Drawn Lines: About the place of work in the struggle

An interesting exchange on the relationship between art and South Africa’s liberation politics —  in the form of Athi Mongezeleli Joja’s review of Judy Seidman’s Drawn Lines exhibition and Seidman’s response in an open letter — occurred recently. 

It was notable because South Africa does not have a strong culture of robust discussion and criticality in contemporary art discourse. For this, we can blame the neoliberal commodification of art, which has alienated the artist and placed them in the subject-position of “hustler”, with the critic as “player-hater”. This, by the way, goes for all fields of art. 

As a student of black historiography, I was more interested in this debate’s implications for South African liberation historiography than in formal and aesthetic matters. What follows is  less a defence of Joja; rather, it is a defence of intellectual tradition he speaks from.

After reading Seidman’s response, I was struck by how it seemed as if she had not heard what Joja was saying at all. Instead she mobilised the illustrious names of her black Medu Art Ensemble colleagues and comrades as a sjambok with which to beat the critic — who, at best, is portrayed as a historical revisionist and, at worst, a reactionary.

Her question, “Are you suggesting that people of this stellar calibre passively accepted a working environment in which ‘white people become the default tutors to black people’?”, sounds like a “Who are you to question these struggle icons’ radicality (and, by extension, mine)?” clapback. Seidman’s question is disingenuous if one considers the problematic nature of white-women tutorship of black artists that attends to South African art historiography – which is itself a discipline whose dominance by white women “is especially glaring,” as artist-scholar Sharlene Khan observed in her essay, Doing it for Daddy, in 2011. In this essay, Khan argued that the post-1994 dispensation has seen white women take up positions of leadership in many art institutions, with the white supremacist capitalist patriarchal power structures (to borrow from black feminist theorist bell hooks) remaining intact.

Disparate liberation traditions

Throughout her response, Seidman evinces an ignorance of the various intellectual traditions that have shaped the ideology and strategy of this country’s liberation movements. Her ignorance leads her to assume that the ANC’s approach (to which Medu was aligned) to the national and/or colonial question is the only legitimate one. Joja’s Afro-pessimistic critique of “cultural work” — which Seidman seemingly misreads as a reference to the Marxist Workers’ Tendency of the ANC — invokes a liberation tradition that refuses the notion of work itself because of its instrumentality in colonial-modern governmentality. 

Following the African-American political philosopher and black studies theorist Cedric Robinson, we can refer to this tradition as the Black Radical Tradition. Its actors include runaway slaves from the Cape Colony, amaqaba and the tsotsis of urban South Africa in the 20th century. What connects these seemingly disparate figures is that none of them are afforded proper revolutionary subjectivity in the Marxist framework of the National Democratic Revolution, which informs the ANC’s strategy and tactics.

Seidman’s failure to hear Joja reminded me of African-American historian and writer Saidiya Hartman’s trenchant observation that “the history of black counter-historical projects is one of failure, precisely because these accounts have never been able to install themselves as history, but rather are insurgent, disruptive narratives that are marginalised and derailed before they ever gain a footing.” Joja’s call for us to “refuse to take theories of commitment only at face value” should be heard as a call for counter-histories of the anticolonial struggle that will eschew grand narratives of progress in favour of historical narratives that aim at the recreation of black life.

Njabulo Zwane is a writer and scholar of Black cultural his- and her-stories    

Njabulo Zwane
Njabulo Zwane is a writer and scholar of Black cultural his- and her-stories

De Klerk now admits apartheid was a crime against humanity

Apartheid’s last president walks back comments that definition was a Soviet plot

February 11 1990: Mandela’s media conquest

Nelson Mandela’s release from prison was also South Africa’s first ‘media event’. And, despite the NP’s, and the SABC’s, attempt to control the narrative, the force of Madiba’s personality meant that he emerged as a celebrity

Eastern Cape MEC orders graft investigation after two workers killed...

The killing of two council workers at the Amathole district municipality appears to be linked to tender fraud and corruption

Strike-off case pulls in judge

Judge Mushtak Parker is implicated in an application to strike off his former partners. He is also involved in the fight between the Western Cape high court’s judge president and his deputy

Press Releases

Response to the report of the independent assessors

VUT welcomes the publishing of the report of the independent assessors to investigate concerns of poor governance, leadership, management, corruption and fraud at the university.

NWU student receives international award

Carol-Mari Schulz received the Bachelor of Health Sciences in Occupational Hygiene Top Achiever Award.

Academic programme resumes at all campuses

Lectures, practicals, seminars and tutorials will all resume today as per specific academic timetables.

Strategic social investments are a catalyst for social progress

Barloworld Mbewu enables beneficiaries to move away from dependence on grant funding

We all have a part to play to make South Africa work

Powering societal progress demands partnerships between all stakeholders

So you want to be a social entrepreneur?

Do the research first; it will save money and time later

Social entrepreneurship means business

Enterprises with a cause at their core might be exactly what our economy desperately needs

Looking inwards

Businesses are finding tangible ways to give back – but only because consumers demand it