/ 16 April 2020

Africa’s Covid-19 response should focus on people’s needs — and rights

Fae087a2 Sudancoronavirus000 1ol01y 696x464
The Covid-19 outbreak should not be used as an occasion to diminish human rights, but as an opportunity to reaffirm them. (Alex McBride/AFP)

The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights  has raised the alarm, calling on March 24 for governments to put human rights at the centre of their fight against Covid-19. The crisis is rapidly spreading across Africa, with more than 15 000 cases reported as of Wednesday April 15.

As Africa intensifies the fight against the virus, there is an urgent need for people-centred interventions that carefully address human rights concerns. Mitigation measures and their integration with human rights vary widely. Several African countries have followed international trends by shutting their borders, imposing stay-at-home orders and, in some cases, enforcing quarantines.

Governments should address the social and economic effects of lockdowns on low-income earners and the unemployed. Kenya announced tax relief and voluntary reduction of salaries of senior state officers. Nigeria is using  an existing  National Social Register to map and identify vulnerable groups for conditional financial help. The Rwandan government has announced  a safety net, including through food distribution in Kigali, although details and any help that might be offered outside the capital remain unclear.

International financial institutions have also taken steps. The World Bank has approved $12-billion in immediate support to reinforce poor countries’ efforts to respond. The African Development Bank raised an exceptional $3-billion bond to alleviate the economic and social effects of Covid-19 on livelihoods. There are numerous campaigns by individuals and organisations in Africa and the African diaspora to  support healthcare workers, and deliver meals and essential items to students and young people in informal settlements.

South Africa, with more testing than elsewhere on the continent, had 2 506 confirmed cases as of April 15, the highest recorded so far in Africa. The authorities have taken steps to limit and prevent the spread of Covid-19, including the declaration of a 21-day national lockdown by President Cyril Ramaphosa, which began on March 26 and has since been extended by two weeks. South Africa’s human settlements, water, and sanitation minister Lindiwe Sisulu announced that her department would increase the provision of water and sanitation measures in high-density public areas, informal settlements and rural areas.

However, some responses, or a lack of response in some cases, have drawn severe condemnation. The Nigerian government’s failure to disclose key details of its cash-transfer programme has raised questions about the criteria for selecting  beneficiaries. In the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Kenya, and Uganda, security forces have used excessive and, in some cases, deadly force to enforce stay-at-home orders. In South Africa, heart-wrenching scenes of police and soldiers rounding up and herding homeless people into a stadium provoked a national outcry; security forces have killed at least nine people while enforcing the lockdown.

In Tanzania, President John Magufuli refused to close down churches on the grounds that the virus is “satanic and therefore cannot thrive in churches”. In Zimbabwe, a Cabinet minister claimed that Covid-19 was not an African disease, but God punishing the West for imposing sanctions on Zimbabwe. Burundi’s government claimed that “the grace of God has protected Burundi” from Covid-19.

Such actions not only undermine African governments’ response to the pandemic, but also violate people’s rights to equal treatment, dignity, access to information, health care, and other necessities. This reduces trust in government institutions and messaging, the key ingredient for achieving compliance with government regulations.

Drawing from past experience

The lessons learned from previous outbreaks of diseases such as Ebola are clear: when rights are blatantly abused, citizens  have no incentive to respond to government appeals to change their behaviour. Behavioural change is one of the best ways of preventing the spread of infections, which in turn would ensure that already strained and inadequate healthcare systems are not overwhelmed. For this to work, trust between citizens and government is crucial.

In its March statement, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights details critical measures that should be incorporated into national Covid-19 response strategies. They include the right to health, access to information and temporary judicial measures to reduce the number of prisoners.

The commission called for solidarity among the private sector, community leaders, the media and religious institutions. The private sector should use their socioeconomic power, influence and resources to promote prevention and containment. The commission said traditional and religious leaders, the media and opinion leaders have a responsibility “for shaping government action, promoting the prevention and containment measures [and] providing relevant information and analysis to the public”/  They should encourage the public to heed scientific advice.

Another critical stakeholder is the African diaspora. The African Union recognises the diaspora as  its sixth region, with systems to enable diaspora bodies to  participate in its structures and decision-making. Diaspora remittances dwarf official development assistance in many African countries, including Ghana, Kenya, and Uganda. During the West African Ebola outbreak of 2014, the African diaspora raised millions of dollars and sent thousands of volunteers to assist the AU Support to Ebola in West Africa, a special mission set up to co-ordinate the African response.

All these partnerships should be rooted in advancing human rights and endeavour to protect the rights of those at high risk of being harmed by the virus or its effects, such as displaced people, migrants, older people, sexual  minorities, women and children. Governments  should focus on community-based approaches to raise awareness, dispel myths, and increase resilience. Artists and social media activists could be enlisted to reach out to people.  Some, like the leading Ugandan opposition politician and singer Bobi Wine, are already using song as a medium for their message.

This is the time for leaders to be ingenious and creative, and to draw lessons from previous efforts to deliver more holistic, rights-driven approaches. The Covid-19 outbreak should not be used as an occasion to diminish rights, but as an opportunity to reaffirm them. AU member states should heed the call of the African Commission and promote a comprehensive, people- and rights-centred response to Covid-19.  

Carine Kaneza Nantulya is the Africa advocacy director and Dewa Mavhinga is the Aouthern Africa director at Human Rights Watch.