The numbers don’t lie: Tito Mboweni must focus on the long game, experts say

Stick to the long game: Hannah Marais

In October, the medium-term budget policy statement painted a dire picture of the state of South Africa’s economy. Against the backdrop of multiple years of weak growth pre-Covid-19, rising unemployment, a sizable fiscal deficit and fast-expanding debt-to-gross-domestic-product ratio, the government will be forced to contend with severely limited budgetary space, and be unable to take the country out of its economic predicament through spending.

The 2021 budget should not deviate from the proposed five-year fiscal consolidation plan. This includes balancing expenditure choices, such as reducing the public-sector wage bill. A significant deviation from the proposed consolidation path could upset markets, dent investor confidence and, at worst, place South Africa on a path towards a debt trap. 

The good news is that there have been green shoots, both in terms of a rebound in economic growth, as well as an overshoot on expected tax receipts in recent months. 

Global tailwinds should also not be discounted — global vaccine distribution, low cost of capital, and rising commodity prices point towards a global growth rebound in 2021. 

Among the immediate challenges is the roll-out of the vaccine. Indeed, the uncertainty around this, weak business and consumer confidence, ongoing structural weaknesses, and possible third and even fourth waves of infections, pose some of the biggest risks to the country’s near-term economic recovery.


Additional borrowing to fund the vaccine roll-out and other programmes to support the economic recovery should be an option because it could see debt increase to unsustainable levels. South Africa has been borrowing R2.1-billion a day, with debt service costs already crowding socioeconomic spending. 

With a supportive economic environment in 2021, raising tax rates might not need to be on the cards. Additional revenues could possibly be raised through “tax-bracket creep” or increasing fuel levies.

Whatever the budget proposals will be, the road to rebuilding South Africa’s economy and stabilising the fiscus will likely be a long one with the need to implement structural reforms even more urgent than before. — Hannah Marais is associate director and insights leader at Deloitte Africa.


Numbers don’t lie: Bonang Mohale

Firstly we must send some top miscreants to prison; secure vaccines; execute on the long-promised deep systemic socio-economic reforms; reduce the soaring government debt and fix the more than 740 state-owned entities and companies. 

We would do well to focus on GDP growth, increase our infrastructure, and execute on the ten-year-old spectrum auction mirage. 

The fiscal crisis is coming, precipitated by the financing crisis. The private capital markets are simply not willing to continuously roll over an ever-growing amount of South African debt. — Bonang Mohale is the chancellor of the University of the Free State and chairman of the Bidvest Group Limited. 

If we, again, waste this opportunity presented by the budget speech 2021, we might as well batten down the  hatchets in preparation for the full sovereign-debt default in a few years. 

In a recent note, Moody’s said that it would likely downgrade South Africa — already two levels below investment grade — further if its debt burden continues to grow. 

Fitch already has the country three levels below investment grade. It is practically impossible to keep on the current trajectory and momentum. Our debt-servicing costs are now R20-billion; our deficit is sitting at 16%. We are forecasting less than 3% gross domestic product (GDP)  growth in 2021 and only in 2024 will we reach the 2019 GDP growth level. 

It will take us up to 10 years to get back to pre-Covid-19 employment levels. Tax revenue projections are at about -18%, and the unemployment rate is about 40%. 

However, ratings agencies are looking for only four things: economic strength; fiscal strength; institutional strength; and susceptibility to event risk. 

Business has been consistent about what needs to be done. The sector argued that the 2020 medium-term budget policy statement would be crucial and would determine our ability to respond to the consequences of Covid-19 and maintain the sustainability of government’s pro-poor and pro-growth policies. The government has great intentions but woefully inadequate execution. 

But how do we address the lowest levels of confidence, trust and hope since World War II? Firstly we must send some top state capture miscreants to prison; secure vaccines; execute on the long-promised deep systemic socioeconomic reforms; reduce the soaring government debt and fix the more than 740 state-owned entities and companies. We would do well to focus on GDP growth, increase our infrastructure, and execute on the 10-year-old spectrum auction mirage. 

