Spy revelations poison the pond

French outrage at the scale of National Security Agency (NSA) espionage is the latest in a series of aftershocks around the world triggered by Edward Snowden’s revelations about United States and British intelligence that have shaken relations with their allies and partners.

Much of the backlash has been rhetorical, often from countries with well-developed electronic intelligence capabilities of their own, without immediate concrete consequences for political and economic ties.

But there are prominent exceptions to the general rule, and in many ways the knock-on effects for trade and investment relationships, in Europe and beyond, are only now beginning to make themselves felt.

Long-stalled European privacy legislation has been dusted off in the wake of revelations by Snowden – a former NSA contractor now living under temporary asylum in Russia – about the bulk collection of the private phone and internet communications of European consumers, and the targeting of European Union missions in New York and Washington for surveillance.

Brazil has meanwhile made itself a rallying point for global opposition to the long reach of US electronic espionage after it emerged that the NSA had bugged President Dilma Rousseff and her aides, and targeted the state-run oil company, Petrobras.

Rousseff put off a trip to Washington due to have taken place this week and delivered a stinging denunciation of US surveillance from the podium of the UN general assembly in New York last month.

Although the economic and security fallout from the Snowden spy scandal has yet to crystallise fully, there is no doubt that the US and Britain’s soft power, their ability to build alliances on the claim of moral leadership, for example, has suffered a tangible blow.

The initial European reaction to the exposure of the US Prism and the British Tempora programmes was muted. With Prism, the NSA had a window on the everyday internet communications of millions of users of the world’s biggest email and social media service providers.

The Tempora programme, meanwhile, allowed Britain’s Government Communications Headquarters to tap directly into the backbone of the global internet infrastructure, the Transatlantic fibreoptic cables, scooping up phone and internet data from much of the world, including millions of Europeans.

Leaders such as Francois Hollande and Angela Merkel voiced displeasure and unease, but let the matter drop. The German interior minister, Hans-Peter Friedrich, said he accepted US assurances that the spy programmes would not affect ordinary citizens.

In the European Parliament, however, the revelations lit a slow-burning fire. After two years on the shelf, new regulations on European data protection standards have been revived that could impose multibillion-dollar fines on US internet providers if they transfer European data abroad in contravention to European law, which is far stronger on privacy than its US counterpart.

It seems likely the new legislation will further entangle the already complicated negotiations over a new Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership under way between the US and Europe. Both sides had been counting on it for an economic boost.

Ankara reacted furiously to the emergence of documents that the UK had spied on its finance minister and up to 15 others in the Turkish delegation visiting Britain for G20 meetings in 2009, calling the economic espionage operation against a Nato ally “scandalous”.

The UK ambassador was summoned and reprimanded, but there has been little sign of fallout since, in part because both countries have more immediate shared concerns over the fate of Syria.

However, the fact that the government communications headquarters set up internet cafés at the London summit to spy on foreign diplomats has done nothing to enhance its reputation as a reliable host.

The news that Britain had eavesdropped on then-president Dmitry Medvedev at the 2009 G20 summit has done limited long-term harm to the bilateral relationship.

UK-Russian ties were at such a low ebb already, as a consequence of previous spy rows and a deep rift over Syria, that the Medvedev tapping story caused no perceptible ripples.

Brazil qualifies as the most persistently outraged victim of the Western electronic espionage laid bare in the Snowden files. Rousseff’s snub to Obama and her withering indictment of US surveillance at the UN General Assembly was not just a deep embarrassment for Washington but also a significant rift in relations between the biggest economies in the North and South American continents.

Rousseff appears determined that there should be real world consequences for the spy scandal.

She has called for the construction of a national internet infrastructure in Brazil that would not be so vulnerable to foreign tapping, raising the prospect of the fragmentation of the world wide web. She has also summoned a global meeting on internet governance, aimed at diminishing the US’s dominant position as the world’s internet hub.

Brazil’s leadership has brought others along in its wake.

India, which had been muted in its response, this week joined the challenge to US-based internet regulating agencies, such as the International Co-operation for Assigned Names and Numbers, which governs resources like domain names. – © Guardian News & Media 2013

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Julian Borger
Julian Borger
Julian Borger is a British journalist and non-fiction writer. He is the world affairs editor at The Guardian. He was a correspondent in the US, eastern Europe, the Middle East and the Balkans and covered the Bosnian War for the BBC. Borger is a contributor to Center of International Cooperation.

Related stories

Housing activists want probe into City of Cape Town ‘spying’

The City of Cape Town admits it monitors the social-media pages of housing activists but denies that this is spying, as tensions surrounding land occupations increase

Pandemics: A social justice issue

Framing coronavirus as a security threat is not the only possible approach

Steal my data, feed me lies

Snowdon's book tells the world about his work for the US government, and how he grew disaffected with what they were up to

Is your smart city spying on you?

Social and surveillance states underline the need for inclusive tech

Canada takes refugees who sheltered NSA whistle-blower Snowden

Vanessa Rodel and her daughter arrived in Toronto on Monday night after years of harassment in Hong Kong

If the 12 indicted Russians never face trial in the US, can anything be gained?

The indictments are an important step in the effort to determine what happened during the 2016 US elections

Subscribers only

Toxic power struggle hits public works

With infighting and allegations of corruption and poor planning, the department’s top management looks like a scene from ‘Survivor’

Free State branches gun for Ace

Parts of the provincial ANC will target their former premier, Magashule, and the Free State PEC in a rolling mass action campaign

More top stories

Meyiwa murder case postponed amid drama in court

The murder case of Senzo Meyiwa has been postponed to next month after the appearance of the five suspects in the Boksburg magistrate’s court took an unexpected turn

Does the Expropriation Bill muddy the land question even further?

Land ownership and its equitable distribution has floundered. Changes to a section of the constitution and the expropriation act are now before parliament, but do they offer any solution?

Wheeling and dealing for a Covid-19 vaccine

A Covid-19 jab could cost hundreds of rands. Or not. It’s anyone’s guess. Could another pandemic almost a century ago hold clues for handling the coronavirus today?

The European companies that armed the Ivorian civil war

AN OCCRP investigation reveals that Gunvor and Semlex brokered weapons-for-oil deals in early 2011 when Côte d’Ivoire was in crisis, despite a UN arms embargo

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday