He says the concrete was acting as a heat bank. Removing it has lowered the temperature in summer, reducing the need for air conditioning.

A carbon tax would make sure polluting industries like mining paid their fair share for the damage they were causing, he said. “Everyone should be making an individual contribution to tackling climate change.” —

Keep the powerful accountable

Subscribe for R30/mth for the first three months. Cancel anytime.

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Montana backs Prasa-fraud accused Mthimkhulu as court hears how he...

Montana testified that ‘unqualified’ Mthimkhulu was the right engineer for the state rail agency, despite his acquisition of allegedly faulty locomotives

The rogue daughter, mounting bills, mum trustees: How Mandela’s artefacts...

The Mandela family saga has not abated: Makaziwe faces criminal charges; trustees, including Moseneke, are silent; and Madiba’s possessions were saved from auction only at the last minute

​​Shrewd management of future Covid waves is key to the...

Stakeholders are cautiously optimistic about 2022, citing relaxed restrictions and discussions with the government as reasons for hope.

‘The Girl in the Yellow Jumper’ is the first Ugandan...

The Ugandan film, directed by Loukman Ali, teaches that the good thing to do is not always the right thing

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…