The fiscal crisis is looming, precipitated by the financing crisis. Private capital markets are simply not willing to keep rolling over an ever-growing amount of South African debt. — Bonang Mohale is the chancellor of the University of the Free State and chairman of the Bidvest Group


More than belt-tightening needed: Nthabiseng Moleko

An economy with more than 11-million unemployed South Africans, a contracting secondary sector, lacklustre growth and the highest global inequality, yielding further pressure to the treasury in its debt servicing and maintaining a balanced budget. 

You would think this resulted from the Covid-19 economic shock, but a pre-crisis dismal financial performance simply pushed the country further into an economic abyss.

Expectations were high that the reported R500-billion stimulus package would ignite household demand and economic activity. However, output continues to contract, and the job losses haven’t recovered in the last quarter, despite resumed economic activity post-lockdown. 

The timing of interventions and the use of countercyclical fiscal policy has never been more necessary. The only problem is that we in South Africa are still debating whether fiscal policy and fiscal stimulus can help us deal with the economic crisis. 

Yet the rest of the world, through the Asian crisis of the late ’90s and global financial crisis of 2009, saw developing and developed nations practising  Keynesian economics. 

Our fiscal policy seems targeted at mainly pleasing credit-ratings agencies and improving business confidence. Yet the role of the state in developing and financing economic development post-crisis is a necessary condition. It cannot happen without reforming the state’s role in advancing the development objectives of South Africa. 

To privatise state-owned entities and diminish their role in the development trajectory will render the inclusive and redistribution growth path needed a dream. It would only affirm that South Africa’s economic policy is geared towards financialisation, big business and multinationals, and benefits only a small minority.

Macroeconomic policy is far broader. The countercyclical fiscal policy offers fiscal multipliers that will stimulate both supply and aggregate demand during a crisis.

A wealth tax that limits repatriation of funds through profit-shifting and illicit flows should be implemented to encourage long-term investments. This would encourage long-term structural reform to advance a growing manufacturing sector and transform South Africa’s investment pathways. 

If policymakers’ goal is to ensure an inclusive growth path, redistribution, sustainability and equity, ensuring poverty reduction and improved employment, the current macroeconomic policy instruments and the fiscal policy path has shown us unless we change course, we will remain in crisis — a crisis of economic thought, and not only of Covid-19. — Dr Nthabiseng Moleko is a development economist at the University of Stellenbosch Business School.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Hannah Marais
Hannah Marais is associate director and insights leader at Deloitte Africa.
Bonang Mohale
Bonang Mohale is the chancellor of the University of the Free State and chairman of the Bidvest Group
Nthabiseng Moleko
Dr Nthabiseng Moleko is a development economist at the University of Stellenbosch Business School and co-author of the report New Wine In New Wine Skins: An Alternative Economic Strategy for South Africa’s Economic Reconstruction

Related stories

Advertising

Subscribers only

Come what may, the UIF will pay

The fund – the main safety net for unemployed workers – will run at an almost R20-billion deficit

‘Terrorised’ family shines a light on traditional leadership for vulnerable...

The ambiguity between traditional and constitutional leadership has been exposed by the violent banishment of an Eastern Cape family

More top stories

Concourt to hear Zondo commission’s application for contempt order against...

The former president has been one week to file answering papers in the application that also seeks a prison sentence imposed on him

Koko maintains he had no idea he was exchanging emails...

In his four turn on the witness stand, the former Eskom CEO maintains he was tricked into sharing company information with a third party

Zuma foundation claims ex-president was prepared to testify, but Zondo...

Zuma’s namesake organisation twists facts and the law – he told Zondo he would answer questions but only in private to the deputy chief justice

Property developers slap Jo’burg environmentalist and conservancy with R197m lawsuit

Century Property Developments and Riversands Developments are suing for income they have allegedly lost because of objections raised
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…